Ian James Kidd
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Ian James Kidd has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Havi Carel
University of Bristol
4 shared publications - Lucienne Spencer
University of Oxford
4 shared publications - Eleanor Alexandra Byrne
University of Nottingham
2 shared publications - Donna Franklin
NEON Lived Experience Advisory Panel, Nottingham, UK
1 shared publication - Eleanor Palafox-Harris
University of Birmingham, UK
1 shared publication - Elvira Perez Vallejos
NIHR MindTech MedTech Co-Operative, Institute of Mental Health, School of Medicine, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in The Journal of Ethics
- p. 1-17
Philosophical Pessimism and the Heterogeneity of Suffering
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in The Journal of Ethics
- p. 1-17
Open AccessPhilosophical Pessimism and the Heterogeneity of Suffering
- Open Access
- 16 September 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 10, e89452
Ethical and Legal Considerations in the Collection and Analysis of Mental Health Lived Experience Narratives: Reflections on 4 Case Studies of Research Practice
Personal narratives describing lived experiences of the entire spectrum of mental health challenges are now widely available to the public, including through autobiographies from public figures, thematic collections of narratives assembled by mental health organizations, and individual narratives published on video sharing services. Mental health lived experience narratives have been used as an “active ingredient” in interventions intended to create change, such as in campaigns against mental health stigma. In the narrative inquiry research approach, they are used to explore mental health phenomenology. Researchers and organizations working with mental health lived experience narratives have to contend with a wide range of legal and ethical challenges, such as how to handle narratives disclosing sensitive personal information about third parties and the ethical trade-off between preserving narrator autonomy over their presentation of personal identity and protecting narrators from harm due to mental health stigma if a narrator is identifiable in their narrative. In 2022, we formed the Interdisciplinary Consortium on Narratives in Context (ICONIC) of people with knowledge of narrative practices across disciplines. Members are engaged in health research, liberal arts, modern languages, history, and philosophy. In this viewpoint, we present four case studies of narrative practices by ICONIC members: (1) a narrative inquiry into the experiences of Ethiopian citizens with schizophrenia, (2) work to curate and share 2 collections of mental health recovery narratives, (3) an exploration of the use of poetic transcription to condense narrative interviews with mental health content, and (4) the development of safe approaches to working with personal narratives shared through an online mental health peer support service. In presenting these case studies, we focused on documenting decision-making on ethical and legal challenges as the best knowledge on ethical and legal decision-making regarding mental health lived experience narratives may come from integrating knowledge across disciplines. Through reflecting on these case studies, we identified cross-cutting challenges regarding consent processes, narrative analysis, and the interpretation and dissemination of data and findings. These challenges have transdisciplinary and disciplinary-specific features and can be used as a preliminary checklist in research design processes. In presenting what we learned, our intent was to demonstrate that greater knowledge on narrative practices can emerge through interdisciplinary contact and inform future decision-making on narrative practices by researchers working across disciplines. We conclude by contemplating interdisciplinary explorations with the potential to expand knowledge, including examining the use of pathographic narratives in philosophical inquiry.
- 16 September 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 10, e89452
Open AccessEthical and Legal Considerations in the Collection and Analysis of Mental Health Lived Experience Narratives: Reflections on 4 Case Studies of Research Practice
Personal narratives describing lived experiences of the entire spectrum of mental health challenges are now widely available to the public, including through autobiographies from public figures, thematic collections of narratives assembled by mental health organizations, and individual narratives published on video sharing services. Mental health lived experience narratives have been used as an “active ingredient” in interventions intended to create change, such as in campaigns against mental health stigma. In the narrative inquiry research approach, they are used to explore mental health phenomenology. Researchers and organizations working with mental health lived experience narratives have to contend with a wide range of legal and ethical challenges, such as how to handle narratives disclosing sensitive personal information about third parties and the ethical trade-off between preserving narrator autonomy over their presentation of personal identity and protecting narrators from harm due to mental health stigma if a narrator is identifiable in their narrative. In 2022, we formed the Interdisciplinary Consortium on Narratives in Context (ICONIC) of people with knowledge of narrative practices across disciplines. Members are engaged in health research, liberal arts, modern languages, history, and philosophy. In this viewpoint, we present four case studies of narrative practices by ICONIC members: (1) a narrative inquiry into the experiences of Ethiopian citizens with schizophrenia, (2) work to curate and share 2 collections of mental health recovery narratives, (3) an exploration of the use of poetic transcription to condense narrative interviews with mental health content, and (4) the development of safe approaches to working with personal narratives shared through an online mental health peer support service. In presenting these case studies, we focused on documenting decision-making on ethical and legal challenges as the best knowledge on ethical and legal decision-making regarding mental health lived experience narratives may come from integrating knowledge across disciplines. Through reflecting on these case studies, we identified cross-cutting challenges regarding consent processes, narrative analysis, and the interpretation and dissemination of data and findings. These challenges have transdisciplinary and disciplinary-specific features and can be used as a preliminary checklist in research design processes. In presenting what we learned, our intent was to demonstrate that greater knowledge on narrative practices can emerge through interdisciplinary contact and inform future decision-making on narrative practices by researchers working across disciplines. We conclude by contemplating interdisciplinary explorations with the potential to expand knowledge, including examining the use of pathographic narratives in philosophical inquiry.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Religious Studies
- Vol. 62 (2) , 446-448
David E. Cooper Pessimism, Quietism and Nature as Refuge (Newcastle upon Tyne: Agenda, 2024). pp. xiv + 168. £18.99 (Pbk. ISBN 9781788217705)
Elegant new book defends a pessimistic and misanthropic appraisal of the human condition and recommends to us a style of 'quietism' inflected by a religious sensibility. Readers familiar with his work will find all his characteristic virtuesthe deployment of ideas from global philosophical and religious traditions, an economical style of writing leavened with literary and cultural learning, a judicious combination of analytical carefulness and existential reflectiveness, and a sobering perspective on the forms and possibilities of human life. The interest of this book for philosophers of religion should be, first, the centrality of Cooper's theme of the human condition to many religious traditions. In Chapter 1, the Buddha's discourses are used to develop a general account of the human condition-one from which anxiety and self-preoccupation and other kinds of suffering are inseparable. Unlike modern 'bright-siding' accounts of Buddhism, the bleak picture admits of no easy solution. We 'unenlightened worldling' are all 'burning' with craving, aversions, attachment, delusion. For many Christians, too, our condition is dominated by corruption, concupiscence, and sin. Cooper, in a section offering 'a brief history of pessimism', reminds us of a long history of sombre reflection on our moral and spiritual condition. This includes ways of responding to our condition, including temptations to 'denial' or, better, embracing the mood of 'disquiet' arising from sober reflection on human life (8-18). A second related interest for philosophers of religion concerns the content and tone of Cooper's characterization of the human condition. It is a bad-motivating pessimism and misanthropy in the philosophical senses of those terms: the human condition is a bad one, suffused with many bad features that cannot be corrected or removed, including a dense array of moral vices and failings. Such pessimism is not, argues Cooper, 'confined to a few German thinkers suffering from Weltschmerz', since a wider survey reveals pessimism and misanthropy to be 'perennial perspectives on the human condition, manifest in many philosophical and religious traditions' (12). Granted, there are historical and cultural variations in the exact content and implications for the conduct of life of these perspectives. Zhuangzi, Augustine, Calvin, Cioran, Benatar, and others disagree on the details, but agree our condition is enduringly and substantially negative. A third interest of Cooper's book for philosophers of religion will be the positive recommendation: the cultivation of modes of 'quietism' of a sort informed by Buddhism, Daoism, the Hellenistic, and Christian traditions and various contemporary literary and intellectual figures. In Chapters 2 and 3, Cooper rejects three responses to the dreadfulness
- 4 December 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Religious Studies
- Vol. 62 (2) , 446-448
Open AccessDavid E. Cooper Pessimism, Quietism and Nature as Refuge (Newcastle upon Tyne: Agenda, 2024). pp. xiv + 168. £18.99 (Pbk. ISBN 9781788217705)
Elegant new book defends a pessimistic and misanthropic appraisal of the human condition and recommends to us a style of 'quietism' inflected by a religious sensibility. Readers familiar with his work will find all his characteristic virtuesthe deployment of ideas from global philosophical and religious traditions, an economical style of writing leavened with literary and cultural learning, a judicious combination of analytical carefulness and existential reflectiveness, and a sobering perspective on the forms and possibilities of human life. The interest of this book for philosophers of religion should be, first, the centrality of Cooper's theme of the human condition to many religious traditions. In Chapter 1, the Buddha's discourses are used to develop a general account of the human condition-one from which anxiety and self-preoccupation and other kinds of suffering are inseparable. Unlike modern 'bright-siding' accounts of Buddhism, the bleak picture admits of no easy solution. We 'unenlightened worldling' are all 'burning' with craving, aversions, attachment, delusion. For many Christians, too, our condition is dominated by corruption, concupiscence, and sin. Cooper, in a section offering 'a brief history of pessimism', reminds us of a long history of sombre reflection on our moral and spiritual condition. This includes ways of responding to our condition, including temptations to 'denial' or, better, embracing the mood of 'disquiet' arising from sober reflection on human life (8-18). A second related interest for philosophers of religion concerns the content and tone of Cooper's characterization of the human condition. It is a bad-motivating pessimism and misanthropy in the philosophical senses of those terms: the human condition is a bad one, suffused with many bad features that cannot be corrected or removed, including a dense array of moral vices and failings. Such pessimism is not, argues Cooper, 'confined to a few German thinkers suffering from Weltschmerz', since a wider survey reveals pessimism and misanthropy to be 'perennial perspectives on the human condition, manifest in many philosophical and religious traditions' (12). Granted, there are historical and cultural variations in the exact content and implications for the conduct of life of these perspectives. Zhuangzi, Augustine, Calvin, Cioran, Benatar, and others disagree on the details, but agree our condition is enduringly and substantially negative. A third interest of Cooper's book for philosophers of religion will be the positive recommendation: the cultivation of modes of 'quietism' of a sort informed by Buddhism, Daoism, the Hellenistic, and Christian traditions and various contemporary literary and intellectual figures. In Chapters 2 and 3, Cooper rejects three responses to the dreadfulness
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 33-47
Feyerabend and Marx
- Open Access
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Epistemology
- Vol. 39 (2) , 150-165
Individual Vices and Institutional Failings as Drivers of Vulnerabilisation
This paper explores the phenomenon of vulnerabilisation in relation to the experiences of persons with chronic illnesses. We distinguish a range of kinds of vulnerability, including epistemic vulnerabilities related to epistemic injustices, and describe various interpersonal and institutional processes which can create, exacerbate, and intensify those vulnerabilities. The dynamics of vulnerablisation are related to individual vices and institutional failings, the the pervasive pathophobia of many societies, and various contingent life-events. We conclude that susceptibility to varieties of vulnerabilisation is ultimately reflective of the fragility that is definitive of the human condition.
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Epistemology
- Vol. 39 (2) , 150-165
Open AccessIndividual Vices and Institutional Failings as Drivers of Vulnerabilisation
This paper explores the phenomenon of vulnerabilisation in relation to the experiences of persons with chronic illnesses. We distinguish a range of kinds of vulnerability, including epistemic vulnerabilities related to epistemic injustices, and describe various interpersonal and institutional processes which can create, exacerbate, and intensify those vulnerabilities. The dynamics of vulnerablisation are related to individual vices and institutional failings, the the pervasive pathophobia of many societies, and various contingent life-events. We conclude that susceptibility to varieties of vulnerabilisation is ultimately reflective of the fragility that is definitive of the human condition.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Project MUSE in Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology
- Vol. 31 (3) , 235-238
Religion, Psychiatry, and “Radical” Epistemic Injustices
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Project MUSE in Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology
- Vol. 31 (3) , 235-238
Religion, Psychiatry, and “Radical” Epistemic Injustices
- Open Access
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy in Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy
- Vol. 27 (2) , 211-233
Is Intellectual Humility Compatible with Political Conviction?
Intellectual humility is often proposed, these days, as an antidote to the profound lack of respect, tolerance, and openness to other views in contemporary politics. Moreover, deficiencies of intellectual humility are clearly at work in now-familiar displays, in political discourse, of arrogance, dogmatism and related phenomena, like polarization. Although we agree that there are roles for intellectual humility, we identify two problems. First, previous research on the relationship between intellectual humility and political conviction has ignored empirical and theoretical work indicating that humility does often result in apathy or lack of political conviction. Second, there are different forms or kinds of intellectual humility which can relate to political conviction in many ways. We end the paper by describing a kind of political quietism, which includes quite different accounts of the nature of intellectual humility.
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy in Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy
- Vol. 27 (2) , 211-233
Open AccessIs Intellectual Humility Compatible with Political Conviction?
Intellectual humility is often proposed, these days, as an antidote to the profound lack of respect, tolerance, and openness to other views in contemporary politics. Moreover, deficiencies of intellectual humility are clearly at work in now-familiar displays, in political discourse, of arrogance, dogmatism and related phenomena, like polarization. Although we agree that there are roles for intellectual humility, we identify two problems. First, previous research on the relationship between intellectual humility and political conviction has ignored empirical and theoretical work indicating that humility does often result in apathy or lack of political conviction. Second, there are different forms or kinds of intellectual humility which can relate to political conviction in many ways. We end the paper by describing a kind of political quietism, which includes quite different accounts of the nature of intellectual humility.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Philosophy Documentation Center in Epistemology & Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 61 (3) , 191-211
Feyerabend on Human Life, Abstraction, and the Conquest of Abundance
I offer a new interpretation of Feyerabend’s ‘conquest of abundance’ narrative. I consider and reject both the ontological reading as implausible and the ‘historical’ reading as uncompelling. My own proposal is that the ‘conquest of abundance’ be understood in terms of an impoverishment of the richness of human experience. For Feyerabend, such abundance is ‘conquered’ when individuals internalize distorting epistemic prejudices including those integral to the theoretical conceptions associated with the sciences. I describe several ways, identified by Feyerabend, in which individuals can be led to occlude the richness of their experience in ways that are existentially impoverishing.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Philosophy Documentation Center in Epistemology & Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 61 (3) , 191-211
Open AccessFeyerabend on Human Life, Abstraction, and the Conquest of Abundance
I offer a new interpretation of Feyerabend’s ‘conquest of abundance’ narrative. I consider and reject both the ontological reading as implausible and the ‘historical’ reading as uncompelling. My own proposal is that the ‘conquest of abundance’ be understood in terms of an impoverishment of the richness of human experience. For Feyerabend, such abundance is ‘conquered’ when individuals internalize distorting epistemic prejudices including those integral to the theoretical conceptions associated with the sciences. I describe several ways, identified by Feyerabend, in which individuals can be led to occlude the richness of their experience in ways that are existentially impoverishing.