Abstract
A soluble surfactant may adsorb at a free surface and desorb into the liquid bulk, but in a closed periodic falling film the total amount of surfactant must remain constant. We use this invariant as a test of nonlinear weighted-residual models for soluble-surfactant-laden films. The models of Pascal et al. [“Stability of inclined flow of a liquid film with soluble surfactants and variable mass density,” Phys. Rev. Fluids 4, 054004 (2019)] and D'Alessio et al. [“Marangoni instabilities associated with heated surfactant-laden falling films,” J. Fluid Mech. 887, A20 (2020)] correctly include the bulk-surface exchange mechanism, but their nonlinear surface closure contains a coefficient that prevents exact conservation of the reduced total surfactant mass. The problematic contribution is proportional to (5/4)ΓΓxhx: it leaves a residual ΓΓxhx that is not a conservative streamwise flux and therefore behaves as an artificial source during nonlinear evolution. We return to Stone's [“A simple derivation of the time-dependent convective-diffusion equation for surfactant transport along a deforming interface,” Phys. Fluids A 2, 111–112 (1990)] material-surface balance, add the Langmuir adsorption–desorption flux, and then take the thin-film long-wave limit used in the weighted-residual reduction. The normal-motion/curvature area-dilation term in Stone's [“A simple derivation of the time-dependent convective-diffusion equation for surfactant transport along a deforming interface,” Phys. Fluids A 2, 111–112 (1990)] equation is shown explicitly to enter two orders higher in the nondimensional surface balance than the retained Marangoni correction. With the same velocity and concentration ansatz used in the earlier weighted-residual framework, the conservative reduction gives the coefficient 1/4. The nonlinear surface term then becomes (1/4)∂x(hΓΓx), the corresponding bulk Marangoni term is also a periodic flux, and the adsorption–desorption terms cancel between the bulk and surface equations. Nonlinear simulations for a comparable parameter set based on the earlier published studies confirm that the corrected model conserves the total reduced surfactant mass to numerical accuracy and removes the secular growth in the surface concentration range, while leaving the linear stability problem unchanged.
Funding Information
  • International Institute of Information Technology Bangalore (17)

This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit: