Eyewitness suspect identification: six claims regarding the state of the science
Open Access
- 28 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Memory
- p. 1-8
Abstract
Psychological science on eyewitness suspect identification has a long and rich history. A few decades ago, modal expert opinion emphasised eyewitnesses' fallibility, and it was widely held that identifications made with high confidence are only slightly more likely to be accurate than those made with low confidence. The authors of this invited Contemporary Discussion agree that current science compels a more nuanced perspective in which the relationship between eyewitnesses' confidence and their accuracy varies predictably depending on specifics of how the suspect was selected, how the identification test was designed, when and how it was administered, and when confidence was assessed. We tender claims regarding conditions under which we believe lineup identification responses can be strongly inculpating. We also articulate claims regarding conditions under which we believe identification responses can be strongly exculpating. While most of the claims described herein were previously advanced by individual scientists, what is new - and important - is that they now reflect an emerging scientific consensus. We do not assert that every claim is firmly established, but we advance arguments for believing they are true. In addition, we propose multiple lines of laboratory and field studies aimed at advancing understanding of these issues.Keywords
This publication has 82 references indexed in Scilit:
- Eyewitness identifications based on biased or unbiased line‐up instructions after a realistic and violent hostage simulationJournal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 2023
- From Witness to Web Sleuth: Does Citizen Enquiry on Social Media Affect Formal Eyewitness Identification Procedures?Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 2021
- An Interdisciplinary and Cross-national Analysis of Legal Safeguards for Eyewitness Evidence2020
- Double Exposure: The Effects of Repeated Identification Lineups on Eyewitness AccuracyApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2013
- Live Showups and Their Influence on a Subsequent Video Line‐upApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2011
- The effect of retention interval on the confidence–accuracy relationship for eyewitness identification.Law and Human Behavior, 2010
- Recent Developments in Eyewitness Identification Procedures in the United Kingdom2009
- On the diagnosticity of multiple-witness identifications.Law and Human Behavior, 2008
- Effects of mugshot commitment on lineup performance in young and older adultsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2008
- Mugshot Exposure Effects: Retroactive Interference, Mugshot Commitment, Source Confusion, and Unconscious Transference.Law and Human Behavior, 2006