Cooperative interaction often unfolds in real time, with individuals choosing not only what to do but also when to commit. This temporal feature gives rise to an endogenous decision order and can fundamentally alter the dynamics of social dilemmas. Here, we examine how endogenous decision timing shapes human cooperation by comparing two-player social dilemmas across three timing structures: simultaneous, assigned-order sequential, and real-time choices. Across two experiments (N = 718), pairs achieved mutual cooperation most often when they interacted in real time. This advantage was not explained by greater cooperation among first movers. Instead, second movers reciprocated cooperation more reliably when the move order emerged endogenously. A belief-dependent reciprocity model captured these patterns, suggesting that real-time interaction can change the meaning of early cooperation for humans. Because players can strategically wait and observe whether the other player acts first, choosing to cooperate early in real time is more demanding than cooperating as an assigned first mover. Voluntary early cooperation thus provides a stronger signal of the first mover’s cooperative intent and increases second movers’ willingness to reciprocate. Real-time interaction facilitates mutual cooperation not by increasing prosociality per se, but by changing the signalling value of actions under strategic uncertainty.