Opt-out and consent
- 2 June 2015
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 41 (10) , 832-835
Abstract
A chief objection to opt-out organ donor registration policies is that they do not secure people's actual consent to donation, and so fail to respect their autonomy rights to decide what happens to their organs after they die. However, scholars have recently offered two powerful responses to this objection. First, Michael B Gill argues that opt-out policies do not fail to respect people's autonomy simply because they do not secure people's actual consent to donation. Second, Ben Saunders argues that opt-out policies do secure people's actual—if not explicit—consent, provided that certain conditions are satisfied. I argue that Gill and Saunders’ arguments are not successful. My conclusion does not imply that jurisdictions should not implement opt-out policies—their failure to secure people's actual consent may be outweighed by other considerations. But, my conclusion does imply that Gill and Saunders are mistaken to claim that opt-out policies are respectful of people's autonomy.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Consent and the Use of the Bodies of the DeadThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2012
- Transplantation and Rights over Our Bodies2011
- Opt-out organ donation without presumptionsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2011
- Tacitly consenting to donate one's organsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2011
- Can Consent be Presumed?Journal of Applied Philosophy, 2011
- Normative consent and opt-out organ donationJournal of Medical Ethics, 2010
- Therapeutic misconception and the appreciation of risks in clinical trialsSocial Science & Medicine, 2004
- Presumed Consent, Autonomy, and Organ DonationThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2004
- Quality of informed consent in cancer clinical trials: a cross-sectional surveyThe Lancet, 2001
- The primary ethical framework: patient-centered principles1990