Over the past few decades, parametric insurance has emerged as a promising tool for closing climate-related protection gaps. By delivering rapid, low-friction payments based on objective triggers rather than individualized loss adjustment, parametric insurance can get funds to those affected precisely when they are most needed. Yet its growth has been constrained by a persistent legal problem: because parametric contracts can pay out more than an insured's actual losses, they sit uneasily within the indemnity and insurable-interest principles that separate insurance from derivatives. Classified as derivatives, these products become largely inaccessible to municipalities, small businesses, and nonprofits, while firms seeking to sell them face increased costs and regulatory uncertainties. This Article identifies two ways to redesign parametric coverage so that it can be sold as insurance while advancing climate adaptation and resilience. The first, forecast-based parametric insurance, ties payouts to credible predictions of extreme weather events. The second, restricted-use parametric insurance, permits triggered payments only to offset actual financial losses or to fund mitigation measures that reduce future exposure to similar risks. Both designs, the Article argues, can be reconciled with insurance law's indemnity framework while preserving the speed, transparency, and administrative simplicity that make parametric coverage valuable. The Article further proposes legal mechanisms for implementing forecast-based and restricted use parametric structures, including requiring ex ante good-faith estimates of expected losses and limited tax-based reporting. Finally, it addresses the distinct problem of parametric shortfalls, explaining why undercompensation does not threaten insurance classification but does warrant targeted policyholder protections.