Courts and health care rationing: the case of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court
- 8 October 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 8 (1) , 75-93
Abstract
The recognition that access to health care is a constitutional right in Brazil has resulted in a situation in which citizens denied treatments by the public health care system have brought lawsuits against health authorities, claiming that their right to health was violated. This litigation forces the courts to decide between a patient-centred and a population-centred approach to public health – a choice that forces the courts to assess health care rationing decisions. This article analyses the judgments of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court in right to health cases, arguing that the Court's recent decisions have been contrary to their long-standing stance against rationing. In 2009, the Court organized a public hearing to discuss this topic with civil society and established criteria to determine when rationing would be legal. However, I argue that these criteria for health care rationing do not adequately address the most difficult health care distribution dilemmas. They force the health care system to keep their rationing criteria implicit and make population-centred concerns secondary to individual-centred ones.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Medicamentos de alto custo para doenças raras no Brasil: o exemplo das doenças lisossômicasCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2010
- Health technology appraisal and the courts: accountability for reasonableness and the judicial model of procedural justiceHealth Economics, Policy and Law, 2010
- Gasto do Ministério da Saúde com medicamentos: tendência dos programas de 2002 a 2007Revista de Saúde Pública, 2009
- Public healthcare resource allocation and the Rule of RescueJournal of Medical Ethics, 2008
- Evolution of Antiretroviral Drug Costs in Brazil in the Context of Free and Universal Access to AIDS TreatmentPLOS Medicine, 2007
- Distorções causadas pelas ações judiciais à política de medicamentos no BrasilRevista de Saúde Pública, 2007
- Law, Legitimacy and the Rationing of Healthcare2007
- Helping a Victim or Helping the Victim: Altruism and IdentifiabilityJournal of Risk and Uncertainty, 2003
- Technology as a ‘major driver’ of health care costs: a cointegration analysis of the Newhouse conjectureJournal of Health Economics, 2002
- Rationing and life-saving treatments: should identifiable patients have higher priority?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2001