Tragic Flaws and Practical Wisdom: Public reasoning behind preferences for different genetic technologies
Open Access
- 9 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Understanding of Science
- Vol. 34 (8) , 1009-1027
Abstract
Advanced bioengineering is often described as a transformative field with the potential to reshape aspects of society and environments. However, it remains largely unfamiliar to publics, compounded by its highly abstract and complex technical details. Increasingly, there have been calls for public engagement that grounds the field in concrete, real-world uses. Furthermore, there have been calls to move beyond the limits of archetypal or intrinsic concerns by encouraging people to flesh out and justify their support or lack thereof. This national focus group study investigated views across Australia regarding four novel applications. By presenting these technologies in contextualised scenarios incorporating characters with a range of perspectives, it answers the call for greater frame awareness. We conclude that publics are more than capable of weighing and negotiating between multiple frames at once, providing their own in order to justify whether to accept or reject one of the technologies.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Wisdom of Negativity: Embracing Public Concerns About Emerging TechnologiesNanoEthics, 2025
- Planetary scale climatic change through bioengineering the microbial world. A technofix imaginaryFutures, 2024
- Three synthetic biology applications and their paths to impact in Australia: Cane toads, bacteriophages, and biomining microbesBiotechnology Journal, 2022
- Scientifically framed gene drive communication perceived as credible but riskierPeople and Nature, 2021
- Playing God and tampering with nature: popular labels for real concerns in synthetic biologyTransgenic Research, 2021
- Using role play to explore energy perceptions in the United States and United KingdomEnergy Research & Social Science, 2018
- Making sense of climate engineering: a focus group study of lay publics in four countriesClimatic Change, 2017
- A Lay Ethics Quest for Technological Futures: About Tradition, Narrative and Decision-MakingNanoEthics, 2016
- Swiss watches, genetic machines, and ethics2015
- “Some Kind of Genetic Engineering… Only One Step Further”—Public Perceptions of Synthetic Biology in Austria2015