I formalize free will through three choice axioms: reasons-responsive control, irreducible alternativism, and constructive sourcehood. For open systems, sourcehood implies alternativism; control is independent of both. A deliberately stochastic rule satisfies alternativism but admits a non-invasive classical extension, separating the two openness conditions. A quantum system with two binary contexts satisfies all three axioms and yields an explicit discrepancy between direct and sequenced probabilities. The separation concerns non-invasive representations; classical processes with state disturbance can also satisfy the axioms.