Simulation-Based Evaluation of Two Insect Trapping Grids for Delimitation Surveys

Authors:

Abstract
In the United States, delimitation trapping surveys with square grids have been used for decades for exotic insects without rigorous evaluation. We used simulations to investigate the effectiveness of two representative designs: an 8-km grid for Acrolepiopsis assectella (leek moth) and a 14.5-km grid for Ceratitis capitata (Mediterranean fruit fly, “Medfly”). We investigated grid compositions and design factors, measuring performance as the mean probability of pest capture over all traps, p(capture), and designed improved grids for both species. For the basic designs, p(capture) was 0.86 for leek moth and 0.71 for Medfly, with the latter performing better due to greater lure and trap attractiveness. For both designs, 86 percent or more of mean p(capture) came from core area captures. Egress testing indicated that both grids were oversized. An improved grid for leek moths would use 80 traps in a 3.2-km diameter circle: mean p(capture) decreased but total cost was reduced by 91 percent. The best grid for Medfly was a 4.8-km diameter circle grid with 232 traps, which gave mean p(capture) of 0.66 and reduced total costs by 86 percent. Simulation may be used to improve common trapping survey plans, often saving significantly on costs while maintaining survey performance.