Mykola Mykolaiovych Pohoretskyi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Mykola Mykolaiovych Pohoretskyi has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Kyiv National Academy Of The Security Service Of Ukraine
5 shared publications- Iryna Oleksandrivna Sukhachova
National Academy of Internal Affairs, Ukraine
3 shared publications - Diana Serhieieva
Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Kyiv, Ukraine
2 shared publications - Hryhorii Denysenko
Doctoral Researcher at the National Academy of Intrnal Affairs, Kyiv, Ukraine
2 shared publications Kiev National Academy Of The Security Service Of Ukraine
2 shared publications- Elchin Iskenderov
Interregional Academy of Personnel Management, Kyiv, Ukraine
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 31 May 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (3) , 506-524
Proving crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine under martial law: digital traces, admissibility of evidence and the rule of law
The article examines the specific features of proving crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine under martial law, with particular emphasis on digital traces, electronic evidence, the admissibility of evidentiary information, the procedural legalization of the results of counterintelligence activities, operational-search activities and covert investigative (search) actions, as well as the significance of the rule of law and judicial control. It is substantiated that, in the context of armed aggression against Ukraine, the digital environment has become not only a means of communication, but also a space for the preparation, coordination, concealment and recording of subversive activities. It is argued that a digital trace is not, in itself, procedurally admissible evidence, but acquires evidentiary significance only after proper identification, recording, copying, preservation, verification, expert examination, procedural formalization and judicial assessment. The article distinguishes between the concepts of a digital trace, electronic evidence, digital evidence, an electronic medium and the electronic form of evidence. It identifies the main types of electronic evidence in criminal proceedings concerning crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine: electronic correspondence, messages in messengers, metadata, geolocation data, photo, video and audio files, mobile operator data, server logs, information from digital devices, open-source materials, cloud service data and digital financial transactions. Their importance is demonstrated for establishing the event of a criminal offence, the method of action, the person’s connections, motive, purpose, form of guilt and links with the aggressor state. The article substantiates that martial law objectively affects the organization of pre-trial investigation, procedural time limits, access to territories, the safety of participants in proceedings and the possibility of obtaining evidence; however, it does not abolish the requirements of legality, admissibility of evidence, the right of defence, judicial control and the prohibition of arbitrary interference with human rights. The conclusion is formulated that the rule of law is not an obstacle, but a necessary condition for the effective and legitimate counteraction to crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine. The article proposes directions for improving the process of proof, including the unification of standards for recording digital traces, the introduction of uniform requirements for copying electronic information, the preservation of metadata, documentation of the chain of custody, proper formalization of OSINT materials, differentiation between operational information and evidence, ensuring the defence’s access to essential materials, and strengthening judicial control over interference with private communications.
- 31 May 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (3) , 506-524
Open AccessProving crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine under martial law: digital traces, admissibility of evidence and the rule of law
The article examines the specific features of proving crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine under martial law, with particular emphasis on digital traces, electronic evidence, the admissibility of evidentiary information, the procedural legalization of the results of counterintelligence activities, operational-search activities and covert investigative (search) actions, as well as the significance of the rule of law and judicial control. It is substantiated that, in the context of armed aggression against Ukraine, the digital environment has become not only a means of communication, but also a space for the preparation, coordination, concealment and recording of subversive activities. It is argued that a digital trace is not, in itself, procedurally admissible evidence, but acquires evidentiary significance only after proper identification, recording, copying, preservation, verification, expert examination, procedural formalization and judicial assessment. The article distinguishes between the concepts of a digital trace, electronic evidence, digital evidence, an electronic medium and the electronic form of evidence. It identifies the main types of electronic evidence in criminal proceedings concerning crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine: electronic correspondence, messages in messengers, metadata, geolocation data, photo, video and audio files, mobile operator data, server logs, information from digital devices, open-source materials, cloud service data and digital financial transactions. Their importance is demonstrated for establishing the event of a criminal offence, the method of action, the person’s connections, motive, purpose, form of guilt and links with the aggressor state. The article substantiates that martial law objectively affects the organization of pre-trial investigation, procedural time limits, access to territories, the safety of participants in proceedings and the possibility of obtaining evidence; however, it does not abolish the requirements of legality, admissibility of evidence, the right of defence, judicial control and the prohibition of arbitrary interference with human rights. The conclusion is formulated that the rule of law is not an obstacle, but a necessary condition for the effective and legitimate counteraction to crimes against the foundations of national security of Ukraine. The article proposes directions for improving the process of proof, including the unification of standards for recording digital traces, the introduction of uniform requirements for copying electronic information, the preservation of metadata, documentation of the chain of custody, proper formalization of OSINT materials, differentiation between operational information and evidence, ensuring the defence’s access to essential materials, and strengthening judicial control over interference with private communications.
- Open Access
- 20 April 2026
- Published by Alerta Publishing House in Herald of criminal justice
- No. 1
Проблеми криміналізації кіберзлочинів в Україні
Стрімка цифровізація суспільних відносин та зростання транснаціональних кіберзагроз зумовлюють необхідність переосмислення кримінально-правових механізмів протидії кіберзлочинності в Україні. Водночас чинне кримінальне законодавство не повною мірою відповідає сучасним міжнародно-правовим стандартам та викликам цифрової епохи. На основі порівняльного аналізу міжнародних актів у сфері протидії кіберзлочинності встановлено еволюцію підходів до розуміння кіберзлочину та обґрунтовано його дуальну природу, що поєднує як самостійні цифрові делікти, так і трансформовані форми традиційних злочинів. Метою статті є дослідження теоретичних і прикладних проблем кримінально-правової протидії кіберзлочинності в Україні та визначення напрямів удосконалення кримінального законодавства з урахуванням міжнародних стандартів. Авторами здійснено порівняльний аналіз Будапештської конвенції про кіберзлочинність 2001 року та Конвенції ООН проти кіберзлочинності 2024 року, на підставі чого розкрито еволюцію поняття кіберзлочину та обґрунтовано його дуальну природу. Встановлено, що частина кіберзлочинів має характер злочинів sui generis, тоді як інша є цифровими модифікаціями традиційних суспільно небезпечних діянь. Проаналізовано доктринальні підходи до визначення кіберзлочину (вузький, широкий та змішаний), а також досліджено структуру КК України у цій сфері. Обґрунтовано наявність системного дуалізму між спеціальними нормами Розділу XVI та загальними нормами кримінального законодавства, що призводить до проблем кваліфікації та неоднакового застосування закону. Виявлено ключові прогалини кримінального законодавства України, зокрема щодо криміналізації несанкціонованого перехоплення даних, комп’ютерної підробки, незаконної ексфільтрації інформації, поширення інтимних матеріалів без згоди особи, кіберпереслідування, кібервимагання та відмивання коштів із використанням криптоактивів. Автори констатують, що ефективна протидія кіберзлочинності потребує системного реформування кримінального законодавства України. Таке реформування має ґрунтуватися на технологічно нейтральному формулюванні кримінально-правових норм, запровадженні двоелементної моделі регулювання (поєднання спеціальних складів та кваліфікуючих ознак використання інформаційно-комунікаційних технологій (далі – ІКТ), посиленому захисті об’єктів критичної інформаційної інфраструктури, адаптації юрисдикційних положень до транснаціонального характеру кіберзлочинності, а також забезпеченні узгодженості понятійного апарату КК України з іншим законодавством. Отримані результати можуть бути використані для вдосконалення правозастосовної практики та формування єдиної моделі кваліфікації кіберзлочинів в Україні.
- 20 April 2026
- Published by Alerta Publishing House in Herald of criminal justice
- No. 1
Open AccessПроблеми криміналізації кіберзлочинів в Україні
Стрімка цифровізація суспільних відносин та зростання транснаціональних кіберзагроз зумовлюють необхідність переосмислення кримінально-правових механізмів протидії кіберзлочинності в Україні. Водночас чинне кримінальне законодавство не повною мірою відповідає сучасним міжнародно-правовим стандартам та викликам цифрової епохи. На основі порівняльного аналізу міжнародних актів у сфері протидії кіберзлочинності встановлено еволюцію підходів до розуміння кіберзлочину та обґрунтовано його дуальну природу, що поєднує як самостійні цифрові делікти, так і трансформовані форми традиційних злочинів. Метою статті є дослідження теоретичних і прикладних проблем кримінально-правової протидії кіберзлочинності в Україні та визначення напрямів удосконалення кримінального законодавства з урахуванням міжнародних стандартів. Авторами здійснено порівняльний аналіз Будапештської конвенції про кіберзлочинність 2001 року та Конвенції ООН проти кіберзлочинності 2024 року, на підставі чого розкрито еволюцію поняття кіберзлочину та обґрунтовано його дуальну природу. Встановлено, що частина кіберзлочинів має характер злочинів sui generis, тоді як інша є цифровими модифікаціями традиційних суспільно небезпечних діянь. Проаналізовано доктринальні підходи до визначення кіберзлочину (вузький, широкий та змішаний), а також досліджено структуру КК України у цій сфері. Обґрунтовано наявність системного дуалізму між спеціальними нормами Розділу XVI та загальними нормами кримінального законодавства, що призводить до проблем кваліфікації та неоднакового застосування закону. Виявлено ключові прогалини кримінального законодавства України, зокрема щодо криміналізації несанкціонованого перехоплення даних, комп’ютерної підробки, незаконної ексфільтрації інформації, поширення інтимних матеріалів без згоди особи, кіберпереслідування, кібервимагання та відмивання коштів із використанням криптоактивів. Автори констатують, що ефективна протидія кіберзлочинності потребує системного реформування кримінального законодавства України. Таке реформування має ґрунтуватися на технологічно нейтральному формулюванні кримінально-правових норм, запровадженні двоелементної моделі регулювання (поєднання спеціальних складів та кваліфікуючих ознак використання інформаційно-комунікаційних технологій (далі – ІКТ), посиленому захисті об’єктів критичної інформаційної інфраструктури, адаптації юрисдикційних положень до транснаціонального характеру кіберзлочинності, а також забезпеченні узгодженості понятійного апарату КК України з іншим законодавством. Отримані результати можуть бути використані для вдосконалення правозастосовної практики та формування єдиної моделі кваліфікації кіберзлочинів в Україні.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (2) , 425-433
Preventing cyberattacks by foreign intelligence services against Ukraine’s critical information infrastructure
The article examines theoretical and applied aspects of preventing cyberattacks conducted by foreign intelligence services against critical information infrastructure of Ukraine under conditions of ongoing armed aggression. It is substantiated that modern cyberattacks against critical information infrastructure are of a complex nature and should be understood not only as technical incidents, but also as a component of intelligence and subversive activities of foreign states in cyberspace. It is determined that effective counteraction to such threats requires a combination of technical cybersecurity measures and counterintelligence mechanisms aimed at prevention, detection, documentation, and neutralization of threat sources. The activity of APT groups associated with foreign intelligence services is analyzed, and their role in the implementation of strategic cyber operations against Ukraine is revealed. A comparative analysis of critical infrastructure protection models in the United States, Israel, and the Republic of Estonia is carried out, which made it possible to establish the system-forming role of intelligence and counterintelligence agencies in ensuring cybersecurity. It is proved that effective national models are based on institutionalized intelligence sharing, public-private partnerships, and integration of civilian, military, and intelligence capabilities. The current regulatory framework of Ukraine in the field of critical information infrastructure protection is analyzed, and its key shortcomings are identified, in particular the lack of proper institutional integration of counterintelligence activities into the cybersecurity system, insufficient effectiveness of mandatory cyber incident reporting mechanisms, and the absence of a legally established cyber reserve. The directions for improving legislation are proposed, including the introduction of mandatory intelligence-sharing mechanisms, strengthening counterintelligence powers in the field of critical infrastructure protection, development of a cyber reserve, and formation of legal frameworks for cyberattack attribution. It is concluded that there is a need to transition from a reactive to a proactive model of counterintelligence support for cybersecurity in Ukraine. The obtained results have practical significance for improving state policy in the field of protection of critical information infrastructure and enhancing the effectiveness of the activities of the subjects of the national cybersecurity system of Ukraine.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (2) , 425-433
Open AccessPreventing cyberattacks by foreign intelligence services against Ukraine’s critical information infrastructure
The article examines theoretical and applied aspects of preventing cyberattacks conducted by foreign intelligence services against critical information infrastructure of Ukraine under conditions of ongoing armed aggression. It is substantiated that modern cyberattacks against critical information infrastructure are of a complex nature and should be understood not only as technical incidents, but also as a component of intelligence and subversive activities of foreign states in cyberspace. It is determined that effective counteraction to such threats requires a combination of technical cybersecurity measures and counterintelligence mechanisms aimed at prevention, detection, documentation, and neutralization of threat sources. The activity of APT groups associated with foreign intelligence services is analyzed, and their role in the implementation of strategic cyber operations against Ukraine is revealed. A comparative analysis of critical infrastructure protection models in the United States, Israel, and the Republic of Estonia is carried out, which made it possible to establish the system-forming role of intelligence and counterintelligence agencies in ensuring cybersecurity. It is proved that effective national models are based on institutionalized intelligence sharing, public-private partnerships, and integration of civilian, military, and intelligence capabilities. The current regulatory framework of Ukraine in the field of critical information infrastructure protection is analyzed, and its key shortcomings are identified, in particular the lack of proper institutional integration of counterintelligence activities into the cybersecurity system, insufficient effectiveness of mandatory cyber incident reporting mechanisms, and the absence of a legally established cyber reserve. The directions for improving legislation are proposed, including the introduction of mandatory intelligence-sharing mechanisms, strengthening counterintelligence powers in the field of critical infrastructure protection, development of a cyber reserve, and formation of legal frameworks for cyberattack attribution. It is concluded that there is a need to transition from a reactive to a proactive model of counterintelligence support for cybersecurity in Ukraine. The obtained results have practical significance for improving state policy in the field of protection of critical information infrastructure and enhancing the effectiveness of the activities of the subjects of the national cybersecurity system of Ukraine.
- Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 5 (93) , 156-174
Criminal Offences Against the Fundamentals of Ukraine’s National Security under Martial Law: Problematic Issues of Forensic Support for Pre-Trial Investigation
The article addresses criminal offences against the fundamentals of Ukraine’s national security under martial law and examines problematic issues of forensic support for their pre-trial investigation. It is substantiated that the “hybridization” of threats, the dispersion of events and actors, and the predominance of digital communications and transnational channels create heightened risks of loss of evidence, defects in procedural formalization, and the subsequent inadmissibility of the evidentiary corpus. Within the general criminal-law characterization, the focus is placed on qualification “bottlenecks” that directly determine the subject matter of proof (conflict of legal norms, delimitation of related offences, proving the direction of intent and role-based participation in network configurations). The study systematizes problems of forensic support at the initial stage of proceedings (primary recording of the event and digital traces), in digital evidence (source, method of acquisition, integrity, reproducibility), in the legalization of materials obtained through operational-search activities and covert investigative (search) actions (procedural prospectivity of results, completeness of documentation, risks of “procedural gaps”), in the use of tactical operations and temporary access to items and documents, as well as in the domain of judicial control, admissibility of evidence, and the standard of substantiation of procedural decisions. A generalizing model of forensic support (detection–fixation–procedural formalization– verification–judicial control) and a set of applied solutions are proposed: an algorithm for primary actions aimed at minimizing “evidentiary gaps,” protocols for digital documentation (metadata recording, integrity control, description of the acquisition environment, chain of custody), criteria of necessity/proportionality for digital intrusions and standards for substantiating motions, as well as organizational standards for interaction between investigators and operational units and prosecutorial oversight of the evidentiary fitness of results. It is demonstrated that the decisive quality criteria of forensic support under martial law should be the verifiability, reproducibility, and admissibility of evidence, provided that human rights guarantees are preserved. Prospects for further research are outlined, including the development of specialized investigative methodologies for specific groups of security-related offences and the unification of approaches to assessing digital and covertly obtained evidence in judicial practice.
- 5 March 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 5 (93) , 156-174
Open AccessCriminal Offences Against the Fundamentals of Ukraine’s National Security under Martial Law: Problematic Issues of Forensic Support for Pre-Trial Investigation
The article addresses criminal offences against the fundamentals of Ukraine’s national security under martial law and examines problematic issues of forensic support for their pre-trial investigation. It is substantiated that the “hybridization” of threats, the dispersion of events and actors, and the predominance of digital communications and transnational channels create heightened risks of loss of evidence, defects in procedural formalization, and the subsequent inadmissibility of the evidentiary corpus. Within the general criminal-law characterization, the focus is placed on qualification “bottlenecks” that directly determine the subject matter of proof (conflict of legal norms, delimitation of related offences, proving the direction of intent and role-based participation in network configurations). The study systematizes problems of forensic support at the initial stage of proceedings (primary recording of the event and digital traces), in digital evidence (source, method of acquisition, integrity, reproducibility), in the legalization of materials obtained through operational-search activities and covert investigative (search) actions (procedural prospectivity of results, completeness of documentation, risks of “procedural gaps”), in the use of tactical operations and temporary access to items and documents, as well as in the domain of judicial control, admissibility of evidence, and the standard of substantiation of procedural decisions. A generalizing model of forensic support (detection–fixation–procedural formalization– verification–judicial control) and a set of applied solutions are proposed: an algorithm for primary actions aimed at minimizing “evidentiary gaps,” protocols for digital documentation (metadata recording, integrity control, description of the acquisition environment, chain of custody), criteria of necessity/proportionality for digital intrusions and standards for substantiating motions, as well as organizational standards for interaction between investigators and operational units and prosecutorial oversight of the evidentiary fitness of results. It is demonstrated that the decisive quality criteria of forensic support under martial law should be the verifiability, reproducibility, and admissibility of evidence, provided that human rights guarantees are preserved. Prospects for further research are outlined, including the development of specialized investigative methodologies for specific groups of security-related offences and the unification of approaches to assessing digital and covertly obtained evidence in judicial practice.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (1) , 136-151
The Rule of law in the practice of applying preventive measures: between the effectiveness of criminal prosecution and the protection of individual liberty
The article examines the implementation of the rule of law in the practice of applying preventive measures as the most intensive form of procedural interference by the state with the right to liberty and personal security. It is substantiated that, in this sphere, the rule of law should be understood not as a declarative principle but as a practical standard for controlling the discretion of the investigating judge and the court, manifested through the requirements of legal certainty, non-arbitrariness, proportionality, subsidiarity (alternativeness), and the verifiability of judicial decisions. It is demonstrated that the “quality of the law” in detention-related decisions encompasses not only the formal existence of a procedural rule but also its foreseeability, coherence, and the capacity of the legal procedure to prevent arbitrariness through substantive judicial control, proper reasoning, and the possibility of effective review. It is proven that reasonable suspicion serves as a primary filter of the lawfulness of restricting liberty by establishing a minimum threshold of factual sufficiency and precluding the application of custodial measures based on assumptions. Risks are revealed as a prognostic ground that must be proven on the basis of specific factual indicators, with mandatory individualization and a prohibition on template reasoning. It is established that proportionality and genuine alternativeness constitute the “core” of the rule of law when selecting a preventive measure and preclude the automatic application of pre-trial detention, requiring an analysis of less intrusive means and proof of their insufficiency in the конкретe case. Emphasis is placed on the dynamic nature of judicial control over detention: grounds that are sufficient at the initial stage may lose their persuasiveness over time, which necessitates updating the factual justification and reassessing risks at each extension of detention. Practical recommendations are proposed regarding the structure of judicial reasoning, a “grounds-renewal test,” standards for assessing alternatives and the temporal parameters of liberty restrictions, as well as safeguards against abuses of procedural rights and powers. Particular attention is paid to the fact that, under martial law, heightened risks cannot serve as a basis for lowering standards of proof and judicial control; on the contrary, they require strengthening guarantees of non-arbitrariness and minimizing interference with personal liberty.
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (1) , 136-151
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe Rule of law in the practice of applying preventive measures: between the effectiveness of criminal prosecution and the protection of individual liberty
The article examines the implementation of the rule of law in the practice of applying preventive measures as the most intensive form of procedural interference by the state with the right to liberty and personal security. It is substantiated that, in this sphere, the rule of law should be understood not as a declarative principle but as a practical standard for controlling the discretion of the investigating judge and the court, manifested through the requirements of legal certainty, non-arbitrariness, proportionality, subsidiarity (alternativeness), and the verifiability of judicial decisions. It is demonstrated that the “quality of the law” in detention-related decisions encompasses not only the formal existence of a procedural rule but also its foreseeability, coherence, and the capacity of the legal procedure to prevent arbitrariness through substantive judicial control, proper reasoning, and the possibility of effective review. It is proven that reasonable suspicion serves as a primary filter of the lawfulness of restricting liberty by establishing a minimum threshold of factual sufficiency and precluding the application of custodial measures based on assumptions. Risks are revealed as a prognostic ground that must be proven on the basis of specific factual indicators, with mandatory individualization and a prohibition on template reasoning. It is established that proportionality and genuine alternativeness constitute the “core” of the rule of law when selecting a preventive measure and preclude the automatic application of pre-trial detention, requiring an analysis of less intrusive means and proof of their insufficiency in the конкретe case. Emphasis is placed on the dynamic nature of judicial control over detention: grounds that are sufficient at the initial stage may lose their persuasiveness over time, which necessitates updating the factual justification and reassessing risks at each extension of detention. Practical recommendations are proposed regarding the structure of judicial reasoning, a “grounds-renewal test,” standards for assessing alternatives and the temporal parameters of liberty restrictions, as well as safeguards against abuses of procedural rights and powers. Particular attention is paid to the fact that, under martial law, heightened risks cannot serve as a basis for lowering standards of proof and judicial control; on the contrary, they require strengthening guarantees of non-arbitrariness and minimizing interference with personal liberty.
- Open Access
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Alerta Publishing House in Herald of criminal justice
- No. 3-4
Crime Provocation in the Criminal Procedure of Ukraine: International Legal Standards, ECHR Practice and Human Rights Guarantees
The article presents a comprehensive analysis of the observance of human rights during the imple-mentation of covert investigative (search) actions (CISA) in the context of ensuring Ukraine’s national security. It examines the specifics of applying CISA in criminal proceedings concerning crimes against the foundations of national security, such as high treason, espionage, terrorist activity, and collaboration. Particular attention is paid to the legal and ethical aspects of using provocative methods in law enforce-ment activities, the limits of their admissibility, and potential risks of violating citizens’ constitutional rights. The paper analyzes international approaches to the regulation of crime provocation, including the practice of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and legislative approaches in the United States, the United Kingdom, and the Federal Republic of Germany. A comparative legal analysis of the norms defining the admissibility of undercover operations has been conducted, identifying common features and differences in human rights protection standards during the use of covert investigative techniques. The author substantiates the need to establish clear mechanisms for controlling the activities of operational units, strengthening judicial oversight and prosecutorial supervision, and introducing effective instruments of public monitoring. It is emphasized that achieving a balance between nation-al security needs and human rights guarantees is a key condition for the democratic nature of the criminal process and the effectiveness of state policy in combating crimes against national security. The purpose of the article is to examine the legal nature and limits of admissibility of crime provocation in the criminal procedure of Ukraine, taking into account international experience and human rights protection standards. The author analyzes Articles 271 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and 370 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, which define the legal boundaries of controlled operations and establish liability for provocation of bribery. The study considers the practice of nation-al courts and the ECHR decisions (in particular, Teixeira de Castro v. Portugal and Ramanuskas v. Lithuania), which establish criteria for distinguishing lawful operational actions from impermissible in-ducement to commit a crime. The article highlights the application of provocative methods in combat-ing crimes against the foundations of national security, including treason, espionage, and terrorism. It reviews the experience of the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany, where provocation may be permissible only to identify individuals with an actual predisposition to commit serious crimes, provided there is strict judicial oversight. It is concluded that, in light of modern threats to Ukraine’s territorial integrity, it is advisable to legislatively define the limits of controlled operational measures involving provocative elements, ensuring compliance with human rights, strengthening judicial and prosecutorial control, and estab-lishing mechanisms of public oversight over operational units. The outlined proposals aim to create a balance between the effectiveness of investigations and the protection of individual legal guarantees in the sphere of national security.
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Alerta Publishing House in Herald of criminal justice
- No. 3-4
Open AccessCrime Provocation in the Criminal Procedure of Ukraine: International Legal Standards, ECHR Practice and Human Rights Guarantees
The article presents a comprehensive analysis of the observance of human rights during the imple-mentation of covert investigative (search) actions (CISA) in the context of ensuring Ukraine’s national security. It examines the specifics of applying CISA in criminal proceedings concerning crimes against the foundations of national security, such as high treason, espionage, terrorist activity, and collaboration. Particular attention is paid to the legal and ethical aspects of using provocative methods in law enforce-ment activities, the limits of their admissibility, and potential risks of violating citizens’ constitutional rights. The paper analyzes international approaches to the regulation of crime provocation, including the practice of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and legislative approaches in the United States, the United Kingdom, and the Federal Republic of Germany. A comparative legal analysis of the norms defining the admissibility of undercover operations has been conducted, identifying common features and differences in human rights protection standards during the use of covert investigative techniques. The author substantiates the need to establish clear mechanisms for controlling the activities of operational units, strengthening judicial oversight and prosecutorial supervision, and introducing effective instruments of public monitoring. It is emphasized that achieving a balance between nation-al security needs and human rights guarantees is a key condition for the democratic nature of the criminal process and the effectiveness of state policy in combating crimes against national security. The purpose of the article is to examine the legal nature and limits of admissibility of crime provocation in the criminal procedure of Ukraine, taking into account international experience and human rights protection standards. The author analyzes Articles 271 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and 370 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, which define the legal boundaries of controlled operations and establish liability for provocation of bribery. The study considers the practice of nation-al courts and the ECHR decisions (in particular, Teixeira de Castro v. Portugal and Ramanuskas v. Lithuania), which establish criteria for distinguishing lawful operational actions from impermissible in-ducement to commit a crime. The article highlights the application of provocative methods in combat-ing crimes against the foundations of national security, including treason, espionage, and terrorism. It reviews the experience of the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany, where provocation may be permissible only to identify individuals with an actual predisposition to commit serious crimes, provided there is strict judicial oversight. It is concluded that, in light of modern threats to Ukraine’s territorial integrity, it is advisable to legislatively define the limits of controlled operational measures involving provocative elements, ensuring compliance with human rights, strengthening judicial and prosecutorial control, and estab-lishing mechanisms of public oversight over operational units. The outlined proposals aim to create a balance between the effectiveness of investigations and the protection of individual legal guarantees in the sphere of national security.
- Open Access
- 22 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (6) , 42-47
Current issues of criminal liability for waging an aggressive war
The article presents a comprehensive scholarly analysis of the challenges associated with establishing criminal liability for waging an aggressive war in light of recent amendments to Ukrainian criminal legislation and contemporary international legal standards governing accountability for crimes against peace and the security of humankind. Particular attention is given to the problem of determining an adequate, proportionate, and equitable sanction that would appropriately reflect the gravity and social danger of the crime of aggression. The study traces the evolution of sanctions under Article 437 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, with special consideration of the amendments introduced by the Law of Ukraine of 9 October 2024 No. 4012-IX, which significantly increased the severity of penalties, including the introduction of life imprisonment. Despite these amendments, the authors note that the current version of Article 437 remains only partially harmonized with the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and the 2010 Kampala Amendments, which provide for imprisonment of up to 30 years or life imprisonment strictly in exceptional circumstances. The article reviews the state of academic research on the issue and demonstrates that Ukrainian legal doctrine has not yet developed a sufficiently detailed theoretical basis for constructing sanctions, differentiating punishment, or determining the internal structure of liability for aggression. Based on judicial statistics for 2015–2024, the authors show that prosecutions under Article 437 have been rare, while criminal liability measures against legal entities have not been applied at all in this category of cases. Particular emphasis is placed on the landmark judgment of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court of 28 February 2024, which clarified that the perpetrator of the crime of aggression can only be a person possessing the actual ability to direct the political or military actions of the State. This decision eliminated doctrinal inconsistencies and aligned Ukrainian judicial practice more closely with international standards on the leadership element of the crime of aggression. The article further examines the consolidated text of the Draft Criminal Code of Ukraine as of 15 October 2025, where the definition of aggression (Art. 11.3.1) reflects the formula of the Rome Statute, and the sanction is differentiated according to the gravity of the offence (16–30 years’ imprisonment or life imprisonment). The authors conclude that revising the sanction of Article 437 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine is necessary to ensure its full harmonization with international principles of proportionality, fairness, and effectiveness. They propose expanding the system of penalties to include additional sanctions such as fines, confiscation of property, and deprivation of special or military rank. The article argues that reform of the provision on the crime of aggression should consider not only the substantive elements of the offence but also the system of penalties envisaged by the Rome Statute, which would contribute to strengthening national criminal policy and ensuring the inevitability of liability for crimes against peace.
- 22 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (6) , 42-47
Open AccessCurrent issues of criminal liability for waging an aggressive war
The article presents a comprehensive scholarly analysis of the challenges associated with establishing criminal liability for waging an aggressive war in light of recent amendments to Ukrainian criminal legislation and contemporary international legal standards governing accountability for crimes against peace and the security of humankind. Particular attention is given to the problem of determining an adequate, proportionate, and equitable sanction that would appropriately reflect the gravity and social danger of the crime of aggression. The study traces the evolution of sanctions under Article 437 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, with special consideration of the amendments introduced by the Law of Ukraine of 9 October 2024 No. 4012-IX, which significantly increased the severity of penalties, including the introduction of life imprisonment. Despite these amendments, the authors note that the current version of Article 437 remains only partially harmonized with the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and the 2010 Kampala Amendments, which provide for imprisonment of up to 30 years or life imprisonment strictly in exceptional circumstances. The article reviews the state of academic research on the issue and demonstrates that Ukrainian legal doctrine has not yet developed a sufficiently detailed theoretical basis for constructing sanctions, differentiating punishment, or determining the internal structure of liability for aggression. Based on judicial statistics for 2015–2024, the authors show that prosecutions under Article 437 have been rare, while criminal liability measures against legal entities have not been applied at all in this category of cases. Particular emphasis is placed on the landmark judgment of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court of 28 February 2024, which clarified that the perpetrator of the crime of aggression can only be a person possessing the actual ability to direct the political or military actions of the State. This decision eliminated doctrinal inconsistencies and aligned Ukrainian judicial practice more closely with international standards on the leadership element of the crime of aggression. The article further examines the consolidated text of the Draft Criminal Code of Ukraine as of 15 October 2025, where the definition of aggression (Art. 11.3.1) reflects the formula of the Rome Statute, and the sanction is differentiated according to the gravity of the offence (16–30 years’ imprisonment or life imprisonment). The authors conclude that revising the sanction of Article 437 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine is necessary to ensure its full harmonization with international principles of proportionality, fairness, and effectiveness. They propose expanding the system of penalties to include additional sanctions such as fines, confiscation of property, and deprivation of special or military rank. The article argues that reform of the provision on the crime of aggression should consider not only the substantive elements of the offence but also the system of penalties envisaged by the Rome Statute, which would contribute to strengthening national criminal policy and ensuring the inevitability of liability for crimes against peace.
- Open Access
- 22 November 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 5 (91) , 211-217
National Security and Human Rights: Balance, Legal Mechanisms, and International Standards
The article offers a comprehensive analysis of the relationship between ensuring national security and respecting human rights amid contemporary multidimensional threats. It substantiates the need to achieve a legitimate balance between protecting state interests and guaranteeing fundamental rights and freedoms through the principles of the rule of law, legality, necessity, and proportionality. The security agenda is shown to encompass military aggression, hybrid influence, cyberattacks, disinformation, corruption, and institutional weakness, which together shape a complex risk profile for the state. The effectiveness of the state’s response is determined by the quality of legal mechanisms: clear procedures for data access and communications oversight, procedural safeguards, independent judicial review, parliamentary oversight, and institutional transparency. A classification of threats and crimes against the foundations of national security by the object of encroachment is proposed (sovereignty and the constitutional order; defense capability and critical infrastructure; information and economic security), enabling targeted preventive tools and risk-management policy adjustments. A comparative analysis of democratic practices confirms that an optimal model is based on clear boundaries for interference in the private sphere, multi-level oversight, and legal remedies for individuals whose rights may be restricted. It is emphasized that any restrictions must be necessary, time-limited, and proportionate to a legitimate aim; their introduction should rely on risk assessment and sufficient reasoning. The practical value lies in formulating criteria for the legitimacy of security decisions, a model of interaction between the state and civil society, and recommendations for harmonizing national legislation with international standards. The article concludes that the resilience of a democratic system is ensured not by prioritizing security over rights, but by building a legal architecture in which security guarantees the realization of rights and freedoms and strengthens institutional trust.
- 22 November 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 5 (91) , 211-217
Open AccessNational Security and Human Rights: Balance, Legal Mechanisms, and International Standards
The article offers a comprehensive analysis of the relationship between ensuring national security and respecting human rights amid contemporary multidimensional threats. It substantiates the need to achieve a legitimate balance between protecting state interests and guaranteeing fundamental rights and freedoms through the principles of the rule of law, legality, necessity, and proportionality. The security agenda is shown to encompass military aggression, hybrid influence, cyberattacks, disinformation, corruption, and institutional weakness, which together shape a complex risk profile for the state. The effectiveness of the state’s response is determined by the quality of legal mechanisms: clear procedures for data access and communications oversight, procedural safeguards, independent judicial review, parliamentary oversight, and institutional transparency. A classification of threats and crimes against the foundations of national security by the object of encroachment is proposed (sovereignty and the constitutional order; defense capability and critical infrastructure; information and economic security), enabling targeted preventive tools and risk-management policy adjustments. A comparative analysis of democratic practices confirms that an optimal model is based on clear boundaries for interference in the private sphere, multi-level oversight, and legal remedies for individuals whose rights may be restricted. It is emphasized that any restrictions must be necessary, time-limited, and proportionate to a legitimate aim; their introduction should rely on risk assessment and sufficient reasoning. The practical value lies in formulating criteria for the legitimacy of security decisions, a model of interaction between the state and civil society, and recommendations for harmonizing national legislation with international standards. The article concludes that the resilience of a democratic system is ensured not by prioritizing security over rights, but by building a legal architecture in which security guarantees the realization of rights and freedoms and strengthens institutional trust.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Alerta Publishing House in Herald of criminal justice
- No. 1-2,p. 60-82
Covert Investigations and Human Rights: International Experience for Ukraine
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the legal regulation of covert investigative (search) actions in the context of ensuring human rights amid contemporary security challenges. It examines the conceptual foundations of covert investigations, their historical evolution–from early forms of hidden surveillance to high-tech digital instruments–and the peculiarities of their application in leading democratic states. Particular attention is devoted to the comparative analysis of models in the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, Switzerland, and Poland, which demonstrate diverse approaches to judicial control, undercover operations, digital surveillance, and institutional oversight. The article also highlights the standards of the European Court of Human Rights regarding interference with private life, including the requirements of legality, necessity, proportionality, effective oversight, and post-factum safeguards. The Ukrainian context is analyzed through the prism of key systemic problems: the formal nature of judicial control, insufficiency of prosecutorial supervision, contradictions between operational-search activity and covert investigative actions, lack of regulation of artificial intelligence, big data, biometric technologies and spyware, as well as the absence of independent external monitoring. It is demonstrated that these factors not only reduce the level of privacy protection but also generate risks of evidence inadmissibility and violations of fair trial standards. The study proposes a structural model for reforming Ukrainian legislation, which includes improving the quality of judicial control, establishing an independent oversight body, introducing procedural regulation of digital technologies, implementing post-factum guarantees, and harmonizing the interaction between operational-search activity and criminal procedure. It is emphasized that the adaptation of foreign standards should follow a model of «flexible implementation,» taking into account the conditions of martial law and the level of security threats. The scientific novelty of the study lies in combining comparative-legal, doctrinal, and technological analysis, which has made it possible to formulate a holistic concept for modernizing the institution of covert investigative actions in accordance with European standards and ECtHR practice. The practical significance is reflected in the identification of specific legislative and institutional solutions capable of ensuring a more effective balance between the interests of national security and human rights protection under conditions of digitalization and hybrid threats.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Alerta Publishing House in Herald of criminal justice
- No. 1-2,p. 60-82
Open AccessCovert Investigations and Human Rights: International Experience for Ukraine
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the legal regulation of covert investigative (search) actions in the context of ensuring human rights amid contemporary security challenges. It examines the conceptual foundations of covert investigations, their historical evolution–from early forms of hidden surveillance to high-tech digital instruments–and the peculiarities of their application in leading democratic states. Particular attention is devoted to the comparative analysis of models in the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, Switzerland, and Poland, which demonstrate diverse approaches to judicial control, undercover operations, digital surveillance, and institutional oversight. The article also highlights the standards of the European Court of Human Rights regarding interference with private life, including the requirements of legality, necessity, proportionality, effective oversight, and post-factum safeguards. The Ukrainian context is analyzed through the prism of key systemic problems: the formal nature of judicial control, insufficiency of prosecutorial supervision, contradictions between operational-search activity and covert investigative actions, lack of regulation of artificial intelligence, big data, biometric technologies and spyware, as well as the absence of independent external monitoring. It is demonstrated that these factors not only reduce the level of privacy protection but also generate risks of evidence inadmissibility and violations of fair trial standards. The study proposes a structural model for reforming Ukrainian legislation, which includes improving the quality of judicial control, establishing an independent oversight body, introducing procedural regulation of digital technologies, implementing post-factum guarantees, and harmonizing the interaction between operational-search activity and criminal procedure. It is emphasized that the adaptation of foreign standards should follow a model of «flexible implementation,» taking into account the conditions of martial law and the level of security threats. The scientific novelty of the study lies in combining comparative-legal, doctrinal, and technological analysis, which has made it possible to formulate a holistic concept for modernizing the institution of covert investigative actions in accordance with European standards and ECtHR practice. The practical significance is reflected in the identification of specific legislative and institutional solutions capable of ensuring a more effective balance between the interests of national security and human rights protection under conditions of digitalization and hybrid threats.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 6,p. 979-988
Mechanism of the prosecutor’s implementation of the function of accusation in proving in the pre-trail investigation of corruption crimes
The scientific article defines the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation as a complex interacting system of processes that has a normatively defined legal form, phasing and is implemented by the prosecutor to objectively and fully establish the subject of evidence in corruption crimes, bringing the perpetrators to justice and / or applying other measures of a criminal law nature. The purpose of the article is to define the concept and structure of the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation. It is established that the category «mechanism for the prosecutor to exercise the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation» is disclosed through a system of other interrelated and interdependent legal categories and is structured. The structural structure reveals the essential side of the implementation mechanism, reflects the unity and diversity of all its constituent elements. In turn, each of the components of the structure can be considered as a separate legally significant category. It is proved that the characteristics of certain elements of the structure of the mechanism will ensure the formation of a holistic and systematic view of the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation. According to the analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights, the Court has determined in its decisions the minimum guarantees to be set out in law in order to avoid violating the rights of the person under the Convention in prosecuting evidence in pre-trial evidence; a list of such guarantees is defined. It is emphasized that the stage is a functional element of the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of accusation of proof in pre-trial investigation, which is defined as the procedure for the prosecutor to perform various procedural actions. The structural elements of the mechanism for the prosecutor to exercise the function of accusation in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation are defined as: the legal form of consolidating the procedure for the prosecutor’s function.
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 6,p. 979-988
Open AccessMechanism of the prosecutor’s implementation of the function of accusation in proving in the pre-trail investigation of corruption crimes
The scientific article defines the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation as a complex interacting system of processes that has a normatively defined legal form, phasing and is implemented by the prosecutor to objectively and fully establish the subject of evidence in corruption crimes, bringing the perpetrators to justice and / or applying other measures of a criminal law nature. The purpose of the article is to define the concept and structure of the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation. It is established that the category «mechanism for the prosecutor to exercise the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation» is disclosed through a system of other interrelated and interdependent legal categories and is structured. The structural structure reveals the essential side of the implementation mechanism, reflects the unity and diversity of all its constituent elements. In turn, each of the components of the structure can be considered as a separate legally significant category. It is proved that the characteristics of certain elements of the structure of the mechanism will ensure the formation of a holistic and systematic view of the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of prosecution in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation. According to the analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights, the Court has determined in its decisions the minimum guarantees to be set out in law in order to avoid violating the rights of the person under the Convention in prosecuting evidence in pre-trial evidence; a list of such guarantees is defined. It is emphasized that the stage is a functional element of the mechanism of implementation by the prosecutor of the function of accusation of proof in pre-trial investigation, which is defined as the procedure for the prosecutor to perform various procedural actions. The structural elements of the mechanism for the prosecutor to exercise the function of accusation in proving corruption crimes in the pre-trial investigation are defined as: the legal form of consolidating the procedure for the prosecutor’s function.