Rules and temptations: which came first?
Open Access
- 19 February 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Institutional Economics
- Vol. 22, e9
Abstract
For received theories, (suboptimal) temptations arise first, and, consequently, people set up rules or institutions to control them. Hence, any deviation from institutions is suboptimal. However, these received theories face an anomaly, coined here the ‘Holiday License Paradox’: Why would people who adopt optimal institutions turn around and designate ‘holidays’ (cheat days) that allow them to indulge in suboptimal consumption? To solve this paradox, this paper reverses the entry point: people first set up rules – whereas temptations are identifiable only with respect to those rules. This solution raises a new question: what is the origin of rules? People adopt rules to control ‘temerity’, i.e., overconfidence. This raises a further question: what is the origin of temerity? Temerity is a default heuristic expressing the optimal response in life-and-death decisions. Thus, temerity-as-heuristics is rather efficient on average. However, temerity can become excessive, and, at second approximation, people adopt rules to control temerity. Once we regard rules or institutions to come first, i.e., prior to temptations, it becomes possible to solve the Holiday License Paradox.Keywords
This publication has 71 references indexed in Scilit:
- The information inelasticity of habits: Kahneman’s bounded rationality or Simon’s procedural rationality?Synthese, 2022
- The parallelism of cognitive economy and physiological economy: A rationality-based dual process theoryCurrent Psychology, 2022
- Dual Process Theories in Behavioral Economics and Neuroeconomics: a Critical ReviewReview of Philosophy and Psychology, 2019
- Non-hyperbolic discounting and dynamic preference reversalTheory and Decision, 2019
- Socialized view of man vs. rational choice theory: What does smith’s sympathy have to say?Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2017
- Temptations as Impulsivity: How far are Regret and the Allais Paradox from Shoplifting?Economic Modelling, 2015
- Lock-in institutions and efficiencyJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2013
- The optimism biasCurrent Biology, 2011
- Darwin's Dangerous IdeaThe Sciences, 1995
- Dynamic inconsistency, cooperation and the benevolent dissembling governmentJournal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 1980