Is Intellectual Humility Compatible with Political Conviction?
Open Access
- 1 April 2024
- journal article
- Published by Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy in Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy
- Vol. 27 (2) , 211-233
Abstract
Intellectual humility is often proposed, these days, as an antidote to the profound lack of respect, tolerance, and openness to other views in contemporary politics. Moreover, deficiencies of intellectual humility are clearly at work in now-familiar displays, in political discourse, of arrogance, dogmatism and related phenomena, like polarization. Although we agree that there are roles for intellectual humility, we identify two problems. First, previous research on the relationship between intellectual humility and political conviction has ignored empirical and theoretical work indicating that humility does often result in apathy or lack of political conviction. Second, there are different forms or kinds of intellectual humility which can relate to political conviction in many ways. We end the paper by describing a kind of political quietism, which includes quite different accounts of the nature of intellectual humility.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Political Epistemology, Technocracy, and Political Anthropology: Reply to a Symposium on Power Without KnowledgeCritical Review, 2020
- Intellectual humility in the sociopolitical domainSelf and Identity, 2020
- Empathy and Testimonial TrustRoyal Institute of Philosophy Supplement, 2018
- The Epistemology of Terrorism and RadicalisationRoyal Institute of Philosophy Supplement, 2018
- Can Closed-mindedness be an Intellectual Virtue?Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement, 2018
- Intellectual humility and openness to the opposing viewSelf and Identity, 2017
- The Correlates of Discord: Identity, Issue Alignment, and Political Hostility in Polarized AmericaPolitical Behavior, 2016
- Intellectual humility and prosocial values: Direct and mediated effectsThe Journal of Positive Psychology, 2016
- The Development and Validation of the Comprehensive Intellectual Humility ScaleJournal of Personality Assessment, 2015
- HIGHER-ORDER EPISTEMIC ATTITUDES AND INTELLECTUAL HUMILITYEpisteme, 2012