MAMohammad Syaiful Aris

Mohammad Syaiful Aris

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Mohammad Syaiful Aris has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Development of Interpretations of Structured, Systematic and Massive Violations in the 2024 Regional Head Elections

    by Mohammad Syaiful Aris, Muwaffiq Jufri, Ousu Mendy, Abdul Wachid Habibullah, Paul Atagamen Aidonojie

    This study examines the development of the Constitutional Court’s interpretation of Structured, Systematic, and Massive (TSM) violations in the settlement of disputes arising from the 2024 Regional Head Election. The analysis is grounded in theory of judicial interpretation, constitutional justice, and substantive justice to explain the Court’s evolving constitutional reasoning in safeguarding electoral integrity. This research employs doctrinal legal research using statutory and case approaches, analysing forty Constitutional Court decisions concerning 2024 Regional Head Election disputes that proceeded to the evidentiary hearing stage. The study finds that the Constitutional Court’s interpretation of TSM violations has evolved from a predominantly vote-count-oriented assessment toward a broader constitutional evaluation of whether serious electoral violations substantially affected the integrity and legitimacy of election results. Rather than disregarding vote calculation, the Court treated proven TSM violations as constitutionally relevant where they distorted the fairness of the electoral process and ultimately affected the validity of election outcomes. This development reflects a shift from a predominantly procedural approach toward a model of constitutional justice that places greater emphasis on substantive justice in election dispute adjudication. The Court also recognised new forms of TSM violations, including the involvement of high-ranking state officials, the mobilisation of village heads, violations of the cooling-off period applicable to former convicts, falsification of administrative documents, and violations of constitutional term limits. This study contributes to the development of constitutional jurisprudence on TSM violations and provides a normative framework for strengthening the future settlement of regional election disputes in Indonesia.

  • Open Access

    Status Kewarganegaraan Bagi Anak (Intended Parents Embryo) Warga Negara Indonesia Menggunakan Mekanisme Gestational Surrogacy

    by Abdulloh Adi, Syaiful Aris

    Assistive Reproductive Technology (ART) is contained in Article 58 of Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health which only recognizes the IVF process, and implicitly prohibiting about Gestational Surrogacy and impact on sitizenship status without paying attention to the principle of legality. The aim of this research is to determine the impact of differences in Gestational Surrogacy procedure arrangements on citizenship status, especially for granting Indonesian citizenship from thet procedure. This writing method is normative legal research using a conceptual approach and a statutory regulatory approach. The result of this research is that there is a causal impact of differences in the settings of Gestational Surrogacy procedures with citizenship status, where in several countries children resulting from Gestational Surrogacy have stateless status. In Indonesia itself, children resulting from this procedure still have Indonesian citizenship status. However, it must be the status of an illegitimate child


  • Open Access

    A Chance to Defend Regional Heads in The Procedure of Regional Head Dismissal as A Manifestation of The Proportionality Principle

    by Mohammad Syaiful Aris, Iqbal Fauzurrahman, Bagus Oktafian Abrianto, Xavier Nugraha, Stefania Arshanty Felicia

    The existence of regional autonomy in Indonesia is implemented through regional leaders who have the authority to run local government. When carrying out their duties, regional leaders are supervised by other state institutions as a form of checks and balances in government power. Hence, the procedure to dismiss regional leaders regulates to involve the Regional People's Representative Assembly, the Supreme Court, and the President through the Minister of Home Affairs as a form of right to dismiss. However, the existence of the proportionality principle in the procedure to dismiss regional leaders, through the right given to regional leaders to defend themselves, has yet to be regulated in the law. This article talks about two things: first, the procedure to dismiss regional leaders, and second, the legal consequences and the position of a chance to summon regional leaders to explain and defend themselves in the procedure to dismiss regional leaders. This article aims to find the importance of proportionality principles in the procedure to dismiss regional leaders. The method used in this article is legal research, with statutes, conceptual, and case approaches. The results of this research show that although the procedure to dismiss regional leaders has been regulated in law, applying the proportionality principle only exists in jurisprudences. Hence, an ius constituendum is needed to determine legal consequences and certainty regarding the procedure to dismiss regional leaders.


  • Open Access

    THE BLOCKCHAIN-BASED ON E-VOTING IN THE LOCAL ELECTIONS SYSTEM: AN EFFORT TO REALIZE E-DEMOCRACY

    by Mohammad Syaiful Aris, Dita Elvia Kusuma Putri, Gio Arjuna Putra, Xavier Nugraha

    E-voting in post-conflict local elections is still a long debate. One of the reasons is related to the security problem e-voting. Over time, system blockchain born which is known unhackable. Therefore, will analyze, first, urgency using e-voting in post-conflict local election system and secondly the formulation use of blockchain-based e-voting in the post-conflict local election system. The method research is legal research with statute approach, conceptual approach, and case approach. As for the results of the study: first, urgency using blockchain in regional head election system, because there are still many problems, namely: 1) Multiple voter data which results in voters being able to vote more than one time, 2) There are still ballots that have been voted, due irresponsible persons, 3) Distribution of ballot boxes and ballots have problems both before and after voting, and 4) Many post-conflict local election officers died and got sick due to fatigue while on duty, and secondly, the formulation use blockchain in electronic-based regional head election system, must considered: 1) review readiness of districts/cities, 2) Making rules with stakeholders, 3) Resource training humans, 4) Socialization to the community, 5) The implementation is carried out systematically tiered, 6) Implement pilot project before implemented.


  • Open Access

    Pembentukan Peradilan Khusus Penyelesaian Hasil Pemilihan Kepala Daerah dalam Pelaksanaan Pemilu Serentak Nasional

    by Mohammad Syaiful Aris

    The urgency of establishing a special court for resolving election disputes because this special court is an order of Law Number 8 of 2015 which must be formed before the implementation of the national simultaneous regional elections in 2024. Although, in its development, The Constitutional Court Decision Number 85/PUU-XX/2022, the Constitutional Court has the authority to examine and adjudicate cases of disputes over election results are no longer limited to “until the establishment of a special judicial body”, but will be permanent, because such a special judicial body will no longer be formed. However, this is considered less than ideal. This study aims to outline the urgency of a special judiciary for the resolution of regional head election results in the implementation of national simultaneous elections using conceptual and statutory approaches. The results showed that it is necessary to establish a special judicial model for national simultaneous elections, which is a special judiciary that is ad hoc under the general judicial environment of the Supreme Court. For the seat of the special judiciary for dispute resolution, the regional elections are placed on the High Court to resolve disputes over the results of elections in the province as is the model of the corruption court based in the provincial capital so that the budget for the establishment and management of this special judiciary is not too large. Keywords: Election; Election Law; Special Courts for Regional Head Elections. AbstrakUrgensi pembentukan peradilan khusus penyelesaian sengketa pilkada karena peradilan khusus ini merupakan perintah Undang-Undang Nomor 8 Tahun 2015 yang harus dibentuk sebelum pelaksanaan Pilkada serentak nasional tahun 2024. Walaupun, dalam perkembangannya Putusan MK Nomor 85/PUU-XX/2022, Mahkamah Konstitusi berwenang memeriksa dan mengadili perkara perselisihan hasil pemilihan tidak lagi terbatas hanya “sampai dibentuknya badan peradilan khusus”, melainkan akan bersifat permanen, karena badan peradilan khusus demikian tidak lagi akan dibentuk. Tetapi, hal tersebut dirasa kurang ideal. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menguraikan urgensi peradilan khusus penyelesaian hasil pemilihan kepala daerah dalam pelaksanaan pemilu serentak nasional dengan menggunakan pendekatan konseptual dan perundang-undangan. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa perlu dibentuk suatu model peradilan khusus untuk pemilu serentak nasional, yang merupakan sebuah Peradilan khusus yang bersifat ad hoc di bawah lingkungan peradilan umum pada Mahkamah Agung. Untuk tempat kedudukan Peradilan khusus penyelesaian sengketa Pilkada diletakan pada Peradilan Tinggi untuk menyelesaikan sengketa hasil pilkada di wilayah propinsi tersebut sebagaimana model pengadilan tindak pidana korupsi yang berkedudukan di ibukota propinsi sehingga anggaran untuk pendirian dan pengelolaan peradilan khusus ini tidak terlalu besar. Kata Kunci: Pemilu; Hukum Pemilu; Peradilan Khusus Hasil Pemilihan Kepala Daerah.


  • Open Access

    Opportunities and Challenges in the Implementation of Plurality - Majority (District) Electoral System for Strengthening the Indonesian Presidential System

    by Mohammad Syaiful Aris

    Presidential government system has its own disadvantages, one of them is the possibility a minority president presence in this system, namely a president who is not supported by a parliamentary majority, even though the President has a strong mandate from public, but with a minority position, the government’s agenda which carried out by the president could be hampered by parliament or the legislature, therefore it is needed a coalition government. The combination of a presidential system with a multi-party system is difficult to implement because whoever the president is elected will be encountered with a certain condition that it is impossible to support him in parliament without forming a coalition. In order to respond the problem in strengthening the presidential system in Indonesia, the author offers a majority general election system or district system (first Past the Post) as an effort to create an effective and responsible government. This is a legal study which used two approaches, namely statutory approach and conceptual approach. Based on the results of study, it can be concluded that the majority system was more appropriate for creating an effective and responsible government because it could encourage the simplification of political parties and the responsibilities of people’s representatives to the voters in each district.