A Response to our Critics: Agreements, Clarifications, and Children
Open Access
- 12 March 2024
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Wiley in The Reading Teacher
- Vol. 77 (5) , 751-755
Abstract
Compton‐Lilly and colleagues respond to recent critiques of their viewpoint article, Stories Grounded in Decades of Research: What We Truly Know about the Teaching of Reading—published in The Reading Teacher. We first respond to specific concerns raised by our critics. We then discuss recent legislation being enacted in statehouses across the United States that does not reflect current research. Finally, we reiterate two preeminent concerns that were not addressed by our critics: (1) instruction must be responsive to readers and (2) teachers must bring a vast range of expertise to competently serve readers who bring multifaceted literate and experiential knowledge to texts. Reiterating concerns raised by other readings scholars, we worry that attending to microdimensions of arguments creates false binaries, obfuscates important areas of agreement, and distracts attention from what truly matters: children.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- “Whatever You Want to Call It”: Science of Reading Mythologies in the Education Reform MovementHarvard Educational Review, 2023
- Stories Grounded in Decades of Research: What We Truly Know about the Teaching of ReadingThe Reading Teacher, 2023
- “Phonics Monkeys” and “Real Life Reading”: Heteroglossic Views of a State Reading InitiativeLiteracy Research and Instruction, 2023
- Red Flags, Red Herrings, and Common Ground: An Expert Study in Response to State Reading PolicyEducational Considerations, 2021
- Lost in Translation? Challenges in Connecting Reading Science and Educational PracticeReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- Connected Phonation is More Effective than Segmented Phonation for Teaching Beginning Readers to Decode Unfamiliar WordsScientific Studies of Reading, 2020
- Making Sense of Learners Making Sense of Written Language2014
- Managing chronic crises and chronic hazard conditionsEnvironmental Hazards, 2013
- Generous Reading: Seeing Students Through Their WritingThe Reading Teacher, 2010
- The role of discourse context in developing word form representations: A paradoxical relation between reading and learningJournal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2006