Pressure garment to prevent abnormal scarring after burn injury in adults and children: the PEGASUS feasibility RCT and mixed-methods study
Authors:
- Naiem MoiemenNaiem Moiemen
- Jonathan MathersJMJonathan Mathers
- Laura JonesLJLaura Jones
- Jonathan BishopJBJonathan Bishop
- Philip KinghornPKPhilip Kinghorn
- Mark MonahanMMMark Monahan
- Melanie CalvertMCMelanie Calvert
- Gemma SlinnGSGemma Slinn
- Fay GardinerFGFay Gardiner
- Amy BamfordABAmy Bamford
- Susan WrightSWSusan Wright
- Ian LitchfieldILIan Litchfield
- 1 June 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Technology Assessment
- Vol. 22 (36) , 1-162
Abstract
Background: Eleven million people suffer a fire-related injury worldwide every year, and 71% have significant scarring. Pressure garment therapy (PGT) is a standard part of burn scar management, but there is little evidence of its clinical effectiveness or cost-effectiveness. Objective: To identify the barriers to, and the facilitators of, conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of burn scar management with and without PGT and test whether or not such a trial is feasible. Design: Web-based surveys, semistructured individual interviews, a pilot RCT including a health economic evaluation and embedded process evaluation. Setting: UK NHS burns services. Interviews and the pilot trial were run in seven burns services. Participants: Thirty NHS burns services and 245 staff provided survey responses and 15 staff participated in individual interviews. Face-to-face interviews were held with 24 adult patients and 16 parents of paediatric patients who had undergone PGT. The pilot trial recruited 88 participants (57 adults and 31 children) who were at risk of hypertrophic scarring and were considered suitable for scar management therapy. Interviews were held with 34 participants soon after recruitment, with 23 participants at 12 months and with eight staff from six sites at the end of the trial. Interventions: The intervention was standard care with pressure garments. The control was standard care comprising scar management techniques involving demonstration and recommendations to undertake massage three or four times per day with moisturiser, silicone treatment, stretching and other exercises. Main outcome measures: Feasibility was assessed by eligibility rates, consent rates, retention in allocated arms, adherence with treatment and follow-up and completion of outcome assessments. The outcomes from interview-based studies were core outcome domains and barriers to, and facilitators of, trial participation and delivery. Results: NHS burns services treat 2845 patients per annum (1476 paediatric and 1369 adult) and use pressure garments for 6–18 months, costing £2,171,184. The majority of staff perceived a need for a RCT of PGT, but often lacked equipoise around the research question and PGT as a treatment. Strong views about the use of PGT have the potential to influence the conduct of a full-scale RCT. A range of outcome domains was identified as important via the qualitative research: perceptions of appearance, specific scar characteristics, function, pain and itch, broader psychosocial outcomes and treatment burden. The outcome tools evaluated in the pilot trial did not cover all of these domains. The planned 88 participants were recruited: the eligibility rate was 88% [95% confidence interval (CI) 83% to 92%], the consent rate was 47% (95% CI 40% to 55%). Five (6%) participants withdrew, 14 (16%) were lost to follow-up and 8 (9%) crossed over. Adherence was as in clinical practice. Completion of outcomes was high for adult patients but poorer from parents of paediatric patients, particularly for quality of life. Sections on range of movement and willingness to pay were found to be challenging and poorly completed. Limitations: The Brisbane Burn Scar Impact Profile appears more suitable in terms of conceptual coverage than the outcome scales that were used in the trial but was not available at the time of the study. Conclusions: A definitive RCT of PGT in burn scar management appears feasible. However, staff attitudes to the use of pressure garments may lead to biases, and the provision of training and support to sites and an ongoing assessment of trial processes are required. Future work: We recommend that any future trial include an in-depth mixed-methods recruitment investigation and a process evaluation to account for this. Trial registration: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN34483199. Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme and will be published in full in Health Technology Assessment; Vol. 22, No. 36. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project informationKeywords
Funding Information
- Health Technology Assessment Programme (12/145/04)
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Valuation of the Child Health Utility 9D IndexPharmacoEconomics, 2012
- Effect of different pressure magnitudes on hypertrophic scar in a Chinese populationBurns, 2010
- 12-Year within-wound study of the effectiveness of custom pressure garment therapyBurns, 2010
- Reasons for participating in randomised controlled trials: conditional altruism and considerations for selfTrials, 2010
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- The assessment of erythema and thickness on burn related scars during pressure garment therapy as a preventive measure for hypertrophic scarringBurns, 2005
- The Effects of High Versus Low Pressure Garments in the Control of Hypertrophic Scar in the Burned Child: A Final ReportJournal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation, 2001
- The Effects of Pressure Versus No Pressure Garments in the Control Hypertrophic Scarring in Children with Small Burns: A Preliminary 6 Month ReportJournal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation, 2000
- Effectiveness of Custom Pressure Garments in Wound Management: A Prospective Trial Within Wounds and With Verified PressureJournal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation, 2000
- Historical notes on the use of pressure in the treatment of hypertrophic scars or keloidsBurns, 1993