The Prevalence of Bayesian Inference, Preregistration, and Open Data in Psychology, 2004-2024

Authors:

Abstract
Psychology has undergone substantial methodological changes in the past two decades. We tracked the adoption of Bayesian inference and two open science practices across 28,738 articles from six ‘top-tier’ (15,634 articles) and six ‘mid-tier’ (13,104 articles) psychology journals in 2004–2024. In ‘top-tier’ journals, human (50%) and LLM-assisted (50%) full-text coding revealed that in 2024, 26% of articles reported a Bayesian analysis, 41% included a preregistration, and 73% provided open data. In ‘mid-tier’ journals, LLM coding showed corresponding rates of 16%, 18%, and 40%. From 2004 to 2012, these practices were virtually nonexistent. Bayesian logistic growth modeling suggests further increases, although their extent remains uncertain. Mixed-effects models became more prevalent, software reporting improved, with greater use of R and less reliance on SPSS, but estimation-focused (vs. hypothesis-testing-focused) reporting showed only modest gains. Despite heterogeneity across journals, psychology articles published in 2024 differ markedly from those published only a decade earlier.