The recent turn in analytical sociology: The dismissal of general theories, mental states, and analytic philosophy – and the old issue of mechanism explanations
Open Access
- 27 May 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Information
- Vol. 63 (2) , 131-154
Abstract
Analytical sociology is a sociological approach whose advocates share two methodological doctrines: sociology should be a rigorous discipline and focus on action-based explanations of social processes. This article analyzes some recent methodological innovations of analytical sociology: (1) it is proposed to abandon general theories, in particular rational choice theory. We raise several objections against this claim. The major argument for applying general theories is that an empirical comparison with middle range theories implies conditions for their modification and at the same time tests the general theory. Another flaw of the critique of rational choice theory is that the target is not a wide ‘bounded rationality’ version that is increasingly applied in the social sciences. Instead, an outdated narrow version is attacked; (2) a new demand is to give up explanations with mental states such as goals and beliefs and focus on situational factors. It is argued that this leads to false explanations because the impact of situational factors on action depends on mental states. Omitting mental states thus leads to invalid explanations; (3) a major unresolved issue is the thesis that mechanism explanations are a special kind of explanation that do not need to apply theories. It is shown why this demand is mistaken.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- How to Escape from Model Platonism in Economics: Critical Assumptions, Robust Conclusions, and Approximate ExplanationsHomo Oeconomicus, 2022
- Analytical Sociology and Symbolic Interactionism: Bridging the Intra-disciplinary DivideThe American Sociologist, 2021
- General Theory and Global Criminology: Childhood Environments, Problem Behaviors, and a Focus on PreventionAsian Journal of Criminology, 2018
- Cognitive Autonomy and Methodological Individualism2015
- Analytical sociology and rational‐choice theory2014
- Data, generative models, and mechanisms: More on the principles of analytical sociology2014
- Analytische Soziologie und Rational Choice2010
- Explanations by mechanisms in the social sciences. Problems, advantages and alternativesMind & Society, 2005
- Low self-control, rational choice, and student test cheatingAmerican Journal of Criminal Justice, 1999
- Theories of the middle range as a strategy for the construction of a general sociological theoryQuality & Quantity, 1970