Making Space for Serendipity and Surprise: Re‐Imagining Open Science Practices in Psychological Research
Open Access
- 20 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Social and Personality Psychology Compass
- Vol. 20 (10) , e70185
Abstract
Open science practices, particularly preregistration, have become central to efforts to improve transparency, reproducibility, and rigor in psychological research. At the same time, concerns have emerged that these practices may narrow opportunities for serendipity and surprise, which are critical elements in scientific discovery. In this article, we examine how methodological traditions and research norms shape the conditions under which serendipity and surprise enter the research process. We argue that constraints on discovery arise from the interaction of two reinforcing dynamics: methodological designs that structure what can be observed, and researcher‐centered processes that shape how research questions are generated and interpreted. Building on this analysis, we propose a reconceptualization of preregistration as a system that can be refined to better support discovery while preserving transparency. We outline four reforms—foregrounding uncertainty, documenting discovery processes, supporting responsiveness to unexpected findings, and expanding epistemic scope—and identify practices that create clearer pathways for engaging with unanticipated observations. Together, these reforms can strengthen psychological science by creating greater opportunity for unexpected observations and perspectives to generate new questions, explanations, and directions for research.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- A registered report survey of open research practices in psychology departments in the UK and IrelandBritish Journal of Psychology, 2024
- Positionality Statements as a Function of Coloniality: Interrogating Reflexive MethodologiesInternational Studies Quarterly, 2024
- Towards a Theory of Serendipity: A Systematic Review and ConceptualizationJournal of Management Studies, 2022
- APA Multicultural Guidelines executive summary: Ecological approach to context, identity, and intersectionality.American Psychologist, 2019
- The preregistration revolutionProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2018
- Serendipity: Towards a taxonomy and a theoryResearch Policy, 2018
- The Center for Open Science Cultivates Openness, Integrity, and ReproducibilityCollege & Undergraduate Libraries, 2015
- Creativity in Science2004
- Three principles of Serendip: insight, chance, and discovery in qualitative researchInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 1996
- Naturalistic inquiryInternational Journal of Intercultural Relations, 1985