Abstract
Coal-to-liquids (CtL) industries represent a critical challenge for long-term energy transitions, combining high greenhouse-gas emissions with strong economic and energy-security roles. South Africa’s Secunda CtL complex—responsible for around 12% of national emissions—illustrates these tensions, where rapid or unplanned shutdown could impose substantial economic and energy-security risks. This study evaluates alternative decarbonisation strategies and transition pathways for a CtL industry using a national energy-system optimisation framework (SATIM). Three pathways are examined: a Baseline; an incremental, roadmap-aligned pathway reflecting near-term efficiency and renewable integration measures; and a structural decarbonisation pathway in which low-carbon technologies are deployed under a national long-term emissions constraint (LTEC).The incremental scenario reduces facility-level emissions by ~26% by 2030, decreasing carbon intensity from 180 to 147 kt CO₂/PJ. Structural decarbonisation under a national Long-Term Emissions Constraint (LTEC) of 8.5 Gt achieves deeper cuts—45% by 2030, 56% by 2040, and 62% by 2045—lowering carbon intensity to 97 kt CO₂/PJ. While a structural transition is feasible, decarbonisation remains partial due to limited CO₂ availability and high transport, storage, and DAC costs. Demand-side electrification and EV uptake ease fuel demand and CO₂ constraints, while transition timing is primarily governed by renewable-energy costs, policy ambition (e.g., tighter LTEC, carbon taxes), and oil-price dynamics. Lower oil prices narrow profit margins and reduce Fischer–Tropsch output and Scope 1 emissions, while accelerating low-carbon technologies and earlier RWGS deployment despite lower FT profitability. The findings provide strategic insights for policymakers and planners designing industrial transition pathways in carbon-intensive economies.

This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit: