Acceleration-Based Estimation of Vertical Ground Reaction Forces during Running: A Comparison of Methods across Running Speeds, Surfaces, and Foot Strike Patterns
Open Access
Abstract
Twenty-seven methods of estimating vertical ground reaction force first peak, loading rate, second peak, average, and/or time series from a single wearable accelerometer worn on the shank or approximate center of mass during running were compared. Force estimation errors were quantified for 74 participants across different running surfaces, speeds, and foot strike angles and biases, repeatability coefficients, and limits of agreement were modeled with linear mixed effects to quantify the accuracy, reliability, and precision. Several methods accurately and reliably estimated the first peak and loading rate, however, none could do so precisely (the limits of agreement exceeded ±65% of target values). Thus, we do not recommend first peak or loading rate estimation from accelerometers with the methods currently available. In contrast, the second peak, average, and time series could all be estimated accurately, reliably, and precisely with several different methods. Of these, we recommend the ‘Pogson’ methods due to their accuracy, reliability, and precision as well as their stability across surfaces, speeds, and foot strike angles.Keywords
Funding Information
- American College of Sports Medicine (18-00671, G2018031595024439, CGSD3-502358-2017)
- Sigma Xi Scientific Research Honor Society (18-00671, G2018031595024439, CGSD3-502358-2017)
- University of California Davis Library’s Open Access Fund (18-00671, G2018031595024439, CGSD3-502358-2017)
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (18-00671, G2018031595024439, CGSD3-502358-2017)
- Maury L Hull Endowed Fellowship for Musculoskeletal Biomechanics Research (18-00671, G2018031595024439, CGSD3-502358-2017)
- University of California Davis Professors for the Future Fellowship (18-00671, G2018031595024439, CGSD3-502358-2017)
This publication has 99 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimating Youth Locomotion Ground Reaction Forces Using an Accelerometer-Based Activity MonitorPLOS ONE, 2012
- A Highly Miniaturized, Wireless Inertial Measurement Unit for Characterizing the Dynamics of Pitched Baseballs and SoftballsSensors, 2012
- A Wearable Ground Reaction Force Sensor System and Its Application to the Measurement of Extrinsic Gait VariabilitySensors, 2010
- Determination of joint moments with instrumented force shoes in a variety of tasksJournal of Biomechanics, 2010
- Runner's stride analysis: comparison of kinematic and kinetic analyses under field conditionsScience & Sports, 2002
- Relationship between vertical ground reaction force and speed during walking, slow jogging, and runningClinical Biomechanics, 1996
- ISB recommendations for standardization in the reporting of kinematic dataJournal of Biomechanics, 1995
- Three-dimensional acceleration of the tibia during walking and runningJournal of Biomechanics, 1991
- Calculation of vertical ground reaction force estimates during running from positional dataJournal of Biomechanics, 1991
- A New Approach to Linear Filtering and Prediction ProblemsJournal of Basic Engineering, 1960