Assessing NATO’s cohesion: methods and implications
Open Access
- 30 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International Politics
- Vol. 62 (5) , 1097-1110
Abstract
While united in initial responses to Putin’s aggression in Ukraine, NATO members face challenges as the alliance adapts to a significantly worsened security environment. Although Russia’s war in Ukraine provided NATO with a unifying threat, we argue that external factors are not sufficient to maintain its cohesion. This forum contribution develops a conceptual tool to assess alliance cohesion across both political and military dimensions, thus highlighting the agency of the “architects”, “bricoleurs”, and “agnostics” in shaping NATO’s internal politics. This approach allows for estimating the degree to which allies coordinate their political objectives, as well as the effectiveness of strategies to achieve them. To estimate the strength of alliance cohesion, we introduce four cohesion drivers—security threats, norms, institutions, and leadership—and assessment criteria. This article outlines three scenarios modelled on the war in Ukraine, suggesting that alliance cohesion suffers the most during prolonged security crises. Using this assessment tool can provide the “architects” of European security with ideas for policies aimed at strengthening NATO cohesion.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Southern Denmark
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Breaking with convention? Zeitenwende and the traditional pillars of German foreign policyInternational Affairs, 2022
- NATO’s strategic concept: responding to Russia and ChinaDefence Studies, 2022
- NATO burden-sharing: past, present, futureDefence Studies, 2022
- Why NATO survived Trump: the neglected role of Secretary-General StoltenbergInternational Affairs, 2021
- Ideology and influence in the debate over Russian election interferenceInternational Politics, 2021
- More allies, weaker missions? How junior partners contribute to multinational military operationsContemporary Security Policy, 2018
- Exiting the Coalition: When Do States Abandon Coalition Partners during War?International Studies Quarterly, 2016
- Why NATO Endures2009
- Why alliances endure or collapseSurvival, 1997
- Arms versus allies: trade-offs in the search for securityInternational Organization, 1993