Anahid S. Modrek
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Anahid S. Modrek has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Deanna Kuhn
Teachers College New York New York Columbia University
6 shared publications- Deanna Kuhn
Teachers College, Columbia University
3 shared publications William A. Sandoval
School of Education & Information Studies, UCLA United States
3 shared publicationsAnne Conway
2 shared publications- Anne Conway
Columbia University
2 shared publications Alexander Kwako
School of Education & Information Studies, UCLA United States
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 September 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Autonomy, Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Across three studies (n = 155) adolescent learners freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. Our purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used (Studies 1-3), (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process (Studies 1-3), and (c) investigate the role of autonomy (Studies 2 and 3). Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Participants completed an autonomy assessment pre- and post-random assignment to three conditions manipulating explanations. Consistent were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited. We additionally find increased levels of reported autonomy from learners by condition, respectively. Individual differences in autonomy supporting belief revision is also found. Overall, explaining facilitated belief revision, all the while, underscoring the need to consider the impact of autonomy for adolescent learners confronted with disconfirming evidence prompting belief revision.
- 12 September 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Open AccessAutonomy, Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Across three studies (n = 155) adolescent learners freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. Our purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used (Studies 1-3), (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process (Studies 1-3), and (c) investigate the role of autonomy (Studies 2 and 3). Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Participants completed an autonomy assessment pre- and post-random assignment to three conditions manipulating explanations. Consistent were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited. We additionally find increased levels of reported autonomy from learners by condition, respectively. Individual differences in autonomy supporting belief revision is also found. Overall, explaining facilitated belief revision, all the while, underscoring the need to consider the impact of autonomy for adolescent learners confronted with disconfirming evidence prompting belief revision.
- Open Access
- 17 July 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Autonomy, Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Across three studies (n = 155) adolescent learners freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. Our purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used (Studies 1-3), (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process (Studies 1-3), and (c) investigate the role of autonomy (Studies 2 and 3). Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Participants completed an autonomy assessment pre- and post-random assignment to three conditions manipulating explanations. Consistent were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited. We additionally find increased levels of reported autonomy from learners by condition, respectively. Individual differences in autonomy supporting belief revision is also found. Overall, explaining facilitated belief revision, all the while, underscoring the need to consider the impact of autonomy for adolescent learners confronted with disconfirming evidence prompting belief revision.
- 17 July 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Open AccessAutonomy, Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Across three studies (n = 155) adolescent learners freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. Our purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used (Studies 1-3), (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process (Studies 1-3), and (c) investigate the role of autonomy (Studies 2 and 3). Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Participants completed an autonomy assessment pre- and post-random assignment to three conditions manipulating explanations. Consistent were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited. We additionally find increased levels of reported autonomy from learners by condition, respectively. Individual differences in autonomy supporting belief revision is also found. Overall, explaining facilitated belief revision, all the while, underscoring the need to consider the impact of autonomy for adolescent learners confronted with disconfirming evidence prompting belief revision.
- Open Access
- 10 April 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Integrating Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Adolescents from two samples (n=109) freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. The study’s purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used, and (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Consistent across age groups were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Yet, consistent across both age groups were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited, underscoring the need to consider both explanation and evidence investigation in examining belief revision.
- 10 April 2026
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Routledge Open Research
- Vol. 5, 4
Open AccessIntegrating Explanation and Evidence in Belief Revision
Adolescents from two samples (n=109) freely investigated a multivariable database to ascertain the extent to which their initial beliefs were affirmed or warranted revision. The study’s purpose was (a) to examine the strategies used, and (b) to identify the respective roles of explanation and evidence in the process. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In Condition 1, explanations were solicited prior to and following data investigation. In Condition 2, explanations were solicited only following data investigation, and in Condition 3, no explanations were solicited. Consistent across age groups were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Only 8% in sample 1 and 10% in sample 2 applied the investigatory strategy of controlled comparison (COV) that is a staple of the middle-school science curriculum. Instead, they mostly used a less reliable strategy of examining the data broadly to identify favorable outcomes and then implicating antecedents often co-occurring with them. Accurate belief revision nonetheless occurred, slightly more successfully among the young adolescent sample, who made more frequent reference to the data in justifying their conclusions. Yet, consistent across both age groups were the ways in which explanation influenced beliefs and benefitted belief revision. Explanation facilitated belief revision in both conditions (1 and 2) in which they were solicited, underscoring the need to consider both explanation and evidence investigation in examining belief revision.
- Open Access
- 20 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Thinking Skills and Creativity
- Vol. 58
Deeper learning offers opportunities for imagination without cost to content knowledge
- 20 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Thinking Skills and Creativity
- Vol. 58
Open AccessDeeper learning offers opportunities for imagination without cost to content knowledge
- Open Access
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Social Development
- Vol. 33 (4)
Is the development of diversification in executive functioning universal? Longitudinal evidence from Ghana
The component structure of executive functioning (EF) has been shown to change across development. Empirical research examining this in Sub‐Saharan Africa is limited. We report the development of EF component structure with a large sample of Ghanaian children (n = 2,979) followed longitudinally from ages 3 through 12 across six waves. Existing literature suggests unitary models of EF (components loading onto a single factor) early in childhood, with development across childhood and into adolescence resulting in a more diversified EF model (components loading onto two‐ or three‐factors). To test these developmental differences, participants completed EF batteries that measured EF components: working memory, short‐term memory, inhibition, and cognitive flexibility/shifting. We employed confirmatory factor analysis to test factor models in 3‐ to 4‐year‐olds, 5‐ to 6‐year‐olds, 7‐ to 9‐year‐olds, and 10‐ to 12‐year‐olds. Contrary to existing literature, a two‐factor EF model best explained EF performance as early as 3–4 years of age. Findings suggest that diversification of EF components may emerge earlier in childhood than expected in some contexts, questioning the universality in the timing of unification and diversification of EF structure.
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Social Development
- Vol. 33 (4)
Open AccessIs the development of diversification in executive functioning universal? Longitudinal evidence from Ghana
The component structure of executive functioning (EF) has been shown to change across development. Empirical research examining this in Sub‐Saharan Africa is limited. We report the development of EF component structure with a large sample of Ghanaian children (n = 2,979) followed longitudinally from ages 3 through 12 across six waves. Existing literature suggests unitary models of EF (components loading onto a single factor) early in childhood, with development across childhood and into adolescence resulting in a more diversified EF model (components loading onto two‐ or three‐factors). To test these developmental differences, participants completed EF batteries that measured EF components: working memory, short‐term memory, inhibition, and cognitive flexibility/shifting. We employed confirmatory factor analysis to test factor models in 3‐ to 4‐year‐olds, 5‐ to 6‐year‐olds, 7‐ to 9‐year‐olds, and 10‐ to 12‐year‐olds. Contrary to existing literature, a two‐factor EF model best explained EF performance as early as 3–4 years of age. Findings suggest that diversification of EF components may emerge earlier in childhood than expected in some contexts, questioning the universality in the timing of unification and diversification of EF structure.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2023
- Published by University of Windsor Leddy Library in Informal Logic
- Vol. 43 (1) , 1-22
The Broad Reach of Multivariable Thinking
Simple explanations are very often inadequate and can encourage faulty inferences. We examined college students’ explanations regarding illegal immigration to determine the prevalence of single-factor explanations. The form of students’ explanations was predicted by their responses on a simple three-item forced-choice multivariable causal reasoning task in which they selected the strongest evidence against a causal claim. In a further qualitative investigation of explanations by a sample of community adults, we identified positive features among those who scored high on this multivariable causal reasoning task. We consider limitations of single-factor reasoning and means of encouraging more comprehensive explanations to support claims.
- 28 March 2023
- Published by University of Windsor Leddy Library in Informal Logic
- Vol. 43 (1) , 1-22
Open AccessThe Broad Reach of Multivariable Thinking
Simple explanations are very often inadequate and can encourage faulty inferences. We examined college students’ explanations regarding illegal immigration to determine the prevalence of single-factor explanations. The form of students’ explanations was predicted by their responses on a simple three-item forced-choice multivariable causal reasoning task in which they selected the strongest evidence against a causal claim. In a further qualitative investigation of explanations by a sample of community adults, we identified positive features among those who scored high on this multivariable causal reasoning task. We consider limitations of single-factor reasoning and means of encouraging more comprehensive explanations to support claims.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA)
Can the Effects of Scientific Explanations Extend to Judgment and Decision Making? (Poster 46)
AERA Online Paper Repository Viewer
- 1 January 2023
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA)
Can the Effects of Scientific Explanations Extend to Judgment and Decision Making? (Poster 46)
AERA Online Paper Repository Viewer