A method for the madness: An international survey of health professions education authors' journal choice
Open Access
- 21 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 11 (3) , 165-172
Abstract
Introduction Scholarship is a key activity in health professions education (HPE). When disseminating scholarly work, how one selects the journal to which they submit is often argued to be a key determinant of subsequent success. To draw more evidence-based recommendations in this regard, we surveyed successful scholars working in HPE regarding their perspectives and experiences with journal selection. Methods We conducted an international survey of HPE scholars, investigating their decisions regarding journal choice. Corresponding authors were identified from a sample of 4000 papers published in 2019 and 2020. They were invited via email with up to four reminders. We describe their experience and use principle component and regression analyses to identify factors associated with successful acceptance. Results In total, 863 responses were received (24.7% response rate), 691 of which were included in our analyses. Two thirds of respondents had their manuscripts accepted at their first-choice journal with revisions required in 98% of cases. We identified six priority factors when choosing journals. In descending order of importance, they were: fit, impact, editorial reputation, speed of dissemination, breadth of dissemination, and guidance from others. Authors who prioritised fit higher and who selected a journal earlier were more likely to have their manuscripts accepted at their first-choice journal. Discussion Based on our results we make three recommendations for authors when writing manuscripts: do not be disheartened by a revise decision, consider journal choice early in the research process, and use the fit between your manuscript and the journal as the main factor driving journal choice.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Improving response rates and evaluating nonresponse bias in surveys: AMEE Guide No. 102Medical Teacher, 2015
- Productivity in medical education research: an examination of countries of originBMC Medical Education, 2014
- Defining the Key Roles and Competencies of the Clinician–Educator of the 21st CenturyAcademic Medicine, 2014
- Does community health care require different competencies from physicians and nurses?BMC Medical Education, 2014
- Flows of Research Manuscripts Among Scientific Journals Reveal Hidden Submission PatternsScience, 2012
- Good advice from the deputy editors of Medical EducationMedical Education, 2012
- The reviewer is always right: peer review of research in Medical EducationMedical Education, 2008
- Boyerʼs Expanded Definitions of Scholarship, the Standards for Assessing Scholarship, and the Elusiveness of the Scholarship of TeachingAcademic Medicine, 2000
- Authors' Criteria for Selecting JournalsJAMA, 1994
- Little Jiffy, Mark IvEducational and Psychological Measurement, 1974