Global Evidence on the Sustainability of Telemedicine in Outpatient and Primary Care During the First 2 Years of the COVID-19 Pandemic: Scoping Review Using the Nonadoption, Abandonment, Scale-Up, Spread, and Sustainability (NASSS) Framework
Authors:
- Daniela ValdesDVDaniela Valdes
- Ankit ShankerASAnkit Shanker
- Ghofran HijaziGHGhofran Hijazi
- Daniel Opoku MensahDMDaniel Opoku Mensah
- Tahir BockarieTBTahir Bockarie
- Ioana LazarILIoana Lazar
- Siti Aishah IbrahimSISiti Aishah Ibrahim
- Hamid ZolfaghariniaHZHamid Zolfagharinia
- Rob ProcterRPRob Procter
- Rachel SpencerRSRachel Spencer
- Jeremy DaleJDJeremy Dale
- Armina PauleAPArmina Paule
Open Access
- 28 February 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Interactive Journal of Medical Research
- Vol. 14 (1) , e45367
Abstract
Background: The rapid implementation of telemedicine during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic raises questions about the sustainability of this intervention at the global level. Objective: This research examines the patient experience, health inequalities, and clinician-patient relationship in telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic’s first 2 years, aiming to identify sustainability factors. Methods: This study was based on a prepublished protocol using the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology for scoping reviews. We included academic and gray literature published between March 2020 and March 2022 according to these criteria: (1) population (any group); (2) concepts (patient experience, clinician-patient relationship, health inequalities); (3) context (telemedicine in primary and outpatient care); (4) excluding studies pertaining to surgery, oncology, and (inpatient) psychiatry. We searched Ovid Medline/PubMed (January 1, 2022), Web of Science (March 19, 2022), Google/Google Scholar (February and March 2022), and others. The risk of bias was not assessed as per guidance. We used an analysis table for the studies and color-coded tabular mapping against a health care technology adoption framework to identify sustainability (using double-blind extraction). Results: Of the 134 studies that met our criteria, 49.3% (66/134) reported no specific population group. Regarding the concepts, 41.8% (56/134) combined 2 of the concepts studied. The context analysis identified that 56.0% (75/134) of the studies referred to, according to the definition in the United Kingdom, an outpatient (ambulatory care) setting, and 34.3% (46/134) referred to primary care. The patient experience analysis reflected positive satisfaction and sustained access during lockdowns. The clinician-patient relationship impacts were nuanced, affecting interaction and encounter quality. When mapping to the nonadoption, abandonment, scale-up, spread, and sustainability (NASSS) framework, 81.3% (109/134) of the studies referenced the innovation’s sustainability. Although positive overall, there were some concerns about sustainability based on quality, eHealth literacy, and access to health care for vulnerable migrants and the uninsured. Conclusions: We identified confusion between the concepts of patient experience and patient satisfaction; therefore, future research could focus on established frameworks to qualify the patient experience across the whole pathway and not just the remote encounter. As expected, our research found mainly descriptive analyses, so there is a need for more robust evidence methods identifying impacts of changes in treatment pathways. This study illustrates modern methods to decolonize academic research by using gray literature extracts in other languages. We acknowledge that the use of Google to identify gray literature at the global level and in other languages has implications on reproducibility. We did not consider synchronous text-based communication. Trial Registration: Open Science Framework 4z5ut; https://osf.io/4z5ut/Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 173 references indexed in Scilit:
- Virtual Prenatal and Postpartum Care Acceptability Among Maternity Care ProvidersMaternal and Child Health Journal, 2022
- Association of an Advance Care Planning Video and Communication Intervention With Documentation of Advance Care Planning Among Older AdultsJAMA Network Open, 2022
- Patient Experience with In-Person and Telehealth Visits Before and During the COVID-19 Pandemic at a Large Integrated Health System in the United StatesJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2022
- The effect of Covid-19 on the willingness to use video consultations among orthopedic and trauma outpatients: a multi-center survey in 1400 outpatientsEuropean Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery, 2021
- Versorgung von rheumatologischen Patienten während des Lockdowns im Frühjahr 2020Zeitschrift für Rheumatologie, 2021
- Efficiency and satisfaction with telephone consultation of follow‐up patients in neuro‐urology: Experience of the COVID‐19 pandemicNeurourology and Urodynamics, 2021
- Telemedicine During COVID‐19 for Outpatient Sports and Musculoskeletal Medicine PhysiciansPM&R, 2020
- How to Conduct an Outpatient Telemedicine Rehabilitation or Prehabilitation VisitPM&R, 2020
- A Conceptual Framework and Pilot Study for Examining Telemedicine Satisfaction ResearchJournal of Medical Systems, 2019
- Multiple imputation using chained equations: Issues and guidance for practiceStatistics in Medicine, 2010