Parental obligation and compelled caesarean section: careful analogies and reliable reasoning about individual cases
Authors:
- 22 June 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 47 (4) , 280-286
Abstract
Whether it is morally permissible to compel women to undergo a caesarean section is a topic of longstanding debate. Despite plenty of arguments against the moral permissibility of a forced caesarean section, the question keeps cropping up. This paper seeks to scrutinise a particular moral argument in favour of compulsion: the appeal to parental obligation. We present what we take to be a distillation of the basic form of this argument. We then argue that, in the absence of an exhaustive theory of parental obligation, the question of whether a labouring woman is morally obliged to undergo emergency surgery—and especially the further question of it is morally permissible for third parties to compel this—cannot be answered via ready-made theory. We propose that the most viable option for settling both questions is by analogy. We follow earlier writers in presenting an analogous case—that of fathers being compelled to undergo non-consensual invasive surgery to save their children—but expand the analogy by considering objections that appeal to the ownership of the fetus. We offer two lines of response: (1) the parthood view of pregnancy and (2) chimaera dad. We argue that it is clear in the analogous case that compulsion cannot be justified. We also offer this analogy as a useful tool for assessing whether mothers have a moral duty to undergo caesarean sections, both in general and in particular cases, even if such a duty is insufficient to warrant compulsion.Keywords
Funding Information
- H2020 European Research Council (679586)
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Adoption is Not Abortion‐LiteJournal of Applied Philosophy, 2012
- FINDING AUTONOMY IN BIRTHBioethics, 2008
- Future People, Involuntary Medical Treatment in Pregnancy and the Duty of Easy RescueUtilitas, 2007
- The essence of living parental liver donation – donors’ lived experiences of donation to their childrenPediatric Transplantation, 2004
- An Orwellian Scenario: court ordered caesarean section and women’s autonomyNursing Ethics, 1999
- Moral Agency and the Family: The Case of Living Related Organ TransplantationCambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 1999
- ARE PREGNANT WOMEN FETAL CONTAINERS?Bioethics, 1990
- Court-Ordered Obstetrical InterventionsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1987
- Donation, Surrogacy and AdoptionJournal of Applied Philosophy, 1985
- Law and the Life Sciences: Forced Cesareans: The Most Unkindest Cut of AllHastings Center Report, 1982