Evaluation of the replicability of systematic reviews with meta-analyses of the effects of health interventions
Open Access
- 9 January 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Research Synthesis Methods
- Vol. 17 (3) , 538-556
Abstract
Systematic reviews are often characterized as being inherently replicable, but several studies have challenged this claim. The objective of the study was to investigate the variation in results following independent replication of literature searches and meta-analyses of systematic reviews. We included 10 systematic reviews of the effects of health interventions published in November 2020. Two information specialists repeated the original database search strategies. Two experienced review authors screened full-text articles, extracted data, and calculated the results for the first reported meta-analysis. All replicators were initially blinded to the results of the original review. A meta-analysis was considered not ‘fully replicable’ if the original and replicated summary estimate or confidence interval width differed by more than 10%, and meaningfully different if there was a difference in the direction or statistical significance. The difference between the number of records retrieved by the original reviewers and the information specialists exceeded 10% in 25/43 (58%) searches for the first replicator and 21/43 (49%) searches for the second. Eight meta-analyses (80%, 95% CI: 49–96) were initially classified as not fully replicable. After screening and data discrepancies were addressed, the number of meta-analyses classified as not fully replicable decreased to five (50%, 95% CI: 24–76). Differences were classified as meaningful in one blinded replication (10%, 95% CI: 1–40) and none of the unblinded replications (0%, 95% CI: 0–28). The results of systematic review processes were not always consistent when their reported methods were repeated. However, these inconsistencies seldom affected summary estimates from meta-analyses in a meaningful way.Keywords
Funding Information
- Australian Research Council (DE200101618)
This publication has 71 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic reviewers' perspectives on sharing review data, analytic code, and other materials: A surveyCochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods, 2023
- Systematic reviewers' perspectives on replication of systematic reviews: A surveyCochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods, 2023
- A systematic review and meta-analysis: the effect of active cancer treatment on severity of COVID-19European Journal of Cancer, 2020
- Inter-review agreement of risk-of-bias judgments varied in Cochrane reviewsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2020
- Discrepancies in meta-analyses answering the same clinical question were hard to explain: a meta-epidemiological studyJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2020
- Implications of applying methodological shortcuts to expedite systematic reviews: three case studies using systematic reviews from agri‐food public healthResearch Synthesis Methods, 2016
- Replication and reproducibility in spinal cord injury researchExperimental Neurology, 2012
- Introduction to Meta‐Analysis2009
- Contradicted and Initially Stronger Effects in Highly Cited Clinical ResearchJAMA, 2005
- High prevalence but low impact of data extraction and reporting errors were found in Cochrane systematic reviewsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2005