Computational Fluid Dynamics in Hybrid Passive–Active Heat Recovery Systems for High-Performance Buildings: A Critical Review
Open Access
- 20 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Caravel Press in Journal of Global Decarbonisation
- Vol. 2 (1) , 54-89
Abstract
Hybrid passive–active heat recovery systems are increasingly used in high-performance buildings as a practical response to the growing pressure for lower energy use and more stable indoor environmental conditions. These systems combine passive heat transfer elements, such as heat pipes, with limited mechanical ventilation support in order to balance energy efficiency with operational controllability. As a result, they occupy a middle ground between fully passive solutions, which are often sensitive to boundary conditions, and fully active systems, which tend to impose higher energy and operational costs. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) has become the main analytical approach for studying the behaviour of these hybrid systems. It is commonly used to investigate airflow patterns, heat transfer processes, pressure losses, and ventilation effectiveness under a wide range of operating conditions. At the same time, the existing literature shows substantial variation in how CFD models are constructed and applied. Differences in turbulence modelling, boundary condition definition, validation strategy, and performance metrics make it difficult to compare results across studies or draw general conclusions. This review critically examines published CFD-based studies on hybrid passive–active heat recovery systems in high-performance buildings. The focus is not on individual case studies, but on identifying recurring modelling practices, common simplifications, and their implications for predicted system performance. Particular attention is given to the treatment of mixed-mode ventilation, conjugate heat transfer, and the interaction between passive components and mechanically assisted airflow. The review also highlights areas where current CFD practice remains limited, including validation against field measurements and representation of climate-driven variability. By consolidating these findings, the paper aims to clarify the role of CFD as a supporting analytical tool for design and retrofit decisions, rather than as a stand-alone predictor of system performance.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Energy-saving of passive ventilation systems in thermally modernized residential buildings – a reviewEnergy and Buildings, 2025
- Comparative analysis of natural and mechanical ventilation strategies for glass-partitioned office spaces using CFD and empirical validationJournal of Building Engineering, 2025
- The health and indoor environmental quality impacts of residential building envelope retrofits: A literature reviewBuilding and Environment, 2025
- Energy retrofits: Factors affecting a just transition to better indoor air qualityIndoor Environments, 2024
- Recent improvements to heating, ventilation, and cooling technologies for buildings based on renewable energy to achieve zero-energy buildings: A systematic reviewResults in Engineering, 2024
- CFD simulation of pumping ventilation with two asymmetrically arranged openings on the rear wall in a three-story isolated buildingBuilding and Environment, 2024
- Numerical analysis, design and application of a decentralized ventilation system with a heat recovery unit adapting to Nordic climates: A case study in NorwayEnergy Reports, 2024
- CFD analyses on the thermal comfort conditions of a cooled room: a case studyJournal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 2021
- Other Types of Heat Pipes2016
- Basic Principles of Heat Pipes and History2016