ASAnkit Shanker

Ankit Shanker

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Ankit Shanker has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Correcting social norm misperceptions to counter online vaccine misinformation during pandemics

    by Ankit Shanker, Ivo Vlaev

    Online vaccine misinformation circulating on social media undermines public health efforts, yet factual debunking alone has shown limited success in improving vaccination intentions. We tested whether combining descriptive social norm information with factual debunking improves the correction of online vaccine misinformation, alters its mechanism of influence, and varies in effectiveness by prior COVID-19 vaccination status. In an online experiment, 731 UK adults were randomly assigned to view online vaccine misinformation about a hypothetical pandemic (Covid-66) under one of three conditions: debunked combined with descriptive norm messaging, debunked alone, or not corrected at all. Vaccine intentions and perceived peer vaccination norms were measured before and after exposure. Uncorrected online vaccine misinformation significantly reduced vaccine intentions by 2.7 percentage points (p < 0.001) and induced substantial norm misperception, with participants underestimating peer vaccine support by 8.04 percentage points (p < 0.001). Both correction conditions increased vaccine intentions relative to no correction, but the combined intervention did not produce significantly greater change than debunking alone (p = .681); our primary hypothesis of an incremental benefit from adding descriptive norm information to debunking was not supported on this average-effect outcome. Exploratory subgroup analyses indicated possible differential effects by COVID-19 vaccination status. Among participants who were unvaccinated or had received only one dose, the combined intervention produced significantly higher post-intervention intentions than exposure to misinformation alone, whereas debunking alone reached only borderline significance (p = .05). Among participants who had received two doses without a booster, the combined intervention produced significantly higher intentions than both debunking alone and no correction. Among boosted participants, intentions were high and comparable across conditions. Across the five posts, which targeted vaccine safety, vaccine efficacy, and institutional trust, exposure reduced vaccine intentions largely by leading people to underestimate how much others support vaccination (pluralistic ignorance): the indirect effect through norm misperception was b = − 6.80 (95% CI [− 10.32, − 3.73]), with no direct effect detectable. Both correction strategies reduced this underestimation of peer support, but to very different extents. The combined intervention almost completely corrected the misperception, and its effect on intentions was carried by that pathway with no residual direct effect detected. Debunking alone only partially corrected the misperception and showed a smaller indirect effect alongside a direct effect at the conventional threshold, suggesting it also operates through mechanisms not measured here. Taken together, these findings suggest that online vaccine misinformation during pandemics can reduce vaccine intentions partly by distorting perceptions of what peers do, and that debunking partially corrects this misperception. Adding descriptive norm information more fully corrects the norm misperception but does not, on average, produce a detectable additional benefit in intention change relative to debunking alone. Exploratory analyses suggest the combined intervention may be more helpful than debunking alone among less-vaccinated participants, a pattern consistent with norm interventions being most effective where room for attitude change is greatest, though these warrants preregistered confirmatory testing.

  • Open Access

    Vaccine misinformation and social determinants of vaccine intentions during a pandemic

    by Ankit Shanker

    The aim is to examine how vaccine misinformation shapes perceived social norms and assess their mediating role in vaccination intentions during pandemics, an underexplored mechanism in misinformation’s influence on vaccine decisions. In a pre-registered online experiment, UK residents (n = 332) were randomly assigned to either a misinformation or control condition in a hypothetical pandemic scenario. I measured changes in vaccination intentions, first-order normative beliefs (perceptions of others’ vaccination intentions) and second-order normative beliefs (perceptions of others’ beliefs about vaccine safety) before and after exposure. Causal mediation analysis using inverse odds ratio weighting assessed the indirect effects of misinformation through changes in normative beliefs. The pre–post comparison revealed that vaccine intentions declined 2.5% more in the misinformation condition compared to the control group (p = 0.024, d = 0.24). In the misinformation group, average vaccine intentions dropped from 62.4% to 59.3%, while the control group showed minimal change from 60.8% to 60.2%. Changes in first-order normative beliefs mediated 39.52% of misinformation’s total effect on vaccination intentions. The findings reveal that vaccine misinformation operates through dual pathways: directly affecting individual beliefs while simultaneously distorting perceptions of social consensus about vaccination.


  • Open Access

    Social Proof as a Vaccine Booster: Enhancing the Efficacy of Fact-Based Corrections of Online Vaccine Misinformation during Pandemics

    by Ankit Shanker, Ivo Vlaev

    In the battleground of pandemic information, vaccine misinformation spreads with virus-like efficiency across social media, potentially undermining public health efforts when they're most crucial. While platforms deploy algorithmic corrections as digital antibodies against false claims, these interventions often fail to penetrate the protective barriers of deeply held skepticism. This study examines a novel immunization strategy: fortifying factual corrections with social proof. Through a controlled experiment simulating a novel pandemic scenario ("COVID-66"), we measured how vaccine intentions fluctuated when exposed to misinformation followed by different corrective treatments. Our findings reveal a compelling asymmetry: while algorithmic corrections alone successfully bolstered overall vaccine intentions compared to untreated controls, they failed to sway the unvaccinated and partially vaccinated—the very groups most critical to achieving population immunity. However, when corrections were combined with normative messaging showing peer acceptance of vaccines, these resistant groups showed significant positive shifts in vaccination intent. Further dissection through mediation analysis unveiled the mechanism behind this enhanced efficacy: unlike standalone corrections that worked through multiple pathways, the combined approach primarily operated by reshaping perceptions of social consensus, which subsequently realigned personal intentions. These results suggest a powerful prescription for pandemic communication: facts alone may not persuade the hesitant, but facts embedded within a supportive social context can overcome resistance where traditional approaches fail. By bridging the gap between cognitive correction and social influence, this research offers practical tools for crafting public health messages that resonate even with those most resistant to conventional expertise.

  • Open Access

    Vaccine Misinformation and Social Determinants of Vaccine Intentions in a Pandemic

    by Ankit Shanker

    Objective: To examine how vaccine misinformation shapes perceivedsocial norms and assess their mediating role in vaccination intentionsduring pandemics, an underexplored mechanism in misinformation'sinfluence on vaccine decisions.Methods: In a pre-registered online experiment, UK residents (n=332)were randomly assigned to either a misinformation or control condition ina hypothetical pandemic scenario. I measured changes in vaccinationintentions, first-order normative beliefs (perceptions of others'vaccination intentions), and second-order normative beliefs (perceptionsof others' beliefs about vaccine safety) before and after exposure. Causalmediation analysis using inverse odds ratio weighting assessed theindirect effects of misinformation through changes in normative beliefs.Results: The pre-post comparison revealed that vaccine intentionsdeclined 2.5% more in the misinformation condition compared to control(p = 0.024, d = 0.24). In the misinformation group, average vaccineintentions dropped from 62.4% to 59.3%, while the control group showedminimal change from 60.8% to 60.2%. Changes in first-order normativebeliefs mediated 39.52% of misinformation's total effect on vaccinationintentions.Conclusions: The findings reveal that vaccine misinformation operatesthrough dual pathways: directly affecting individual beliefs whilesimultaneously distorting perceptions of social consensus aboutvaccination.

  • Open Access

    Global Evidence on the Sustainability of Telemedicine in Outpatient and Primary Care During the First 2 Years of the COVID-19 Pandemic: Scoping Review Using the Nonadoption, Abandonment, Scale-Up, Spread, and Sustainability (NASSS) Framework

    by Daniela Valdes, Ankit Shanker, Ghofran Hijazi, Daniel Opoku Mensah, Tahir Bockarie, Ioana Lazar, Siti Aishah Ibrahim, Hamid Zolfagharinia, Rob Procter, Rachel Spencer, et al.

    Background: The rapid implementation of telemedicine during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic raises questions about the sustainability of this intervention at the global level. Objective: This research examines the patient experience, health inequalities, and clinician-patient relationship in telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic’s first 2 years, aiming to identify sustainability factors. Methods: This study was based on a prepublished protocol using the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology for scoping reviews. We included academic and gray literature published between March 2020 and March 2022 according to these criteria: (1) population (any group); (2) concepts (patient experience, clinician-patient relationship, health inequalities); (3) context (telemedicine in primary and outpatient care); (4) excluding studies pertaining to surgery, oncology, and (inpatient) psychiatry. We searched Ovid Medline/PubMed (January 1, 2022), Web of Science (March 19, 2022), Google/Google Scholar (February and March 2022), and others. The risk of bias was not assessed as per guidance. We used an analysis table for the studies and color-coded tabular mapping against a health care technology adoption framework to identify sustainability (using double-blind extraction). Results: Of the 134 studies that met our criteria, 49.3% (66/134) reported no specific population group. Regarding the concepts, 41.8% (56/134) combined 2 of the concepts studied. The context analysis identified that 56.0% (75/134) of the studies referred to, according to the definition in the United Kingdom, an outpatient (ambulatory care) setting, and 34.3% (46/134) referred to primary care. The patient experience analysis reflected positive satisfaction and sustained access during lockdowns. The clinician-patient relationship impacts were nuanced, affecting interaction and encounter quality. When mapping to the nonadoption, abandonment, scale-up, spread, and sustainability (NASSS) framework, 81.3% (109/134) of the studies referenced the innovation’s sustainability. Although positive overall, there were some concerns about sustainability based on quality, eHealth literacy, and access to health care for vulnerable migrants and the uninsured. Conclusions: We identified confusion between the concepts of patient experience and patient satisfaction; therefore, future research could focus on established frameworks to qualify the patient experience across the whole pathway and not just the remote encounter. As expected, our research found mainly descriptive analyses, so there is a need for more robust evidence methods identifying impacts of changes in treatment pathways. This study illustrates modern methods to decolonize academic research by using gray literature extracts in other languages. We acknowledge that the use of Google to identify gray literature at the global level and in other languages has implications on reproducibility. We did not consider synchronous text-based communication. Trial Registration: Open Science Framework 4z5ut; https://osf.io/4z5ut/


  • Open Access

    The Social influence of the Corrections of Vaccine Misinformation on Social Media

    by Ankit Shanker, Ivo Vlaev

    This study examines the impact of social versus algorithmic corrections of vaccine misinformation on social media, on the perceptions of social norms around vaccination and vaccine intentions during a hypothetical pandemic. In an online experiment with 720 participants, we assessed whether user-generated or algorithmically generated corrections influenced perception of social norms measured as beliefs about other’s vaccination intentions (empirical expectations about vaccination), perception about the social appropriateness of vaccine refusal (normative expectations), and beliefs about others' perceptions of vaccine safety (second-order normative beliefs), and own vaccine intentions.User-generated corrections significantly increased the perceptions that refusing vaccination is socially very inappropriate and increased the perception that consensus is in support of vaccine safety. Algorithmic corrections did not influence social norm perceptions. Interestingly, neither social nor algorithmic corrections significantly altered empirical expectations about others' vaccination intentions. Both corrections also helped maintain participants' high initial vaccine intentions with algorithmic correction having stronger effects, in contrast to a significant decline in intentions observed in the control group exposed to misinformation without corrections.Algorithmic corrections from credible health agencies were effective in sustaining vaccine intentions, while user-generated corrections were more influential in improving perceptions of social norms. The study suggests that different correction types influence distinct determinants of vaccination behaviour: user-generated corrections reshape perceived social norms, while algorithmic corrections, citing credible sources, may better sustain high vaccine intentions.Keywords: Misinformation Corrections, Perceived Social Norms, Vaccine Intentions, Vaccine Misinformation, Social Corrections, Algorithmic Correction.

  • Open Access

    Assessing the Relationships Between Capability, Opportunity, and Motivation in Influencing Self-Isolation Behaviour During Pandemics

    by Gbeminiyi Joshua Oyedele, Ankit Shanker, Michael J. Tildesley, Ivo Vlaev

    This study presents an analysis of the direct and indirect effects of the behavioural determinants of Capability, Opportunity, and Motivation, the necessary and sufficient conditions for any behaviour change, on self-isolation behaviour during the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK. Uniquely, we also explore the causal interactions between these variables, unveiling the most significant contributors to individuals' decisions to self-isolate. Using a retrospective dataset from the UK Office for National Statistics' 2019 Opinion and Lifestyle Survey, we applied a sophisticated structural equation model to dissect the behavioural dynamics. Our findings are striking in that both opportunity and motivation exert a direct and significant impact on self-isolation, while capability influences behaviour indirectly through the mediating power of motivation. This pioneering analysis offers a powerful framework for future public health strategies, providing critical insights into how we can better engage the public in self-isolation behaviours to ensure more effective compliance in the face of future pandemics.

  • Open Access

    Global Evidence on the Sustainability of Telemedicine in Outpatient and Primary Care During the First 2 Years of the COVID-19 Pandemic: Scoping Review Using the Nonadoption, Abandonment, Scale-Up, Spread, and Sustainability (NASSS) Framework (Preprint)

    by Daniela Valdes, Ankit Shanker, Ghofran Hijazi, Daniel Opoku Mensah, Tahir Bockarie, Ioana Lazar, Siti Aishah Ibrahim, Hamid Zolfagharinia, Rob Procter, Rachel Spencer, et al.

    BACKGROUND The rapid implementation of telemedicine during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic raises questions about the sustainability of this intervention at the global level. OBJECTIVE This research examines the patient experience, health inequalities, and clinician-patient relationship in telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic’s first 2 years, aiming to identify sustainability factors. METHODS This study was based on a prepublished protocol using the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology for scoping reviews. We included academic and gray literature published between March 2020 and March 2022 according to these criteria: (1) population (any group); (2) concepts (patient experience, clinician-patient relationship, health inequalities); (3) context (telemedicine in primary and outpatient care); (4) excluding studies pertaining to surgery, oncology, and (inpatient) psychiatry. We searched Ovid Medline/PubMed (January 1, 2022), Web of Science (March 19, 2022), Google/Google Scholar (February and March 2022), and others. The risk of bias was not assessed as per guidance. We used an analysis table for the studies and color-coded tabular mapping against a health care technology adoption framework to identify sustainability (using double-blind extraction). RESULTS Of the 134 studies that met our criteria, 49.3% (66/134) reported no specific population group. Regarding the concepts, 41.8% (56/134) combined 2 of the concepts studied. The context analysis identified that 56.0% (75/134) of the studies referred to, according to the definition in the United Kingdom, an outpatient (ambulatory care) setting, and 34.3% (46/134) referred to primary care. The patient experience analysis reflected positive satisfaction and sustained access during lockdowns. The clinician-patient relationship impacts were nuanced, affecting interaction and encounter quality. When mapping to the nonadoption, abandonment, scale-up, spread, and sustainability (NASSS) framework, 81.3% (109/134) of the studies referenced the innovation’s sustainability. Although positive overall, there were some concerns about sustainability based on quality, eHealth literacy, and access to health care for vulnerable migrants and the uninsured. CONCLUSIONS We identified confusion between the concepts of patient experience and patient satisfaction; therefore, future research could focus on established frameworks to qualify the patient experience across the whole pathway and not just the remote encounter. As expected, our research found mainly descriptive analyses, so there is a need for more robust evidence methods identifying impacts of changes in treatment pathways. This study illustrates modern methods to decolonize academic research by using gray literature extracts in other languages. We acknowledge that the use of Google to identify gray literature at the global level and in other languages has implications on reproducibility. We did not consider synchronous text-based communication. CLINICALTRIAL Open Science Framework 4z5ut; https://osf.io/4z5ut/