Validation of the Acuros XB dose calculation algorithm versus Monte Carlo for clinical treatment plans
Authors:
Open Access
- 6 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 45 (8) , 3909-3915
Abstract
Purpose: The two distinct dose computation paradigms of Boltzmann equation solvers and Monte Carlo simulation both promise in principle maximum accuracy. In practice, clinically acceptable calculation times demand approximations and numerical short‐cuts on one hand, and modeling the beam characteristics of a real linear accelerator to the required accuracy on the other. A thorough benchmark of both algorithm types therefore needs to start with beam modeling, and needs to include a number of clinically challenging treatment plans.Methods: The Acuros XB (v 13.7, Varian Medical Systems) and SciMoCa (v 1.0, Scientific RT) algorithms were commissioned for the same Varian Clinac accelerator for beam qualities 6 and 15 MV. Beam models were established with water phantom measurements and MLC calibration protocols. In total, 25 patients of five case classes (lung/three‐dimensional (3D) conformal, lung/IMRT, head and neck/VMAT, cervix/IMRT, and rectum/VMAT) were randomly selected from the clinical database and computed with both algorithms. Statistics of 3D gamma analysis for various dose/distance‐to‐agreement (DTA) criteria and differences in selected DVH parameters were analyzed.Results: The percentage of points fulfilling a gamma evaluation was scored as the gamma agreement index (GAI), denoted as G(ΔD, DTA). G(3,3), G(2,2), and G(1,1) were evaluated for the full body, PTV, and selected organs at risk (OARs). For all patients, G(3,3) ≥ 99.9% and G(2,2) > 97% for the body. G(1,1) varied among the patients. However, for all patients, G(1,1) > 70% and G(1,1) > 80% for 68% of the patients. For each patient, the mean dose deviation was ΔD < 1% for the body, PTV, and all evaluated OARs, respectively. In dense bone and at off‐axis distance > 10 cm, the Acuros algorithm yielded slightly higher doses. In the first layer of voxels of the patient surface, the calculated doses deviated between the algorithms. However, at the second voxel, good agreement was observed. The differences in D(98%PTV) were <1.9% between the two algorithms and for 76% of the patients, deviations were below 1%.Conclusions: Overall, an outstanding agreement was found between the Boltzmann equation solver and Monte Carlo. High‐accuracy dose computation algorithms have matured to a level that their differences are below common experimental detection thresholds for clinical treatment plans. Aside from residual differences which could be traced back to implementation details and fundamental cross‐section data, both algorithms arrive at identical dose distributions.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Small field segments surrounded by large areas only shielded by a multileaf collimator: Comparison of experiments and dose calculationMedical Physics, 2012
- Experimental validation of deterministic Acuros XB algorithm for IMRT and VMAT dose calculations with the Radiological Physics Center's head and neck phantomMedical Physics, 2012
- Accuracy of Acuros XB and AAA dose calculation for small fields with reference to RapidArc® stereotactic treatmentsMedical Physics, 2011
- Dosimetric evaluation of Acuros XB Advanced Dose Calculation algorithm in heterogeneous mediaRadiation Oncology, 2011
- Dosimetric comparison of Acuros XB deterministic radiation transport method with Monte Carlo and model-based convolution methods in heterogeneous mediaMedical Physics, 2011
- Dosimetric validation of Acuros® XB with Monte Carlo methods for photon dose calculationsMedical Physics, 2011
- Dosimetric validation of the Acuros XB Advanced Dose Calculation algorithm: fundamental characterization in waterPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2011
- Validation of a new grid-based Boltzmann equation solver for dose calculation in radiotherapy with photon beamsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2010
- Comparison of dose calculation algorithms for treatment planning in external photon beam therapy for clinical situationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2006
- Dose calculations for external photon beams in radiotherapyPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1999