Karl-Dieter Opp
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Karl-Dieter Opp has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Christiane Gern
1 shared publication- Heike Diefenbach
Chapel Cottage, King Street, Odiham, Hants, RG29 1NH, UK
1 shared publication - Lieven J. R. Pauwels
Faculty of Law and Criminology, Department of Criminology, Ghent University, Criminal Law and Social Law, Gent, Belgium
1 shared publication Michael Beck
1 shared publication- Michael Mäs
Sociology and Computational Social Science, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Douglasstraße 24, Karlsruhe, Baden-Württemberg, 76131, GERMANY
1 shared publication - Mühler
Universität Leipzig
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie
- Vol. 78 (3) , 1-30
The Methodology of the Cologne School of Sociology as a Precursor of Analytical–Empirical Sociology: Strengths and Weaknesses
This paper focuses on the methodology (i.e., the philosophy of science) of the so-called Cologne School of sociology, which was founded after World War II by René König. Although there is extensive literature about the history of Cologne Sociology, its methodology has not yet been examined in detail. That is the subject of this article. The first step is to reconstruct the rules and assumptions underlying this methodology. Since the underlying methodology is critical rationalism, this methodology is applied to describe the strengths and weaknesses of the Cologne methodology. A major strength was the rigorous testing of descriptive hypotheses and middle-range theories. Weaknesses included the lack of micro–macro modeling and the absence of systematic application of general action theories. The paper also discusses the introduction of methodological individualism and the codification of the Cologne methodology in the 1960s and early 1970s. The final part outlines the diffusion of the Cologne methodology as a precursor of modern analytical–empirical sociology, along with suggestions for further research.
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie
- Vol. 78 (3) , 1-30
Open AccessThe Methodology of the Cologne School of Sociology as a Precursor of Analytical–Empirical Sociology: Strengths and Weaknesses
This paper focuses on the methodology (i.e., the philosophy of science) of the so-called Cologne School of sociology, which was founded after World War II by René König. Although there is extensive literature about the history of Cologne Sociology, its methodology has not yet been examined in detail. That is the subject of this article. The first step is to reconstruct the rules and assumptions underlying this methodology. Since the underlying methodology is critical rationalism, this methodology is applied to describe the strengths and weaknesses of the Cologne methodology. A major strength was the rigorous testing of descriptive hypotheses and middle-range theories. Weaknesses included the lack of micro–macro modeling and the absence of systematic application of general action theories. The paper also discusses the introduction of methodological individualism and the codification of the Cologne methodology in the 1960s and early 1970s. The final part outlines the diffusion of the Cologne methodology as a precursor of modern analytical–empirical sociology, along with suggestions for further research.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Rationality and Society
- Vol. 38 (1) , 6-41
How to integrate theories of norm emergence. The example of James S. Coleman’s and Robert C. Ellickson’s theories
There are different theories that aim at explaining the emergence of norms (defined as statements about oughtness). It is not known which theory is superior. This paper is a first attempt to propose a new integrated norm theory, based on two plausible and widely accepted theories: James Coleman’s and Robert Ellickson’s theories about the origin of norms. After discussing methodological issues referring, among other things, to arguments for integrating the theories, the new theory is proposed. Among other things, it does not only explain norms as effects of externalities (as Coleman’s theory), but also as signals to express distinctiveness and group commitment (with the example of the Hells Angels motor club). Coleman’s theory is further modified by integrating from Ellickson’s theory a set of variables that intervene between the exogenous variable “close social relationships” and the origin of norms. The model includes transaction costs and cooperation as intervening factors. Furthermore, “overarching norms” (from Ellickson’s research) is added as a new condition for the origin of norms.
- 10 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Rationality and Society
- Vol. 38 (1) , 6-41
Open AccessHow to integrate theories of norm emergence. The example of James S. Coleman’s and Robert C. Ellickson’s theories
There are different theories that aim at explaining the emergence of norms (defined as statements about oughtness). It is not known which theory is superior. This paper is a first attempt to propose a new integrated norm theory, based on two plausible and widely accepted theories: James Coleman’s and Robert Ellickson’s theories about the origin of norms. After discussing methodological issues referring, among other things, to arguments for integrating the theories, the new theory is proposed. Among other things, it does not only explain norms as effects of externalities (as Coleman’s theory), but also as signals to express distinctiveness and group commitment (with the example of the Hells Angels motor club). Coleman’s theory is further modified by integrating from Ellickson’s theory a set of variables that intervene between the exogenous variable “close social relationships” and the origin of norms. The model includes transaction costs and cooperation as intervening factors. Furthermore, “overarching norms” (from Ellickson’s research) is added as a new condition for the origin of norms.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Mohr Siebeck
Die Entstehung sozialer Normen
Die Entstehung sozialer Normen. Ein Integrationsversuch soziologischer, sozialpsychologischer und ökonomischer Erklärungen
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Mohr Siebeck
Die Entstehung sozialer Normen
Die Entstehung sozialer Normen. Ein Integrationsversuch soziologischer, sozialpsychologischer und ökonomischer Erklärungen
- Open Access
- 27 May 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Information
- Vol. 63 (2) , 131-154
The recent turn in analytical sociology: The dismissal of general theories, mental states, and analytic philosophy – and the old issue of mechanism explanations
Analytical sociology is a sociological approach whose advocates share two methodological doctrines: sociology should be a rigorous discipline and focus on action-based explanations of social processes. This article analyzes some recent methodological innovations of analytical sociology: (1) it is proposed to abandon general theories, in particular rational choice theory. We raise several objections against this claim. The major argument for applying general theories is that an empirical comparison with middle range theories implies conditions for their modification and at the same time tests the general theory. Another flaw of the critique of rational choice theory is that the target is not a wide ‘bounded rationality’ version that is increasingly applied in the social sciences. Instead, an outdated narrow version is attacked; (2) a new demand is to give up explanations with mental states such as goals and beliefs and focus on situational factors. It is argued that this leads to false explanations because the impact of situational factors on action depends on mental states. Omitting mental states thus leads to invalid explanations; (3) a major unresolved issue is the thesis that mechanism explanations are a special kind of explanation that do not need to apply theories. It is shown why this demand is mistaken.
- 27 May 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Information
- Vol. 63 (2) , 131-154
Open AccessThe recent turn in analytical sociology: The dismissal of general theories, mental states, and analytic philosophy – and the old issue of mechanism explanations
Analytical sociology is a sociological approach whose advocates share two methodological doctrines: sociology should be a rigorous discipline and focus on action-based explanations of social processes. This article analyzes some recent methodological innovations of analytical sociology: (1) it is proposed to abandon general theories, in particular rational choice theory. We raise several objections against this claim. The major argument for applying general theories is that an empirical comparison with middle range theories implies conditions for their modification and at the same time tests the general theory. Another flaw of the critique of rational choice theory is that the target is not a wide ‘bounded rationality’ version that is increasingly applied in the social sciences. Instead, an outdated narrow version is attacked; (2) a new demand is to give up explanations with mental states such as goals and beliefs and focus on situational factors. It is argued that this leads to false explanations because the impact of situational factors on action depends on mental states. Omitting mental states thus leads to invalid explanations; (3) a major unresolved issue is the thesis that mechanism explanations are a special kind of explanation that do not need to apply theories. It is shown why this demand is mistaken.
- 3 September 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 89-116
When Do People Follow the Behavior of Others? The Effects of Descriptive and Injunctive Norms, and the Werther Effect
- 3 September 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 89-116
When Do People Follow the Behavior of Others? The Effects of Descriptive and Injunctive Norms, and the Werther Effect
- 5 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 6-20
The concept of crime, the definition of “theory,” and the characteristics of a good theory
“Crime” is defined in this book as an action or inaction that violates the criminal law. The reason for choosing this definition is its theoretical fruitfulness (which is discussed in the text). A “theory” is defined a set of general statements (not referring to certain times and places) about conditions that bring about some phenomena. The analysis of theories is the major concern of this book. It is therefore necessary to discuss the requirements a theory should fulfill: its concepts and structure (i.e. its dependent and independent variables and their relationships) should be precise; the theory should be valid and should have a high informative content. This means that it should explain a large number of specific phenomena and should have a wide range or application. It is criticized that much of the criminological literature consists of “orienting propositions” with a low informative content. For example, the hypothesis that an environmental input has an effect on perception does not tell us which environmental input leads to which kinds of perception. This is an example for the “poverty of orienting hypotheses.” Based on the logic of deductive-nomological explanation, we show that an acceptable mechanism explanation requires laws.
- 5 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 6-20
The concept of crime, the definition of “theory,” and the characteristics of a good theory
“Crime” is defined in this book as an action or inaction that violates the criminal law. The reason for choosing this definition is its theoretical fruitfulness (which is discussed in the text). A “theory” is defined a set of general statements (not referring to certain times and places) about conditions that bring about some phenomena. The analysis of theories is the major concern of this book. It is therefore necessary to discuss the requirements a theory should fulfill: its concepts and structure (i.e. its dependent and independent variables and their relationships) should be precise; the theory should be valid and should have a high informative content. This means that it should explain a large number of specific phenomena and should have a wide range or application. It is criticized that much of the criminological literature consists of “orienting propositions” with a low informative content. For example, the hypothesis that an environmental input has an effect on perception does not tell us which environmental input leads to which kinds of perception. This is an example for the “poverty of orienting hypotheses.” Based on the logic of deductive-nomological explanation, we show that an acceptable mechanism explanation requires laws.
- 1 April 2019
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Zeitschrift Fur Soziologie
- Vol. 48 (2) , 97-115
Die Theorie rationalen Handelns, das Modell der Frame-Selektion und die Wirkungen von Bestrafungen auf Kooperation
Zusammenfassung: Fehr & Gächter (2000, 2002) überprüfen in einem Kollektivgut-Experiment Hypothesen über die Wirkungen von Bestrafungen auf Kooperation. Hartmut Esser (2018, in dieser Zeitschrift) behauptet, dass zentrale Ergebnisse des Experiments der „rational choice“-Theorie (RCT) widersprechen und das Modell der Frame-Selektion (MFS) bestätigen. Es wird gezeigt, dass Esser eine problematische enge Version der RCT heranzieht. Eine „weite“ Version weist die von Esser behandelten Probleme nicht auf und kann die Ergebnisse des Experiments erklären. Weiter wird auf gravierende Probleme des MFS hingewiesen, die die Erklärung der experimentellen Befunde fragwürdig erscheinen lassen. Die Analyse zeigt weiter, dass das MFS eine Ergänzung und nicht eine Alternative zu einer weiten RCT ist und auf keinen Fall die übergreifende „general theory of action“ ist, wie Esser behauptet.
- 1 April 2019
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Zeitschrift Fur Soziologie
- Vol. 48 (2) , 97-115
Die Theorie rationalen Handelns, das Modell der Frame-Selektion und die Wirkungen von Bestrafungen auf Kooperation
Zusammenfassung: Fehr & Gächter (2000, 2002) überprüfen in einem Kollektivgut-Experiment Hypothesen über die Wirkungen von Bestrafungen auf Kooperation. Hartmut Esser (2018, in dieser Zeitschrift) behauptet, dass zentrale Ergebnisse des Experiments der „rational choice“-Theorie (RCT) widersprechen und das Modell der Frame-Selektion (MFS) bestätigen. Es wird gezeigt, dass Esser eine problematische enge Version der RCT heranzieht. Eine „weite“ Version weist die von Esser behandelten Probleme nicht auf und kann die Ergebnisse des Experiments erklären. Weiter wird auf gravierende Probleme des MFS hingewiesen, die die Erklärung der experimentellen Befunde fragwürdig erscheinen lassen. Die Analyse zeigt weiter, dass das MFS eine Ergänzung und nicht eine Alternative zu einer weiten RCT ist und auf keinen Fall die übergreifende „general theory of action“ ist, wie Esser behauptet.
- 14 August 2018
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Soziologische Revue
- Vol. 41 (3) , 525-529
John H. Goldthorpe, Sociology as a Population Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2016, 168 S., kt., 18,72 €
- 14 August 2018
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Soziologische Revue
- Vol. 41 (3) , 525-529
John H. Goldthorpe, Sociology as a Population Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2016, 168 S., kt., 18,72 €
- 11 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 65-95
Can Attitude Theory Improve Rational Choice Theory or Vice Versa?
- 11 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 65-95
Can Attitude Theory Improve Rational Choice Theory or Vice Versa?