Autonomy, Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Open Access
- 17 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Abstract
Across three studies (n = 155) adolescent learners freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. Our purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used (Studies 1-3), (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process (Studies 1-3), and (c) investigate the role of autonomy (Studies 2 and 3). Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Participants completed an autonomy assessment pre- and post-random assignment to three conditions manipulating explanations. Consistent were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited. We additionally find increased levels of reported autonomy from learners by condition, respectively. Individual differences in autonomy supporting belief revision is also found. Overall, explaining facilitated belief revision, all the while, underscoring the need to consider the impact of autonomy for adolescent learners confronted with disconfirming evidence prompting belief revision.Keywords
This publication has 86 references indexed in Scilit:
- Designing for Epistemic Development2024
- Uncovering Student Strategies for Solving Scientific Inquiry Tasks: Insights from Student Process Data in PISAResearch in Science Education, 2023
- Rethinking the “gap”:Self‐directedlearning in cognitive development and scientific reasoningWIREs Cognitive Science, 2021
- Choose Your EvidenceScience & Education, 2021
- Identifying patterns of students' performance on simulated inquiry tasks using PISA 2015 log‐file dataJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2020
- Choice within limits: how the institutional context of forced relocation affects tenants’ housing searches and choice strategiesJournal of Housing and the Built Environment, 2013
- Self‐determination theory and work motivationJournal of Organizational Behavior, 2005
- Structured leisure activities in middle childhood: Links to well‐beingJournal of Community Psychology, 2003
- The Development of Scientific Reasoning SkillsDevelopmental Review, 2000
- Conceptualizations of Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination1985