Abstract
The article presents a comprehensive scholarly analysis of the challenges associated with establishing criminal liability for waging an aggressive war in light of recent amendments to Ukrainian criminal legislation and contemporary international legal standards governing accountability for crimes against peace and the security of humankind. Particular attention is given to the problem of determining an adequate, proportionate, and equitable sanction that would appropriately reflect the gravity and social danger of the crime of aggression. The study traces the evolution of sanctions under Article 437 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, with special consideration of the amendments introduced by the Law of Ukraine of 9 October 2024 No. 4012-IX, which significantly increased the severity of penalties, including the introduction of life imprisonment. Despite these amendments, the authors note that the current version of Article 437 remains only partially harmonized with the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and the 2010 Kampala Amendments, which provide for imprisonment of up to 30 years or life imprisonment strictly in exceptional circumstances. The article reviews the state of academic research on the issue and demonstrates that Ukrainian legal doctrine has not yet developed a sufficiently detailed theoretical basis for constructing sanctions, differentiating punishment, or determining the internal structure of liability for aggression. Based on judicial statistics for 2015–2024, the authors show that prosecutions under Article 437 have been rare, while criminal liability measures against legal entities have not been applied at all in this category of cases. Particular emphasis is placed on the landmark judgment of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court of 28 February 2024, which clarified that the perpetrator of the crime of aggression can only be a person possessing the actual ability to direct the political or military actions of the State. This decision eliminated doctrinal inconsistencies and aligned Ukrainian judicial practice more closely with international standards on the leadership element of the crime of aggression. The article further examines the consolidated text of the Draft Criminal Code of Ukraine as of 15 October 2025, where the definition of aggression (Art. 11.3.1) reflects the formula of the Rome Statute, and the sanction is differentiated according to the gravity of the offence (16–30 years’ imprisonment or life imprisonment). The authors conclude that revising the sanction of Article 437 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine is necessary to ensure its full harmonization with international principles of proportionality, fairness, and effectiveness. They propose expanding the system of penalties to include additional sanctions such as fines, confiscation of property, and deprivation of special or military rank. The article argues that reform of the provision on the crime of aggression should consider not only the substantive elements of the offence but also the system of penalties envisaged by the Rome Statute, which would contribute to strengthening national criminal policy and ensuring the inevitability of liability for crimes against peace.