Identifying Positive Deviant Farms Using Pareto-Optimality Ranking Technique to Assess Productivity and Livelihood Benefits in Smallholder Dairy Farming under Contrasting Stressful Environments in Tanzania
Open Access
Abstract
In smallholder dairy-cattle farming, identifying positive deviants that attain outstanding performance can inform targeted improvements in typical, comparable farms under similar environmental stresses. Mostly, positive deviants are identified subjectively, introducing bias and limiting generalisation. The aim of the study was to objectively identify positive deviant farms using the Pareto-optimality ranking technique in a sample of smallholder dairy farms under contrasting stressful environments in Tanzania to test the hypothesis that positive deviant farms that simultaneously outperform typical farms in multiple performance indicators also outperform in yield gap, productivity and livelihood benefits. The selection criteria set five performance indicators: energy balance ≥ 0.35 Mcal NEL/d, disease-incidence density ≤ 12.75 per 100 animal-years at risk, daily milk yield ≥ 6.32 L/cow/day, age at first calving ≤ 1153.28 days and calving interval ≤ 633.68 days. Findings proved the hypothesis. A few farms (27: 3.4%) emerged as positive deviants, outperforming typical farms in yield gap, productivity and livelihood benefits. The estimated yield gap in typical farms was 76.88% under low-stress environments and 48.04% under high-stress environments. On average, total cash income, gross margins and total benefits in dairy farming were higher in positive deviants than in typical farms in both low- and high-stress environments. These results show that the Pareto-optimality ranking technique applied in a large population objectively identified a few positive deviant farms that attained higher productivity and livelihood benefits in both low- and high-stress environments. However, positive deviants invested more in inputs. With positive deviant farms objectively identified, it is possible to characterise management practices that they deploy differently from typical farms and learn lessons to inform the uptake of best practices and extension messages to be directed to improving dairy management.Keywords
Funding Information
- The World Bank Centre of Excellence in Sustainable Agriculture and Agribusiness Management at Egerton University, Kenya (IDA Credit P151847, 005/2016)
- The African Dairy Genetic Gains (ADGG) Project (IDA Credit P151847, 005/2016)
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Educating pastoralists and extension officers on diverse livestock diseases in a changing environment in TanzaniaPastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 2015
- Handling multi-functionality of livestock in a life cycle assessment: the case of smallholder dairying in KenyaCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2014
- Contribution of the calving interval to dairy farm profitability: results of a cluster analysis of FADN data for a major milk production area in southern ItalySpanish Journal of Agricultural Research, 2013
- Yield gap analysis with local to global relevance—A reviewField Crops Research, 2013
- Nutritional Manipulations to Optimize Productivity During Environmental Stresses in Livestock2012
- Livestock’s Contribution to Poverty Alleviation: How to Measure It?World Development, 2011
- Metabolic and hormonal acclimation to heat stress in domesticated ruminantsAnimal, 2010
- Smallholder dairy production and markets: A comparison of production systems in Zambia, Kenya and Sri LankaAgricultural Systems, 2007
- Smallholder dairy systems in the Kenya highlands: cattle population dynamics under increasing intensificationLivestock Production Science, 2003
- Measuring and interpreting the benefits of goat keeping in tropical farm systemsAgricultural Systems, 1997