Evolving Ostrom’s first principle: The dynamic evolution of common property rights and their role in resource management
Authors:
Preprint
- 5 January 2023
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
When and how can collective property rights evolve to effectively manage otherwise open access resources? We introduce a generic but formal modelling framework that explores under what conditions collective property rights over natural resources emerge, the causal mechanisms through which such rights aid in sustainability and the challenges that groups face in maintaining them. Our focus is on both the origins of collective property rights, and the co-evolutionary interactions driving their emergence and stabilization. Results suggest that, in the presence of inter-group conflict over resources, groups must establish and enforce rules regarding access and exclusion before implementing effective internal management. This is because when groups lack boundaries, inter-group conflict erodes surplus gains and impairs groups' ability to identify sustainable management targets. We compare these theoretical insights with empirical data from Pemba, Tanzania on the relationship between inter-group conflicts, and investments in boundaries and internal management. We find that inter-group conflict is positively correlated with support for boundaries but negatively correlated with investment in tree planting activities, supporting our theoretical insights on the evolutionary drivers of collective property rights when borders are porous. We discuss these results in the context of strategies to overcome collective action dilemmas and connections to cultural multi-level selection.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2023-01-05, Research Square
- Published version: Nature Sustainability, 7 (4), 404.
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Universal and variable leadership dimensions across human societiesEvolution and Human Behavior, 2020
- From nouns to verbs: How process ontologies enhance our understanding of social‐ecological systems understood as complex adaptive systemsPeople and Nature, 2020
- Cultural group selection and the design of REDD+: insights from PembaSustainability Science, 2017
- Coevolution of farming and private property during the early HoloceneProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2013
- 1 Common Property Resources: Economic Analytics2008
- The Coevolution of Parochial Altruism and WarScience, 2007
- Multilevel Selection and the Major Transitions in EvolutionPhilosophy of Science, 2005
- Regulation and Evolution of Compliance in Common Pool ResourcesThe Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 2005
- Does “Participation” in Common Pool Resource Management Help the Poor? A Social Cost–Benefit Analysis of Joint Forest Management in Jharkhand, IndiaWorld Development, 2002
- The Evolutionary Theory of Land Rights as Applied to Sub‐Saharan Africa: A Critical AssessmentDevelopment and Change, 1996