Quantitative Trade-Off Evaluation of Hardened DFFs in 130 nm ProASIC3 Flash-Based FPGAs Under Wide-LET Heavy-Ion Irradiation
Open Access
- 19 November 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Electronics
- Vol. 15 (22) , 5390
Abstract
Single-event upset (SEU) hardening of native D flip-flops (DFFs) in flash-based field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) lacks unified experimental conditions and quantitative selection criteria; this work implements six DFF structures on one and the same A3PE3000 chip as identical dual 243-bit shift-register test chains. These include an unhardened baseline DFF (BL-DFF), a conventional triple-modular-redundancy DFF (TMR-DFF), three delay-filtering TMR-DFF variants (DF-TMR-DFF), and one dual-path combinational-logic-replica TMR-DFF (DCLR-TMR-DFF). Realized DF-TMR-DFF filtering windows are set by on-chip process–voltage–temperature (PVT) calibration rather than nominal design values. Six heavy-ion species are used, with linear energy transfer (LET) of 4.4–82.06 MeV·cm2/mg, and irradiation data are processed through a five-stage procedure to remove terminal output-stage single-event transients (SETs) and retain genuine bit-cell upsets. All cross-sections are normalized per logic bit (one complete instance) rather than per storage cell. At the highest LET, the DCLR-TMR-DFF achieves the lowest cross-section of 8.23 × 10−10 cm2/bit, approximately 1/145 and 1/27 of the BL-DFF and TMR-DFF cross-sections, respectively; the DF-TMR-DFF cross-sections decrease from 1.58 × 10−8 to 2.06 × 10−9 cm2/bit as the filtering windows widen. The proposed analytical model shows that which of the DF-TMR-DFF and the DCLR-TMR-DFF has the lower per-bit VersaTile overhead depends on the delay-stage count relative to the combinational-to-sequential resource ratio ρ0, with measured per-bit overheads from 11 (BL-DFF) to 37 (DCLR-TMR-DFF) VersaTiles. Post-layout static timing analysis (STA) of standalone projects gives maximum frequencies of 59.034, 52.384, and 43.092 MHz for BL-DFF, TMR-DFF, and DCLR-TMR-DFF, and 40.827–32.083 MHz for the DF-TMR-DFF variants, whose radiation-hardness gain comes at the expense of timing performance. No structure is optimal across all three dimensions, and trade-offs are required in design. A four-tier engineering selection boundary is established for 130 nm ProASIC3 space circuits. All TMR-based structures share an inherent single-point vulnerability at the terminal three-input majority voter.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Design and Evaluation of Flip-Flops for eFPGA Configuration Hardening2024
- SET characterization of 130 nm flash-based FPGA deviceMicroelectronics Reliability, 2021
- Proton Beam Validation of a New Single Event Transient Mitigation TechniqueJournal of Electronic Testing, 2020
- Experimental verification of the effectiveness of a new circuit to mitigate single event upsets in a Xilinx Artix-7 field programmable gate arrayMicroprocessors and Microsystems, 2020
- SESRI 300MeV Proton and Heavy Ion AcceleratorJournal of Physics: Conference Series, 2019
- A new CAD tool for Single Event Transient Analysis and mitigation on Flash-based FPGAsIntegration, 2019
- Muller C-element Self-corrected Triple Modular Redundant Logic with Multithreading and Low Power Modes2017
- A new methodology for single event transient suppression in flash FPGAsMicroprocessors and Microsystems, 2013
- On the Evaluation of Radiation-Induced Transient Faults in Flash-Based FPGAs2008
- Predictions and observations of SEU rates in spaceIEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 1997