BCBarney P. Caton

Barney P. Caton

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Barney P. Caton has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Evaluating the impacts of trap and lure costs and attractiveness on invasive insect trapping designs

    by Lauren Stutts, Barney P. Caton, Hui Fang, Nicholas C. Manoukis, Godshen Robert

    We quantitatively examined the effects of trap and lure costs and attractiveness—which determines densities—on total insect survey costs. We modeled and compared costs for standard and reduced-density designs facilitated either by increased trap attractiveness, or by combining lures in traps. Survey costs were based on supply and replacement, and servicing distances and times. We quantified likelihoods of capture [ p (Capture), survey efficacy] for each design in simulations. In a sensitivity analysis, total costs were most affected by trap density and survey area; trap-and-lure costs and durations were much less important. In a proof-of-concept example, we evaluated the impact of doubled attractiveness or tripled duration for Anastrepha ludens (Mexican fruit fly [Diptera: Tephritidae]). Increased attractiveness facilitated reducing traps by 61% and service distances by 58%, which decreased total costs by 44%. By contrast, increasing lure duration to 90 days in a 90-d survey only reduced costs by 6.5%. We then evaluated three case studies from published research. In two, though trap and lure prices at least doubled, total costs decreased by 42% or more because densities dropped by at least 59%. Moreover, p (Capture) at least doubled. In the third case study, combining three lures in traps reduced total costs by about 14% when attractiveness was unaffected, but when attractiveness declined, requiring greater densities, total costs increased 1.5 times. Incorporating traps with greater attractiveness usually reduced total costs and sometimes increased p (Capture). These examples demonstrate how to quantitatively assess trapping costs and survey efficacy to generate more optimal designs.

  • Open Access

    Evaluating a Risk-Based Sampling Inspection Programme on Mexican Produce Imported on Trucks to the United States of America

    by Barney Caton, Scott Blackwood, Bruce Cheong, Ernie Hain, Darlene Judd, Alison Neeley, Jason Neil, Craig Noble, Jacob Rodler, Irma Rodriquez

    We evaluated a risk-based sampling (RBS) inspection programme in a real-world trial with dynamic inspection frequencies on Mexican produce imported by truck through land border ports. The commodities were avocado, celery, papaya, and broccoli+cauliflower (combined). Some commodities were managed by region (Texas, or Arizona/California). Results were from September, 2018, to December, 2020, with trial lengths of either 27 (avocado and celery) or 19 months (others). Pest action rates, inspection rates, and leakage rates (acceptance of infested lots) were compared before and during the trial, and we estimated monthly time savings with RBS. Mean action rates were unchanged for three commodity-region combinations but increased significantly in three of the other four combinations. Inspection rates were consistently very low for avocado and papaya but were more variable for broccoli+cauliflower and celery. Estimated leakage rates were similar before and during the trial but were universally low (0.7 percent at most). Mean annual total inspection times increased by 21 percent for celery because reductions did not offset increases due to hypergeometric sampling, but over all commodities RBS gave 28 percent savings. This reduced-frequency RBS programme seemed well suited to broader application to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of agricultural safeguarding for imported fruits and vegetables.


  • Open Access

    Evaluating a novel core-and-perimeter delimiting trapping survey design for insects. I. Field experiment

    by Barney P Caton, Hui Fang, Ernie Hain, Nadya Kandel, Rosalie Nelson, Godshen R Pallipparambil, Nicholas C Manoukis

    We propose a novel “core-and-perimeter” delimiting trapping design for invasive insects, improving upon the ubiquitous fully trapped square grids using regular spacing. The core-and-perimeter design has traps near the epicenter and in a perimeter set at a distance to result in zero captures, to directly set the population boundary. We compared the core-and-perimeter and fully trapped designs in a mark–release–recapture experiment with Ceratitis capitata (Weidemann) (Diptera: Tephritidae) in Hawaii in 2022. Each design had 4 repetitions with 4 separate releases of flies and 6 collection days from 1 to 14 d after release. The square fully trapped grid had 20 core area traps plus 79 other traps in 0.92 km2, plus 24 “sentinel” traps beyond. The circular core-and-perimeter grid had 20 core traps, and 108 traps in a 220 m-wide perimeter, set 500 m from the release point (smaller than the recommended radius). Slightly more flies on average were captured in the fully trapped treatment but proportional captures in common locations were similar. Flies were caught in the sentinel traps in every replicate of the fully trapped treatment. Four percent of captures occurred in the perimeter of the core-and-perimeter treatment on average. Trap usage rate for the fully trapped design was 67%, while for the core area of the core-and-perimeter design was nearly 94%. Overall mean daily dispersal distance was 96.3 m, and the regression-based 99th percentile of total distance was 700 m. Results supported the potential of the core-and-perimeter design and demonstrated 2 fully trapped design disadvantages—trap inefficiency and egress potential.


  • Open Access

    Customized and rapid observational delimiting surveys for plant pests based on transect data and scouting

    by Barney P. Caton, Godshen R. Pallipparambil, Hui Fang

    We have created a complete, standard methodology for designing customized observation-based delimiting surveys for localized incursions of non-endemic plant pests. We propose using transects customized for the species and situation to do the following: Collect data for ∼120 detections Fit an exponential function to the histogram using an extreme values analysis peaks-over-threshold (EVA POT) technique Calculate a percentile-based boundary distance that accounts for two-dimensional (radial) spread Use field scouting for verification We call the approach “Delimitation via Transect Data and Scouting,” or DTDS. In simulations we compared DTDS plans to published survey plans for the Asian longhorned beetle (ALB; Anoplophora glabripennis (Motschulsky)), the fungus Phyllosticta citricarpa (Guigci), and the tomato brown rugose fruit virus (TBRFV; Tobamovirus). The EVA POT method avoided problems with highly skewed data, and ninety-ninth percentile boundary estimates from it that accounted for radial dispersal always contained the adventive populations. Based on sample sizes, time required, and success (containment) rates the DTDS surveys were efficient and effective. For ALB and TBRFV, DTDS surveys reduced sample sizes and durations by 77 percent or more. For P. citricarpa , the DTDS design greatly increased the sample area, but eliminated 6% (scenario 1) and 68% (scenario 2) failure rates in the original plan. The DTDS methodology synthesizes established techniques in a novel way, providing a standardized, clear, and often rapid process for designing customized, transect-based observation-based delimitation surveys that are both efficient and effective. The approach has clear management and financial benefits, and should facilitate quicker, improved decision making. Key messages: DTDS is a customizable delimitation survey design method based on transect sampling and scouting Transects designed to produce ∼120 positives facilitate efficient sampling of incursion areas Boundaries can be accurately determined with uncertainty using extreme values analysis of the distance data Case studies demonstrated that using DTDS always contained incursions and often greatly reduced survey effort

  • Evaluating a novel core-and-perimeter delimiting trapping survey design for insects. II. Simulations and case studies

    by Barney P Caton, Nicholas C Manoukis, Godshen R Pallipparambil, Rosalie Nelson, Ernie Hain, Hui Fang

    We compared 2 delimitation trapping designs via mark–release–recapture of Ceratitis capitata Weidemann (Medfly) [Tephritidae: Diptera]: a fully trapped grid versus a novel, “core-and-perimeter” design. Results showed some disadvantages of fully trapped and supported the core-and-perimeter concept, but grids were too small to address all questions. Here we used computer models to more fully compare the designs. We employed random walk dispersal using parameters from recent results for another Dipteran. Parameter sensitivity was highest for maximum step distance (DDay), but structural sensitivity was more affected by dispersal probability (PDisp) and correlated movement (θMax). We incorporated trapping, modeling capture probabilities based on the hyperbolic secant function. We quantified the likelihood of inner traps to “intercept” insects along their paths and implemented that process in all trapping models. Validation against 3 independent datasets was successful using PDisp of 0.4 or 0.3, and θMax = 180°, based on dispersal densities and proportion of flies captured. Under the validated dispersal model, Medflies never traveled more than 2.8 km in 30 d. A trapping version gave zero perimeter captures with the core-and-perimeter design, but core area captures in 40% of iterations for single flies. The fully trapped grid captured flies in 79% of iterations but only 12% of traps had captures, indicating suboptimal efficiency. Finally, we compared fully trapped and core-and-perimeter trapping costs using published plans for Medfly and four other species. The costs of the core-and-perimeter designs were 49% to 77% lower at standard sizes but 69% to 88% lower with optimal (shorter) radii.


  • Open Access

    Transect-based trapping for area-wide delimitation of insects

    by Barney P Caton, Hui Fang, Godshen R Pallipparambil, Nicholas C Manoukis

    Typical delimitation trapping survey designs for area-wide (nonlocalized) insect populations are regularly spaced grids, and alternative shapes have not been evaluated. We hypothesized that transect-based designs could give similar detection rates with significantly shorter servicing distances. We used the TrapGrid model to investigate novel “trap-sect” designs incorporating crossed, spoked, and parallel lines of traps, comparing them to a regular grid, in single survey and multiple-site scenarios. We calculated minimum servicing distances and simulated mean probabilities of detecting a pest population, judging overall performance of trap network designs using both metrics. For single sites, trap-sect designs reduced service distances by 65–89%, and most had similar detection probabilities as the regular grid. Kernel-smoothed intensity plots indicated that the best performing trap-sect designs distributed traps more fully across the area. With multiple sites (3 side by side), results depended on insect dispersal ability. All designs performed similarly in terms of detection for highly mobile insects, suggesting that designs minimizing service distances would be best for such pests. For less mobile pests the best trap-sect designs had 4–6 parallel lines, or 8 spokes, which reduced servicing distances by 33–50%. Comparisons of hypothetical trap-sect arrays to real program trap locations for 2 pests demonstrated that the novel designs reduced both trap numbers and service distances, with little differences in mean nearest trap distance to random pest locations. Trap-sect designs in delimitation surveys could reduce costs and increase program flexibility without harming the ability to detect populations.


  • Open Access

    Wood borer detection rates on wood packaging materials entering the United States during different phases of ISPM 15 implementation and regulatory changes

    by Robert A. Haack, Jesse A. Hardin, Barney P. Caton, Toby R. Petrice

    Wood packaging material (WPM) used in international trade, such as crating and pallets, is recognized as a high-risk pathway for the introduction of bark- and wood-infesting insects (borers). The International Standards for Phytosanitary Measures No. 15 (ISPM 15), which sets treatment requirements for WPM, was adopted in 2002. The United States (US) implemented ISPM 15 during 2005–2006. We used 2003–2020 AQIM (Agriculture Quarantine Inspection Monitoring, conducted by USDA APHIS) data, based on standard random sampling, to compare pre-ISPM 15 borer detection rates in WPM entering the US (2003–2004) to detection rates during 2005–2006 (implementation phase), 2007–2009 (post-ISPM 15 when bark was not regulated) and 2010–2020 (post-ISPM 15 when bark was regulated). We examined borer detection rates overall for all AQIM WPM records and individually for the three main cargo survey programs within AQIM [Italian tiles, perishables, and general WPM (GWPM) for any WPM associated with containerized maritime imports], and individually for three major US trading partners (China, Italy, and Mexico). During 2003–2020, wood borers were detected in 180 of 87,571 consignments with WPM (0.21%). When compared to 2003–2004 (detection rate of 0.34%), detection rates fell 61% during 2005–2006, 47% during 2007–2009, and 36% during 2010–2020. Similar declines occurred for WPM associated with Italian tiles and perishables. However, for GWPM there was no significant reduction post-ISPM 15. WPM infestation rates were reduced significantly during various post-ISPM 15 periods for Italy and Mexico, but not for China. Seven families or subfamilies of borers were recorded in WPM with Cerambycidae and Scolytinae being most frequent. The incidence of WPM with bark fell significantly after the 2009 change to ISPM 15 that required debarked WPM. We discuss several factors that could influence the apparent effectiveness of ISPM 15.


  • Open Access

    Simulation-based evaluation of two insect trapping grids for delimitation surveys

    by Hui Fang, Barney P. Caton, Nicholas C. Manoukis, Godshen R. Pallipparambil

    In the United States of America, delimitation trapping surveys with square grids have been used for decades for exotic insects without rigorous evaluation. We used simulations to investigate the effectiveness of two representative designs: an 8-km grid for Acrolepiopsis assectella (leek moth) and a 14.5-km grid for Ceratitis capitata (Mediterranean fruit fly, “Medfly”). We investigated grid compositions and design factors, measuring performance as the mean probability of pest capture over all traps, p(capture), and designed improved grids for both species. For the standard designs, p(capture) was 0.86 for leek moth and 0.71 for Medfly, with the latter performing better due to greater lure and trap attractiveness. For both designs, 86 percent or more of mean p(capture) came from core area captures. Egress testing indicated that both grids were oversized. An improved grid for leek moths would use 177 traps in a 4.8-km diameter circle, which had mean p(capture) = 0.73 and reduced the cost by 80 percent. The best Medfly grid was a 4.8-km diameter circle with 232 traps, which gave mean p(capture) of 0.66 and reduced the cost by 86 percent. Simulation may be used to improve trapping survey plans, often saving significantly on costs while maintaining survey performance.


  • Open Access

    Simulation-Based Evaluation of Two Insect Trapping Grids for Delimitation Surveys

    by Barney Caton, Hui Fang, Nicholas Manoukis, Godshen Pallipparambil

    In the United States, delimitation trapping surveys with square grids have been used for decades for exotic insects without rigorous evaluation. We used simulations to investigate the effectiveness of two representative designs: an 8-km grid for Acrolepiopsis assectella (leek moth) and a 14.5-km grid for Ceratitis capitata (Mediterranean fruit fly, “Medfly”). We investigated grid compositions and design factors, measuring performance as the mean probability of pest capture over all traps, p(capture), and designed improved grids for both species. For the basic designs, p(capture) was 0.86 for leek moth and 0.71 for Medfly, with the latter performing better due to greater lure and trap attractiveness. For both designs, 86 percent or more of mean p(capture) came from core area captures. Egress testing indicated that both grids were oversized. An improved grid for leek moths would use 80 traps in a 3.2-km diameter circle: mean p(capture) decreased but total cost was reduced by 91 percent. The best grid for Medfly was a 4.8-km diameter circle grid with 232 traps, which gave mean p(capture) of 0.66 and reduced total costs by 86 percent. Simulation may be used to improve common trapping survey plans, often saving significantly on costs while maintaining survey performance.

  • Quantifying insect dispersal distances from trapping detections data to predict delimiting survey radii

    by Barney P. Caton, Hui Fang, Nicholas C. Manoukis, Godshen R. Pallipparambil

    The spread potential of invasive pests is a major concern for delimitation, quarantine and eradication efforts. We analysed trapping survey detections data for five insects and one low‐dispersing mollusc to quantify 30‐day dispersal kernels (mean total distance [MTD], m). We hypothesized that MTD would increase with species’ reported diffusion coefficients (D, m2 per day), and that D could be used to predict containment radius lengths for delimiting surveys for exotic pests. We collected trapping data for the following six invasive pest species: European grapevine moth (EGVM; Lobesia botrana [Denis & Schiffermüller]), Giant African land snail (GALS; Lissachatina fulica [Bowdich]), Japanese beetle (JB; Popillia japonica [Newman]), Mediterranean fruit fly (Medfly; Ceratitis capitata [Wiedemann]), Mexican fruit fly (Mexfly; Anastrepha ludens [Loew]) and Oriental fruit fly (OFF; Bactrocera dorsalis [Hendel]). We used K‐means clustering to group detections that were proximate in space and time, then finalized them manually. We calculated MTD from the cluster centroid for each detection. Probability histograms for MTD were fit to a two‐parameter exponential function, and from those functions we estimated species’ dispersal limits for four percentiles (99th to 99.99th). The least vagile species, GALS and EGVM, had the greatest decay rates, and smallest MTD and percentile distances. OFF, with the greatest reported D, had the smallest decay rates and greatest MTD and percentile distances. Medfly, Mexfly and JB had intermediate MTD and percentile distances. Each regression of percentile distance as a logarithmic function of D fit the data well. The best regression used adjusted 99.9th percentile distances. These empirical results indicated that many delimiting surveys currently in use are oversized; adopting the new recommendations could yield significant cost savings. These results could be a general solution for estimating delimiting survey radii (for durations of ca. 30 days) across a wide range of insect dispersal abilities.