The Development of Interpretations of Structured, Systematic and Massive Violations in the 2024 Regional Head Elections
Open Access
- 19 August 2026
- journal article
- Published by Universitas Mataram in Jurnal IUS Kajian Hukum dan Keadilan
- Vol. 14 (2) , 422-455
Abstract
This study examines the development of the Constitutional Court’s interpretation of Structured, Systematic, and Massive (TSM) violations in the settlement of disputes arising from the 2024 Regional Head Election. The analysis is grounded in theory of judicial interpretation, constitutional justice, and substantive justice to explain the Court’s evolving constitutional reasoning in safeguarding electoral integrity. This research employs doctrinal legal research using statutory and case approaches, analysing forty Constitutional Court decisions concerning 2024 Regional Head Election disputes that proceeded to the evidentiary hearing stage. The study finds that the Constitutional Court’s interpretation of TSM violations has evolved from a predominantly vote-count-oriented assessment toward a broader constitutional evaluation of whether serious electoral violations substantially affected the integrity and legitimacy of election results. Rather than disregarding vote calculation, the Court treated proven TSM violations as constitutionally relevant where they distorted the fairness of the electoral process and ultimately affected the validity of election outcomes. This development reflects a shift from a predominantly procedural approach toward a model of constitutional justice that places greater emphasis on substantive justice in election dispute adjudication. The Court also recognised new forms of TSM violations, including the involvement of high-ranking state officials, the mobilisation of village heads, violations of the cooling-off period applicable to former convicts, falsification of administrative documents, and violations of constitutional term limits. This study contributes to the development of constitutional jurisprudence on TSM violations and provides a normative framework for strengthening the future settlement of regional election disputes in Indonesia.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- From Justice to Politics: The Constitutional Court’s Role in Structured and Systematic Election ViolationsLex Scientia Law Review, 2025
- Establishment of Electoral Court in Indonesia: Problems and Future ChallengesJournal of Indonesian Legal Studies, 2023
- Roles of justice courts: settlement of general election administrative disputes in IndonesiaHeliyon, 2022
- Study of the Verdict of Constitutional Court on Regional Leaders Election Dispute in the Province of East Nusa Tenggara in 2018Journal of Law and Legal Reform, 2022
- Multilayered Oversight: Electoral Administration in IndonesiaAsian Journal of Comparative Law, 2021
- Limitations to subnational authoritarianism: Indonesian local government head elections in comparative perspectiveRegional & Federal Studies, 2021
- Competing not complementing: KPU, Bawaslu, and the dynamic of election monitoring in PEMILU 2019Asian Journal of Political Science, 2020
- Unconstitutional Authority of Indonesia's Constitutional Court: The Resolution of Pilkada Result DisputesElection Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy, 2019
- The Elimination of Constitutional Court's Authority in The Dispute Case of General Election of Regional Head (Analysis of Decision of the Constitutional Court Number 97/PUU-XI/2013)JURNAL CITA HUKUM, 2017
- Normative and Empirical Research Methods: Their Usefulness and Relevance in the Study of Law as an ObjectProcedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2016