Meike Waaijers
Research Subjects
Meike Waaijers has a total of 69 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alexandra Sarafoglou
University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
3 shared publications - Caspar J. Van Lissa
Department of Methodology and Statistics, Tilburg University, Tilburg, The Netherlands
3 shared publications - Denny Borsboom
Department of Psychological Methods, University of Amsterdam
3 shared publications Jason Nak
3 shared publications- Andrea K. Wittenborn
Human Development and Family Studies Michigan State University East Lansing Michigan USA
2 shared publications - Andreas Glöckner
Department of Psychology, University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The Prevalence of Bayesian Inference, Preregistration, and Open Data in Psychology, 2004-2024
Psychology has undergone substantial methodological changes in the past two decades. We tracked the adoption of Bayesian inference and two open science practices across 28,738 articles from six ‘top-tier’ (15,634 articles) and six ‘mid-tier’ (13,104 articles) psychology journals in 2004–2024. In ‘top-tier’ journals, human (50%) and LLM-assisted (50%) full-text coding revealed that in 2024, 26% of articles reported a Bayesian analysis, 41% included a preregistration, and 73% provided open data. In ‘mid-tier’ journals, LLM coding showed corresponding rates of 16%, 18%, and 40%. From 2004 to 2012, these practices were virtually nonexistent. Bayesian logistic growth modeling suggests further increases, although their extent remains uncertain. Mixed-effects models became more prevalent, software reporting improved, with greater use of R and less reliance on SPSS, but estimation-focused (vs. hypothesis-testing-focused) reporting showed only modest gains. Despite heterogeneity across journals, psychology articles published in 2024 differ markedly from those published only a decade earlier.
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe Prevalence of Bayesian Inference, Preregistration, and Open Data in Psychology, 2004-2024
Psychology has undergone substantial methodological changes in the past two decades. We tracked the adoption of Bayesian inference and two open science practices across 28,738 articles from six ‘top-tier’ (15,634 articles) and six ‘mid-tier’ (13,104 articles) psychology journals in 2004–2024. In ‘top-tier’ journals, human (50%) and LLM-assisted (50%) full-text coding revealed that in 2024, 26% of articles reported a Bayesian analysis, 41% included a preregistration, and 73% provided open data. In ‘mid-tier’ journals, LLM coding showed corresponding rates of 16%, 18%, and 40%. From 2004 to 2012, these practices were virtually nonexistent. Bayesian logistic growth modeling suggests further increases, although their extent remains uncertain. Mixed-effects models became more prevalent, software reporting improved, with greater use of R and less reliance on SPSS, but estimation-focused (vs. hypothesis-testing-focused) reporting showed only modest gains. Despite heterogeneity across journals, psychology articles published in 2024 differ markedly from those published only a decade earlier.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Theorytopia: Psychological Science in 2050
The year is 2050, and psychology has transformed into a theory-driven science—a Theorytopia. Drawing on initiatives and frameworks developed over the past decades since the Theory Crisis, three main advancements have made this transformation possible. First, specialization in theory construction within psychology ensures that theories are tested independently of those who propose them. Methodologies and training in theorizing have been strengthened, while new repositories, such as the “Garden of Living Theories,” promote cumulative record-keeping. Second, worldwide efforts consolidate robust psychological phenomena, reduce reliance on WEIRD samples, and systematize theoretical concepts. Measurement validation and studies probing context-dependency and auxiliary assumptions are now valued research directions in psychology, providing improved empirical bases for rigorous conceptual work. Third, stronger theories better serve the public. Computational modeling, tighter collaboration with stakeholders, better intervention design, new interfaces between science and the public, and the active inclusion of diverse perspectives are improving not just psychology’s societal impact, but also its epistemic value. In this paper, we describe what discussions, actions, and structural changes have led to these drastic improvements, and invite readers to participate in co-shaping the future of a psychological Theorytopia.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessTheorytopia: Psychological Science in 2050
The year is 2050, and psychology has transformed into a theory-driven science—a Theorytopia. Drawing on initiatives and frameworks developed over the past decades since the Theory Crisis, three main advancements have made this transformation possible. First, specialization in theory construction within psychology ensures that theories are tested independently of those who propose them. Methodologies and training in theorizing have been strengthened, while new repositories, such as the “Garden of Living Theories,” promote cumulative record-keeping. Second, worldwide efforts consolidate robust psychological phenomena, reduce reliance on WEIRD samples, and systematize theoretical concepts. Measurement validation and studies probing context-dependency and auxiliary assumptions are now valued research directions in psychology, providing improved empirical bases for rigorous conceptual work. Third, stronger theories better serve the public. Computational modeling, tighter collaboration with stakeholders, better intervention design, new interfaces between science and the public, and the active inclusion of diverse perspectives are improving not just psychology’s societal impact, but also its epistemic value. In this paper, we describe what discussions, actions, and structural changes have led to these drastic improvements, and invite readers to participate in co-shaping the future of a psychological Theorytopia.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
CLDassist: LLM-assisted CLD construction
The Causal Loop Diagram (CLD) method is a structured approach for constructing conceptual representations of how variables may causally relate to one another, developed either individually or collaboratively with a group of experts. However, CLD construction is labor-intensive, time-consuming, and cognitively demanding. Large Language Models (LLMs), with their advanced text processing capabilities and extensive knowledge base, offer the potential to support this process. This paper presents CLDassist, an R package and Shiny app that supports CLD construction by integrating LLMs into the CLD construction process. Researchers can use CLDassist to define a list of putative variables, then query an LLM to evaluate causal links between these variables and provide supporting literature. Rather than replacing expert judgment, CLDassist functions as a thinking partner that helps researchers explore causal relationships and organize causal structures. We describe how LLMs can be used to assist in the CLD construction process and demonstrate empirically that the agreement between CLDassist and human experts is comparable to the agreement observed between experts themselves. In addition to helping researchers generate an initial CLD, CLDassist may reduce tunnel vision in the modeling process by suggesting alternative perspectives and highlighting variables or relationships that may otherwise be overlooked. By combining the established CLD method with the generative capabilities of LLMs, CLDassist provides users with a standardized, multi-stage framework for supporting the early stages of theory formalization.
- 24 July 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessCLDassist: LLM-assisted CLD construction
The Causal Loop Diagram (CLD) method is a structured approach for constructing conceptual representations of how variables may causally relate to one another, developed either individually or collaboratively with a group of experts. However, CLD construction is labor-intensive, time-consuming, and cognitively demanding. Large Language Models (LLMs), with their advanced text processing capabilities and extensive knowledge base, offer the potential to support this process. This paper presents CLDassist, an R package and Shiny app that supports CLD construction by integrating LLMs into the CLD construction process. Researchers can use CLDassist to define a list of putative variables, then query an LLM to evaluate causal links between these variables and provide supporting literature. Rather than replacing expert judgment, CLDassist functions as a thinking partner that helps researchers explore causal relationships and organize causal structures. We describe how LLMs can be used to assist in the CLD construction process and demonstrate empirically that the agreement between CLDassist and human experts is comparable to the agreement observed between experts themselves. In addition to helping researchers generate an initial CLD, CLDassist may reduce tunnel vision in the modeling process by suggesting alternative perspectives and highlighting variables or relationships that may otherwise be overlooked. By combining the established CLD method with the generative capabilities of LLMs, CLDassist provides users with a standardized, multi-stage framework for supporting the early stages of theory formalization.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
LLM-Based Prior Elicitation for Bayesian Graphical Modeling
In the Bayesian Graphical Modeling framework, priors on network structureencode theoretical assumptions and uncertainty about the topology of psychologicalconstructs under study. For instance, the Bernoulli prior specifiesthe probability of each pairwise interaction, the Beta–Bernoulli prior governsexpected network density, and the Stochastic Block prior models clustering.In practice, however, specifying informed hyperparameters is challenging:theoretical guidance is limited, and default choices can be overly simplisticor restrictive. To address this, we introduce an LLM-based prior elicitationframework in which a large language model provides inclusion judgments foreach variable pair. These judgments are converted into edge-specific priorprobabilities for the Bernoulli prior and used to derive hyperparameters forthe Beta–Bernoulli and Stochastic Block priors. To make the approach accessible,we provide an R package, bgmElicit, with a Shiny app implementingthe methodology. We illustrate the framework in two examples. First, avalidation on a subset of a PTSD network from a meta-analysis comparesOpenAI GPT models across several conditions. Second, an empirical analysisof 17 PTSD symptoms shows that elicited priors can modestly strengthenevidence regarding edge presence and absence. Taken together, this work isa proof of concept, complementary to expert judgment and prior sensitivitychecks.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessLLM-Based Prior Elicitation for Bayesian Graphical Modeling
In the Bayesian Graphical Modeling framework, priors on network structureencode theoretical assumptions and uncertainty about the topology of psychologicalconstructs under study. For instance, the Bernoulli prior specifiesthe probability of each pairwise interaction, the Beta–Bernoulli prior governsexpected network density, and the Stochastic Block prior models clustering.In practice, however, specifying informed hyperparameters is challenging:theoretical guidance is limited, and default choices can be overly simplisticor restrictive. To address this, we introduce an LLM-based prior elicitationframework in which a large language model provides inclusion judgments foreach variable pair. These judgments are converted into edge-specific priorprobabilities for the Bernoulli prior and used to derive hyperparameters forthe Beta–Bernoulli and Stochastic Block priors. To make the approach accessible,we provide an R package, bgmElicit, with a Shiny app implementingthe methodology. We illustrate the framework in two examples. First, avalidation on a subset of a PTSD network from a meta-analysis comparesOpenAI GPT models across several conditions. Second, an empirical analysisof 17 PTSD symptoms shows that elicited priors can modestly strengthenevidence regarding edge presence and absence. Taken together, this work isa proof of concept, complementary to expert judgment and prior sensitivitychecks.
- Open Access
- 13 February 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The state and status of theory in psychological science
Psychology’s theory problem, long noted since Meehl, persists: most theories are verbal, underspecified, and make weak predictions, so hypotheses rarely follow from theory and findings seldom constrain it. Historical empiricism and today’s incentives (novelty, significance, volume) favor flexible, low-risk, strategically vague theorizing, while reforms and training emphasize methods over theory construction and formal/computational modeling. The result is fragmented subfields, drifting constructs, and “effects” that don’t cumulate—fueling replication failures, post-hoc rationalization, and shallow applied progress. Improving epistemic design requires educating and rewarding precise, falsifiable theories.
- 13 February 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe state and status of theory in psychological science
Psychology’s theory problem, long noted since Meehl, persists: most theories are verbal, underspecified, and make weak predictions, so hypotheses rarely follow from theory and findings seldom constrain it. Historical empiricism and today’s incentives (novelty, significance, volume) favor flexible, low-risk, strategically vague theorizing, while reforms and training emphasize methods over theory construction and formal/computational modeling. The result is fragmented subfields, drifting constructs, and “effects” that don’t cumulate—fueling replication failures, post-hoc rationalization, and shallow applied progress. Improving epistemic design requires educating and rewarding precise, falsifiable theories.