Growth in electricity demand and generation is increasingly constrained by generator interconnection bottlenecks, with 2,061 gigawatts of proposed capacity stalled in US queues. Energy-only, or non-firm, interconnection is intended to let generators connect to the grid more cheaply and quickly by accepting "as-available" service. Texas's "connect and manage" model has made this approach central to reform debates, but most US regions instead offer two service options: firm Network Resource Interconnection Service (NRIS) and non-firm Energy Resource Interconnection Service (ERIS). Using a dataset of over 36,000 interconnection requests and 4,500 cost studies spanning two decades, we show that ERIS fails to function as a true non-firm access option, offering neither cheaper nor faster interconnection. The historical network-upgrade cost discount associated with ERIS is driven by a "threshold effect," providing financial relief only when network upgrades are entirely avoided. Once physical upgrades are triggered, non-firm (ERIS) and firm (NRIS) interconnection face statistically comparable costs. As mounting grid constraints have cut the share of zero-cost ERIS outcomes from 80% to 10%, ERIS's financial and temporal advantages have largely evaporated and developer demand for this service has contracted. Our results suggest that the concept of "energy-only" interconnection is not inherently flawed; rather, ERIS's observed performance stems from restrictive study methodologies that do not reflect the characteristics of a true non-firm service option. These findings point to an opportunity to align interconnection rules with as-available grid access through operational redispatch, and to examine whether capacity value can remain informed by grid constraints without being dictated by interconnection service. Note: This manuscript is one of two complementary papers on energy-only interconnection. The companion paper reviews the regulatory and institutional design of ERIS and is also available as an SSRN preprint under the title, ‘A Review of United States Energy-only Generator Interconnection Service Policy and Considerations for Reform’, available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=6870718