CCCatherine Compton-Lilly

Catherine Compton-Lilly

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Catherine Compton-Lilly has a total of 48 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    A Historical Analysis of Science, Equity, and Reading: The Summary of Investigations Relating to Reading

    by Catherine Compton‐Lilly, Rebecca Rogers

    This historical analysis focuses on the 72‐year legacy of the Summary Investigations of Reading Research ( SIRR ) originally written by William S. Gray as a monograph in 1925, and continuing under the authorship of Helen Robinson and Samuel Weintraub until 1997. While publication venues changed, the intention remained the same: to provide reading scholars and educators with a comprehensive overview of reading research published each year. While many questions could be brought to this archive, we ask: What can we learn about how reading has developed as a science, and the role played by equity and diversity in reading scholarship by exploring the 72‐year history of the Summary of Reading Investigations?‐‐ To address these issues, we attend to intersections among discourses of place (e.g., venues, universities), interactional orders (e.g., collaborations, forms of communication), and foci (e.g., recurring themes) through a discourse‐historical approach. Our analysis reveals numerous historical points of tensions and suggests that increases in the use of scientific language in the Summary Investigations coincided with increased attention to student diversity and equitable schooling experiences. Notably, these advances revealed tensions between what science can and cannot reveal about how children become readers, especially when we ask who is well‐served. Representation of international scholarship is discussed.

  • Open Access

    The Intertwined Development of Atayal Oral Language, Emergent Reading and Identity Among Indigenous Young Children in a Bilingual Book Project

    by Ching‐Ting Hsin, Catherine Compton‐Lilly, Di Tam Luu

    This mixed‐methods study explored the intertwined development of Atayal oral language, emergent reading‐like behaviors, and cultural identity for 28 Indigenous preschoolers (average age 4.11 years) during a year‐long book project. Eight early childhood and Atayal language teachers from two classrooms implemented bilingual books at two levels of difficulty. Each level was used for a semester. Pre‐project, mid‐project and post‐project assessments related to oral language, emergent reading, and cultural identity were conducted; child interviews and observational field notes were collected. Quantitative (i.e., ANOVA with repeated measures, paired sample t ‐test, Pearson correlation) and qualitative analyses (i.e., coding of interview transcripts and field notes, identification/counting of reading‐like behaviors) revealed significant improvement for Atayal oral language, emergent reading‐like behaviors, and cultural identity after the first semester. However, further improvement on oral language and reading‐like behaviors was not indicated, perhaps due to dissimilar sentence structures between level one and level two books. While this project enhanced children's attention to print and print concepts, most children continued to rely on picture cues and memory rather than phonetic cues. This study sheds light on developing and implementing materials to sustain Indigenous languages.

  • Connecting Community through Critical Residency Work

    by Jonathan Jd Dillensnyder, Catherine Compton-Lilly, George J. Roy, Kristin E. Harbour, Sommer A. Garrett

    Teacher residency programs are important pathways to address certified teacher shortages (e.g., Ingersoll, 2003; Ingersoll & Tran, 2023). Rural areas experience unique challenges (e.g., Aragon, 2016; Cowan et al., 2016; Tieken, 2017) and can benefit from grow-your-own models (Garcia et al., 2019; Gist et al., 2019) built upon the recognition of Community Cultural Wealth (Yosso, 2005). Valuing forms of Community Cultural Wealth serves as a starting point for educators to develop community partnerships, establishing “even playing fields” that reorder traditional educational structures and inspire unity of effort toward meeting educational program goals. The stories provided in this chapter – focused on how various forms of Community Cultural Wealth can and should support program design, and continual re-design – provide a starting point for all stakeholders within and across teacher preparation pathways who aim to connect communities through critical residency work.

  • Teaching and learning indigenous languages: An Atayal book project

    by Ching-Ting Hsin, Ming-Fang Hsieh, Ya-Lun Tsao, Wan-Chen Chang, Catherine Compton-Lilly

    This study drew on two case studies to explore the implementation of the Atayal Indigenous book program in Taiwan. Eight teachers from two focal classrooms were invited to use dual language books featuring recurring grammatical structures to help young children learn the Atayal language. This study’s purpose was to explore the instructional strategies teachers used and the contribution of the book project to children’s Atayal language learning. The teachers were interviewed and asked to videotape the Atayal lessons conducted using the books. Pre- and post-tests were conducted to assess children’s Atayal language learning, particularly for the language presented in the books. Qualitative and quantitative analyses (i.e., Wilcoxon signed-rank and Chi-square tests) were performed. The findings suggest that the teachers in both focal classrooms used multiple strategies to successfully promote children’s learning of Atayal vocabulary, sentences, and cultural practices. The findings indicated an interplay between instructional strategies and children’s Atayal language learning, with practices extending beyond teaching vocabulary being particularly beneficial. Thus, teacher expertise can affect language learning and the instructional strategies that teachers use to support young children’s Atayal language acquisition.


  • Open Access

    A Response to our Critics: Agreements, Clarifications, and Children

    by Catherine Compton‐Lilly, Lucy K. Spence, Paul L. Thomas, Scott L. Decker

    Compton‐Lilly and colleagues respond to recent critiques of their viewpoint article, Stories Grounded in Decades of Research: What We Truly Know about the Teaching of Reading—published in The Reading Teacher. We first respond to specific concerns raised by our critics. We then discuss recent legislation being enacted in statehouses across the United States that does not reflect current research. Finally, we reiterate two preeminent concerns that were not addressed by our critics: (1) instruction must be responsive to readers and (2) teachers must bring a vast range of expertise to competently serve readers who bring multifaceted literate and experiential knowledge to texts. Reiterating concerns raised by other readings scholars, we worry that attending to microdimensions of arguments creates false binaries, obfuscates important areas of agreement, and distracts attention from what truly matters: children.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Stories Grounded in Decades of Research: What We Truly Know about the Teaching of Reading

    by Catherine Compton‐Lilly, Lucy K. Spence, Paul L. Thomas, Scott L. Decker

    The recent dissemination of selective research findings related to reading privileges a narrow body of reading scholarship and a singular, unproven solution—teaching phonics. We offer a research‐based correction by presenting two compelling bodies of research to argue that reading instruction must be responsive to individual children. While this confluence of complexity does not deny the importance of phonics, it highlights the significant findings related to: (1) the brain and reading, and (2) the systematic observation of young readers. We argue that reductive and singular models of reading fail to honor the cultures, experiences, and diversity of children. This confluence of research findings reveals an unequivocal need for caution as states, universities, schools, and teachers adopt assumedly universal and narrow approaches to teaching reading.