Evaluating Undersampling Schemes and Deep Learning Reconstructions for High-Resolution 3D Double Echo Steady State Knee Imaging at 7 T: A Comparison Between GRAPPA, CAIPIRINHA, and Compressed Sensing
Authors:
- Thomas Dr. Med. Univ. MarthTMThomas Dr. Med. Univ. Marth
- Adrian Alexander MarthAMAdrian Alexander Marth
- Georg Wilhelm KajdiGKGeorg Wilhelm Kajdi
- Marcel Dominik NickelMNMarcel Dominik Nickel
- Dominik PaulDPDominik Paul
- Reto SutterRSReto Sutter
- Daniel NanzDNDaniel Nanz
- Constantin von DeusterCDConstantin von Deuster
- 25 February 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Investigative Radiology
- Vol. 60 (9) , 609-615
Abstract
Objective: The 3-dimensional (3D) double echo steady state (DESS) magnetic resonance imaging sequence can image knee cartilage with high, isotropic resolution, particularly at high and ultra-high field strengths. Advanced undersampling techniques with high acceleration factors can provide the short acquisition times required for clinical use. However, the optimal undersampling scheme and its limits are unknown. Materials and Methods: High-resolution isotropic (reconstructed voxel size: 0.3 × 0.3 × 0.3 mm3) 3D DESS images of 40 knees in 20 volunteers were acquired at 7 T with varying undersampling factors (R = 4–30) and schemes (regular: GRAPPA, CAIPIRINHA; incoherent: compressed sensing [CS]), whereas the remaining imaging parameters were kept constant. All imaging data were reconstructed with deep learning (DL) algorithms. Three readers rated image quality on a 4-point Likert scale. Four-fold accelerated GRAPPA was used as reference standard. Incidental cartilage lesions were graded on a modified Whole-Organ Magnetic Resonance Imaging Score (WORMS). Friedman's analysis of variance characterized rating differences. The interreader agreement was assessed using κ statistics. Results: The quality of 16-fold accelerated CS images was not rated significantly different from that of 4-fold accelerated GRAPPA and 8-fold accelerated CAIPIRINHA images, whereas the corresponding data were acquired 4.5 and 2 times faster (01:12 min:s) than in 4-fold accelerated GRAPPA (5:22 min:s) and 8-fold accelerated CAIPIRINHA (2:22 min:s) acquisitions, respectively. Interreader agreement for incidental cartilage lesions was almost perfect for 4-fold accelerated GRAPPA (κ = 0.91), 8-fold accelerated CAIPIRINHA (κ = 0.86), and 8- to 16-fold accelerated CS (κ = 0.91). Conclusions: Our results suggest significant advantages of incoherent versus regular undersampling patterns for high-resolution 3D DESS cartilage imaging with high acceleration factors. The combination of CS undersampling with DL reconstruction enables fast, isotropic, high-resolution acquisitions without apparent impairment of image quality. Since DESS specific absorption rate values tend to be moderate, CS DESS with DL reconstruction promises potential for high-resolution assessment of cartilage morphology and other musculoskeletal anatomies at 7 T.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- 3D-DESS MRI with CAIPIRINHA two- and fourfold acceleration for quantitatively assessing knee cartilage morphologySkeletal Radiology, 2024
- Ultra-high resolution 3D MRI for chondrocalcinosis detection in the knee—a prospective diagnostic accuracy study comparing 7-tesla and 3-tesla MRI with CTEuropean Radiology, 2021
- Association of blood pressure with knee cartilage composition and structural knee abnormalities: data from the osteoarthritis initiativeSkeletal Radiology, 2020
- Learning a variational network for reconstruction of accelerated MRI dataMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2017
- 3D double-echo steady-state sequence assessment of hip joint cartilage and labrum at 3 Tesla: comparative analysis of magnetic resonance imaging and intraoperative dataEuropean Radiology, 2017
- Interobserver reproducibility of quantitative meniscus analysis using coronal multiplanar DESS and IWTSE MR imagingMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2011
- Routine 3D magnetic resonance imaging of jointsJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 2011
- Controlled aliasing in parallel imaging results in higher acceleration (CAIPIRINHA) for multi‐slice imagingMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2005
- Generalized autocalibrating partially parallel acquisitions (GRAPPA)Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2002
- SENSE: Sensitivity encoding for fast MRIMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 1999