Relationships between Pacing Mode and Quality of Life: Evidence from Randomized Clinical Trials
Author:
- 1 December 2003
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Cardiac Electrophysiology Review
- Vol. 7 (4) , 401-405
Abstract
Although mode-dependent differences in mortality are for the moment unproven, establishing a health-related quality of life difference between assigned pacing modes would be useful. Such a difference, if one exists, should be ≥0.5 standard deviation units among scales using validated instruments to have significant clinical meaning. Two large data sets, the Canadian Trial of Physiological Pacing (CTOPP) and the Mode Selection Trial (MOST) both similar in design, largely failed to clearly establish such a significant difference. Another trial the Pacemaker Selection in the Elderly (PASE) did suggest that for sinus node disease, DDD-R pacing may lead to an improvement in quality of life mainly early post implant. Two other large trials, UK-PACE and DANPACE have yet to present quality of life related results. All published data have established that restoration of chronotropic competence by pacing leads to improvements in quality of life that are significant. In CTOPP an attempt to quantify a mode-dependent difference for a pacemaker syndrome suggested that the prevalence and clinical importance of pacemaker syndrome may be exaggerated. The relative ease of crossover from VVI-R to DDD, by device upgrade in CTOPP or by programming in MOST, may explain the 2.9% vs. 31% crossover rates seen in CTOPP vs. MOST respectively. Trials to date may have had a mode dependent difference undermined by possible adverse effects from right ventricular apical sites of pacing. Future trial data; DANPACE, sinus node disease AAI-R vs. DDD-R and PAVE, post AVJ ablation VVI-R vs. VVI-CRT, will asses in more detail the role of site of pacing as a factor in determining mode dependent outcomes in pacing.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Canadian trial of physiologic pacing. effects of physiologic pacing during long-term follow-upACC Current Journal Review, 2004
- Predictors and Clinical Impact of Atrial Fibrillation After Pacemaker Implantation in Elderly Patients Treated with Dual Chamber Versus Ventricular PacingPacing and Clinical Electrophysiology, 2003
- Pacemaker Mode Selection:Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology, 2003
- Effect of pacing mode on health-related quality of life in the Canadian Trial of Physiologic PacingAmerican Heart Journal, 2003
- Dual-Chamber Pacing or Ventricular Backup Pacing in Patients With an Implantable DefibrillatorJAMA, 2002
- Health values before and after pacemaker implantationAmerican Heart Journal, 2002
- Ventricular Pacing or Dual-Chamber Pacing for Sinus-Node DysfunctionNew England Journal of Medicine, 2002
- Effects of Physiologic Pacing versus Ventricular Pacing on the Risk of Stroke and Death Due to Cardiovascular CausesNew England Journal of Medicine, 2000
- Quality of Life and Clinical Outcomes in Elderly Patients Treated with Ventricular Pacing as Compared with Dual-Chamber PacingNew England Journal of Medicine, 1998
- Recommendations of the Panel on Cost-Effectiveness in Health and MedicineJAMA, 1996