Middle-School Students’ Reasoning About Alternative Hypotheses in a Scaffolded, Software-Based Inquiry Investigation
Author:
- 13 October 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cognition and Instruction
- Vol. 27 (4) , 277-311
Abstract
The examination of alternative hypotheses can initiate students into scientific practices and equip them with scientific literacy skills that will help them participate in ongoing debates involving complex socio-scientific problems. Hypothesis testing, in which the examination of alternative hypotheses is situated, has received much attention in the literature. However, the topic of alternative hypotheses has not been examined as extensively in scaffolded data-rich instructional interventions. This article contributes to that body of knowledge by reporting on middle-school students’ inquiry practices as they relate to considering alternative hypotheses of their data. Specifically, the article reports a multiple-case study examining six pairs’ reasoning as they try to solve a data-rich, scientific problem, scaffolded by the software investigation, the task setup, and the teacher. The students’ generation and testing of alternative hypotheses was examined through students’ discourse, actions, inquiry products, and interactions with their teacher and peers. Pre–post assessment analyses showed statistically significant learning gains while the analyses of the students’ inquiry discourse and actions indicated that the scaffolding contributed to students’ inquiry. However, several epistemological problems surfaced relating to students’ perception of the usefulness of examining and communicating alternative explanations. These findings indicate the importance of epistemologically targeted discourse alongside guided inquiry experiences, and underline the need for further examination of appropriate scaffolding to support students’ scientific reasoning processes.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Scientific Reasoning in Young Children: IntroductionSwiss Journal of Psychology, 2005
- Theory and data interactions of the scientific mind: Evidence from the molecular and the cognitive laboratory.Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology / Revue canadienne de psychologie expérimentale, 2004
- Conceptual and Epistemic Aspects of Students' Scientific ExplanationsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 2003
- Interpreting experimental data: the views of upper secondary school and university science studentsInternational Journal of Science Education, 2000
- Evaluation of abilities in interpreting media reports of scientific researchInternational Journal of Science Education, 1999
- Inquiry in Project-Based Science Classrooms: Initial Attempts by Middle School StudentsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 1998
- On understanding the nature of scientific knowledgeEducational Psychologist, 1993
- Epistemic forms and Epistemic Games: Structures and Strategies to Guide InquiryEducational Psychologist, 1993
- Appropriating Scientific Discourse: Findings From Language Minority ClassroomsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 1992
- ‘An experiment is when you try it and see if it works’: a study of grade 7 students’ understanding of the construction of scientific knowledgeInternational Journal of Science Education, 1989