The Zeroing Issue: a critical analysis of Softwood V
Authors:
- Chad P. BownCBChad P. Bown
- Alan O. SykesASAlan O. Sykes
- 1 January 2008
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in World Trade Review
- Vol. 7 (1) , 121-142
Abstract
This paper addresses the issues that came before the Appellate Body in the Softwood V dispute, concerning an affirmative antidumping determination by the US Department of Commerce. The paper addresses both the original Appellate Body opinion in the dispute, and the later opinion reviewing the compliance panel findings. We focus primarily on the ‘zeroing’ issue in ‘transaction-to-transaction (T–T)’ calculations of dumping, and briefly on two other cost-allocation issues. In general, we are ambivalent about the Appellate Body's approach to the zeroing issue. On the one hand, zeroing inflates dumping margins without any sound economic rationale for doing so. On the other hand, zeroing has been a standard administrative practice for many years and the ADA does not clearly prohibit it. The Appellate Body's legal analysis of the matter in T–T cases, in particular, rests on shaky premises. We also consider the wisdom of addressing the zeroing issue in piecemeal fashion through what has proven to be a lengthy sequence of narrow decisions.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Overruling and the instability of lawJournal of Comparative Economics, 2007
- The Evolution of Common LawJournal of Political Economy, 2007
- WTO Dispute Settlement and the Missing Developing Country Cases: Engaging the Private SectorJournal of International Economic Law, 2005
- Participation in WTO Dispute Settlement: Complainants, Interested Parties, and Free RidersThe World Bank Economic Review, 2005
- Trade Remedies and World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement: Why Are So Few Challenged?The Journal of Legal Studies, 2005
- U.S. Trade Policy and the Adjustment ProcessIMF Staff Papers, 2005
- Creative Destruction or Just Plain Destruction?: The U.S. Textile and Apparel Industries since 19722001