Abstract
Property insurers have long been heralded as potential leaders in driving adaptation and resilience to the accelerating impacts of climate change. In practice, however, insurers have largely fallen short of these expectations. Premiums frequently fail to reflect even near-term climate risks, discounts for climate-linked property hardening remain limited, and insurers regularly withdraw from the regions most exposed to climate change. Several structural features of contemporary property insurance markets help explain this disappointing track record, including annual policy terms, individualized underwriting, and purchasers’ informational, cognitive, and financial constraints. This Article argues that these structural barriers to insurers promoting climate adaptation and resilience can be mitigated through a largely overlooked legal reform: modernizing state insurance laws that prohibit insurers from providing group insurance coverage to homeowners living within geographically defined communities. Such group property insurance, this Article argues, could enable insurers and communities to better coordinate and finance climate adaptation and resilience strategies, while also producing more accurate and durable pricing signals. Historical experiments with group property insurance and the success of group models in health and life insurance demonstrate both the feasibility and potential benefits of such arrangements. Yet in most states, “fictitious group” laws and restrictive interpretations of state prohibitions against “unfair discrimination” render such group property insurance arrangements legally unworkable. Updating these laws would open the door to much-needed experimentation in homeowners insurance markets, creating the prospect of better aligning these markets with the urgent risks posed by climate change.