Drilling Automation: Potential for Human Error
- 7 March 2013
- journal article
- Published by Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE) in SPE Drilling & Completion
- Vol. 28 (01) , 45-59
Abstract
Summary: Mode confusion is an automated system behaving differently than expected and the operator not being aware of (or not properly understanding) what the system is doing. Mode confusion is well-recognized in the aviation community and has been indicated in a number of high-profile aviation accidents. As an example, a JAS Gripen fighter jet crashed during a test flight in the 1980s because the pilot tried to manually correct instability while the plane's computer was automatically trying to do the same. The potential for the same type of problems, and associated safety hazards, arises in drilling-rig operations as a result of the increasing trend for automation and advisory systems. A simple example could be formation fracturing with an automated downhole pressure-control system when displacing to higher mud weight caused by the driller relying on the automated system to maintain sufficiently low flow rate without having reconfigured the system with the new mud properties. This paper describes how the use of a drilling support system in different modes and levels of automation may influence the system operator's performance and risk of human error. The development of a systematic method for detecting mode-confusion problems by model checking is central in this respect. The test cases have been simulated in a virtual test environment created at IRIS specifically for such purposes. The test environment and test cases are described, and results are reported and discussed.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Early Symptom Detection Based on Real-Time Evaluation of Downhole Conditions: Principles and Results from several North Sea Drilling Operations2012
- Automation in Drilling: Future Evolution and Lessons from Aviation2012
- Advanced Drilling Simulation Environment for Testing New Drilling Automation Techniques2012
- Closed-Loop Control for Decision-Making Applications in Remote Operations2010
- The Automated Drilling Pilot on Statfjord C2010
- Real-Time Optimization of the Drilling Process—Challenges in Industrialization2009
- Early Detection of Drilling Conditions Deterioration Using Real-Time Calibration of Computer Models: Field Example from North Sea Drilling Operations2009
- eDrilling Used on Ekofisk for Real-Time Drilling Supervision, Simulation, 3D Visualization and Diagnosis2008
- A Rigorous View of Mode ConfusionLecture Notes in Computer Science, 2002
- Beyond Mode Error: Supporting Strategic Knowledge Structures to Enhance Cockpit Safety2001