Jeffrey Andrews
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Jeffrey Andrews has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Monique Borgerhoff Mulder
Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology
5 shared publications Monique Borgerhoff Mulder
3 shared publications- Matt Clark
University of Sydney
2 shared publications Matthew Clark
2 shared publicationsVicken Hillis
2 shared publications- Vicken Hillis
Human-Environment Systems, Boise State University, Boise, USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 December 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 380 (1940)
Cultural transmission and market participation in a Congo Basin village
Guided by cultural evolutionary theory, this study investigates people’s economic activities in a village in the Republic of the Congo as shifting sets of traits that, at the individual level, are learnt according to their perceived advantages in relation to the current environment, but can scale up to influence population-level adaptation. Using systematic interviews (n = 181), we examine the cultural transmission pathways and social learning processes through which people integrate earning cash into subsistence strategies, and use Bayesian regression modelling to test four hypotheses around which demographic attributes are associated with greater participation in the (limited) formal wage-earning sector. We show that market integration through the sale of forest and agricultural products follows the same cultural transmission pathways and social learning processes as traditional subsistence practices themselves. In contrast, integrating the earning of cash through wage labour requires non-local pathways and disembedded, higher-cost social learning. Also, males and migrants to the village were more likely to engage in wage labour. We conclude that a mixed economy seems sustainable at the study village, but that integration of the wage-labour market can lead to economic inequality resulting from fundamental cultural evolutionary properties of globalization. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Transforming cultural evolution research and its application to global futures’.
- 4 December 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 380 (1940)
Open AccessCultural transmission and market participation in a Congo Basin village
Guided by cultural evolutionary theory, this study investigates people’s economic activities in a village in the Republic of the Congo as shifting sets of traits that, at the individual level, are learnt according to their perceived advantages in relation to the current environment, but can scale up to influence population-level adaptation. Using systematic interviews (n = 181), we examine the cultural transmission pathways and social learning processes through which people integrate earning cash into subsistence strategies, and use Bayesian regression modelling to test four hypotheses around which demographic attributes are associated with greater participation in the (limited) formal wage-earning sector. We show that market integration through the sale of forest and agricultural products follows the same cultural transmission pathways and social learning processes as traditional subsistence practices themselves. In contrast, integrating the earning of cash through wage labour requires non-local pathways and disembedded, higher-cost social learning. Also, males and migrants to the village were more likely to engage in wage labour. We conclude that a mixed economy seems sustainable at the study village, but that integration of the wage-labour market can lead to economic inequality resulting from fundamental cultural evolutionary properties of globalization. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Transforming cultural evolution research and its application to global futures’.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Ecology and Society
- Vol. 30 (2)
Adaptive responses to inter-group competition over natural resources: the case of leakage
Policies create externalities. In conservation, one of the most common types of externalities is leakage, where damages are exported beyond a policy's jurisdictional boundaries. Although much research has measured leakage, little addresses its impact on the lives of people suffering from damages from leakage. This paper develops a comprehensive modeling framework to formalize the dynamics by which individuals and communities exposed to leakage adapt to the challenges posed. Specifically, we use a combination of bio-economic models, abatement curves, and other ethnographically informed analytic modeling to explore the types of damages caused, how communities can adapt to them, and the consequences of such adaptive processes. The theory points to critical system dynamics necessary to understand when and why leakage produces environmental and economic damage. Firstly, the kinds of damages imposed are fundamentally linked to the resource's health, the incentives of those committing leakage, labor market dynamics, and ecosystem services. Secondly, there is no silver bullet for communities adapting to leakage; adaptation is often costly, which means that stopping all the damages from leakage may be infeasible, requiring communities to make the best of a bad situation and allocate precious resources across various strategies. Finally, the strategies adopted to deal with leakage can have far-reaching negative and positive effects, potentially creating cyclical changes in resource stocks, cascades of further leakage or promoting strict property rights that reshape the social landscape.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Ecology and Society
- Vol. 30 (2)
Open AccessAdaptive responses to inter-group competition over natural resources: the case of leakage
Policies create externalities. In conservation, one of the most common types of externalities is leakage, where damages are exported beyond a policy's jurisdictional boundaries. Although much research has measured leakage, little addresses its impact on the lives of people suffering from damages from leakage. This paper develops a comprehensive modeling framework to formalize the dynamics by which individuals and communities exposed to leakage adapt to the challenges posed. Specifically, we use a combination of bio-economic models, abatement curves, and other ethnographically informed analytic modeling to explore the types of damages caused, how communities can adapt to them, and the consequences of such adaptive processes. The theory points to critical system dynamics necessary to understand when and why leakage produces environmental and economic damage. Firstly, the kinds of damages imposed are fundamentally linked to the resource's health, the incentives of those committing leakage, labor market dynamics, and ecosystem services. Secondly, there is no silver bullet for communities adapting to leakage; adaptation is often costly, which means that stopping all the damages from leakage may be infeasible, requiring communities to make the best of a bad situation and allocate precious resources across various strategies. Finally, the strategies adopted to deal with leakage can have far-reaching negative and positive effects, potentially creating cyclical changes in resource stocks, cascades of further leakage or promoting strict property rights that reshape the social landscape.
- Open Access
- 18 November 2024
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 121 (48)
Bridging theory and data: A computational workflow for cultural evolution
Cultural evolution applies evolutionary concepts and tools to explain the change of culture over time. Despite advances in both theoretical and empirical methods, the connections between cultural evolutionary theory and evidence are often vague, limiting progress. Theoretical models influence empirical research but rarely guide data collection and analysis in logical and transparent ways. Theoretical models themselves are often too abstract to apply to specific empirical contexts and guide statistical inference. To help bridge this gap, we outline a quality-assurance computational workflow that starts from generative models of empirical phenomena and logically connects statistical estimates to both theory and real-world explanatory goals. We emphasize and demonstrate validation of the workflow using synthetic data. Using the interplay between conformity, migration, and cultural diversity as a case study, we present coded and repeatable examples of directed acyclic graphs, tailored agent-based simulations, a probabilistic transmission model for longitudinal data, and an approximate Bayesian computation model for cross-sectional data. We discuss the assumptions, opportunities, and pitfalls of different approaches to generative modeling and show how each can be used to improve data analysis depending on the structure of available data and the depth of theoretical understanding. Throughout, we highlight the significance of ethnography and of collecting basic cultural and demographic information about study populations and call for more emphasis on logical and theory-driven workflows as part of science reform.
- 18 November 2024
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 121 (48)
Open AccessBridging theory and data: A computational workflow for cultural evolution
Cultural evolution applies evolutionary concepts and tools to explain the change of culture over time. Despite advances in both theoretical and empirical methods, the connections between cultural evolutionary theory and evidence are often vague, limiting progress. Theoretical models influence empirical research but rarely guide data collection and analysis in logical and transparent ways. Theoretical models themselves are often too abstract to apply to specific empirical contexts and guide statistical inference. To help bridge this gap, we outline a quality-assurance computational workflow that starts from generative models of empirical phenomena and logically connects statistical estimates to both theory and real-world explanatory goals. We emphasize and demonstrate validation of the workflow using synthetic data. Using the interplay between conformity, migration, and cultural diversity as a case study, we present coded and repeatable examples of directed acyclic graphs, tailored agent-based simulations, a probabilistic transmission model for longitudinal data, and an approximate Bayesian computation model for cross-sectional data. We discuss the assumptions, opportunities, and pitfalls of different approaches to generative modeling and show how each can be used to improve data analysis depending on the structure of available data and the depth of theoretical understanding. Throughout, we highlight the significance of ethnography and of collecting basic cultural and demographic information about study populations and call for more emphasis on logical and theory-driven workflows as part of science reform.
- Open Access
- 6 March 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Ecological Economics
- Vol. 220
The value of failure: The effect of an expired REDD+ conservation program on residents’ willingness for future participation
- 6 March 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Ecological Economics
- Vol. 220
Open AccessThe value of failure: The effect of an expired REDD+ conservation program on residents’ willingness for future participation
- Open Access
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Sustainability
- Vol. 7 (6) , 833
Author Correction: The cultural evolution of collective property rights for sustainable resource governance
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Sustainability
- Vol. 7 (6) , 833
Open AccessAuthor Correction: The cultural evolution of collective property rights for sustainable resource governance
- Open Access
- 19 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Sustainability
- Vol. 7 (4) , 404-412
The cultural evolution of collective property rights for sustainable resource governance
With commons encompassing approximately 65% of Earth’s surface and vast tracts of the ocean, a critical challenge for sustainability involves establishing effective institutions for governing these common-pool resources (CPR). While examples of successful governance exist, the circumstances and mechanisms behind their development have often faded from historical records and memories. Drawing on ethnographic work, we introduce a generic evolutionary multigroup modelling framework that examines the emergence, stability and temporal dynamics of collective property rights. Our research reveals a fundamental insight: when intergroup conflicts over resources exist, establishing and enforcing ‘access rights’ becomes an essential prerequisite for evolving sustainable ‘use rights’. These access rights, in turn, enable cultural group selection and facilitate the evolution of sustainable use rights through the imitation of successful groups. Moreover, we identify four crucial aspects within these systems: (1) seizures in CPR systems create individual-level incentives to enforce use and access rights; (2) support for collective property rights is frequency dependent and prone to oscillations; (3) the maximum sustainable yield (MSY) is a tipping point that alters the interplay between individual and group-level selection pressures; (4) success-biased social learning (imitation) of out-group members plays a vital role in spreading sustainable institutions and preventing the tragedy of the commons.
- 19 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Sustainability
- Vol. 7 (4) , 404-412
Open AccessThe cultural evolution of collective property rights for sustainable resource governance
With commons encompassing approximately 65% of Earth’s surface and vast tracts of the ocean, a critical challenge for sustainability involves establishing effective institutions for governing these common-pool resources (CPR). While examples of successful governance exist, the circumstances and mechanisms behind their development have often faded from historical records and memories. Drawing on ethnographic work, we introduce a generic evolutionary multigroup modelling framework that examines the emergence, stability and temporal dynamics of collective property rights. Our research reveals a fundamental insight: when intergroup conflicts over resources exist, establishing and enforcing ‘access rights’ becomes an essential prerequisite for evolving sustainable ‘use rights’. These access rights, in turn, enable cultural group selection and facilitate the evolution of sustainable use rights through the imitation of successful groups. Moreover, we identify four crucial aspects within these systems: (1) seizures in CPR systems create individual-level incentives to enforce use and access rights; (2) support for collective property rights is frequency dependent and prone to oscillations; (3) the maximum sustainable yield (MSY) is a tipping point that alters the interplay between individual and group-level selection pressures; (4) success-biased social learning (imitation) of out-group members plays a vital role in spreading sustainable institutions and preventing the tragedy of the commons.
- Open Access
- 11 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
The interdependence of relational and material wealth inequality in Pemba, Zanzibar
The extent of inequality in material wealth across different types of societies is wellestablished. Less clear, however, is how material wealth is associated with relationalwealth, and the implications of such associations for material wealth inequality. Theory and evidence suggest that material wealth both guides, and is patterned by, relational wealth. While existing comparative studies typically assume complementarity between different types of wealth, such associations may differ for distinct kinds of relational wealth. Here, we first review the literature to identify how and why different forms of relational wealth may align. We then turn to an analysis of household-level social networks (food sharing, gender-specific friendship and gender-specific co-working networks) and material wealth data from a rural community in Pemba, Zanzibar. We find that (a) the materially wealthy have most relational ties, (b) the associations between relational and material wealth—as well as relational wealth more generally—are patterned by gender differences, and (c) different forms of relational wealth have similar structural properties and are closely aligned. More broadly, we show how examining the patterning of distinct types of relational wealth provides insights into how and why inequality in material wealth remains muted in a community undergoing rapid economic change.
- 11 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessThe interdependence of relational and material wealth inequality in Pemba, Zanzibar
The extent of inequality in material wealth across different types of societies is wellestablished. Less clear, however, is how material wealth is associated with relationalwealth, and the implications of such associations for material wealth inequality. Theory and evidence suggest that material wealth both guides, and is patterned by, relational wealth. While existing comparative studies typically assume complementarity between different types of wealth, such associations may differ for distinct kinds of relational wealth. Here, we first review the literature to identify how and why different forms of relational wealth may align. We then turn to an analysis of household-level social networks (food sharing, gender-specific friendship and gender-specific co-working networks) and material wealth data from a rural community in Pemba, Zanzibar. We find that (a) the materially wealthy have most relational ties, (b) the associations between relational and material wealth—as well as relational wealth more generally—are patterned by gender differences, and (c) different forms of relational wealth have similar structural properties and are closely aligned. More broadly, we show how examining the patterning of distinct types of relational wealth provides insights into how and why inequality in material wealth remains muted in a community undergoing rapid economic change.
- Open Access
- 5 January 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Evolving Ostrom’s first principle: The dynamic evolution of common property rights and their role in resource management
When and how can collective property rights evolve to effectively manage otherwise open access resources? We introduce a generic but formal modelling framework that explores under what conditions collective property rights over natural resources emerge, the causal mechanisms through which such rights aid in sustainability and the challenges that groups face in maintaining them. Our focus is on both the origins of collective property rights, and the co-evolutionary interactions driving their emergence and stabilization. Results suggest that, in the presence of inter-group conflict over resources, groups must establish and enforce rules regarding access and exclusion before implementing effective internal management. This is because when groups lack boundaries, inter-group conflict erodes surplus gains and impairs groups' ability to identify sustainable management targets. We compare these theoretical insights with empirical data from Pemba, Tanzania on the relationship between inter-group conflicts, and investments in boundaries and internal management. We find that inter-group conflict is positively correlated with support for boundaries but negatively correlated with investment in tree planting activities, supporting our theoretical insights on the evolutionary drivers of collective property rights when borders are porous. We discuss these results in the context of strategies to overcome collective action dilemmas and connections to cultural multi-level selection.
- 5 January 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessEvolving Ostrom’s first principle: The dynamic evolution of common property rights and their role in resource management
When and how can collective property rights evolve to effectively manage otherwise open access resources? We introduce a generic but formal modelling framework that explores under what conditions collective property rights over natural resources emerge, the causal mechanisms through which such rights aid in sustainability and the challenges that groups face in maintaining them. Our focus is on both the origins of collective property rights, and the co-evolutionary interactions driving their emergence and stabilization. Results suggest that, in the presence of inter-group conflict over resources, groups must establish and enforce rules regarding access and exclusion before implementing effective internal management. This is because when groups lack boundaries, inter-group conflict erodes surplus gains and impairs groups' ability to identify sustainable management targets. We compare these theoretical insights with empirical data from Pemba, Tanzania on the relationship between inter-group conflicts, and investments in boundaries and internal management. We find that inter-group conflict is positively correlated with support for boundaries but negatively correlated with investment in tree planting activities, supporting our theoretical insights on the evolutionary drivers of collective property rights when borders are porous. We discuss these results in the context of strategies to overcome collective action dilemmas and connections to cultural multi-level selection.
- Open Access
- 16 February 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Forest Income and Livelihoods on Pemba: A Quantitative Ethnography
This paper offers a systematic approach to quantifying the socio-economic role of forests for 'forest-dependent' communities. Focusing on the island of Pemba (Zanzibar, Tanzania), we investigate how forest income contributes to livelihood portfolios, local inequality, and households' insurance against shocks. We also examine how forest income is affected by local institutions and household socio-demographics. We use a series of non-parametric measures in conjunction with multi-level Bayesian models supported by directed acyclic graphs to address these questions. On average, we find that 27% of household income comes from forests, with 83% of that value deriving from fuel products, and that 62% of the total value of forest products are harvested from the agroforestry scrub matrix. At the same time, forest income scales positively with income, forest-dependency scales negatively. Top income earners control ~4 times more forest income than low earners. However, when we consider forestry against other economic sectors, forest income reduces overall income inequality on the island. Despite forests being critical for the poor, we find it offers little insurance against shocks, especially for the vulnerable. In fact, in contrast to expectations, we find that the well-insured are the most likely to increase forest use in response to shocks. Regarding institutions, most forest products come from either government land or land owned by other private individuals, indicating weak tenure institutions on the island. Finally, young, poorly educated male-headed households, which are not integrated into markets, are the most likely to have high forest income. However, female-headed households are generally more dependent due to a lack of alternative income sources. Our results are encouraging as the use of tools from formal causal inference and detailed Bayesian modelling, in conjunction with a quantitative ethnography, build upon previous findings while improving our understanding of local socio-ecological systems.
- 16 February 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessForest Income and Livelihoods on Pemba: A Quantitative Ethnography
This paper offers a systematic approach to quantifying the socio-economic role of forests for 'forest-dependent' communities. Focusing on the island of Pemba (Zanzibar, Tanzania), we investigate how forest income contributes to livelihood portfolios, local inequality, and households' insurance against shocks. We also examine how forest income is affected by local institutions and household socio-demographics. We use a series of non-parametric measures in conjunction with multi-level Bayesian models supported by directed acyclic graphs to address these questions. On average, we find that 27% of household income comes from forests, with 83% of that value deriving from fuel products, and that 62% of the total value of forest products are harvested from the agroforestry scrub matrix. At the same time, forest income scales positively with income, forest-dependency scales negatively. Top income earners control ~4 times more forest income than low earners. However, when we consider forestry against other economic sectors, forest income reduces overall income inequality on the island. Despite forests being critical for the poor, we find it offers little insurance against shocks, especially for the vulnerable. In fact, in contrast to expectations, we find that the well-insured are the most likely to increase forest use in response to shocks. Regarding institutions, most forest products come from either government land or land owned by other private individuals, indicating weak tenure institutions on the island. Finally, young, poorly educated male-headed households, which are not integrated into markets, are the most likely to have high forest income. However, female-headed households are generally more dependent due to a lack of alternative income sources. Our results are encouraging as the use of tools from formal causal inference and detailed Bayesian modelling, in conjunction with a quantitative ethnography, build upon previous findings while improving our understanding of local socio-ecological systems.
- Open Access
- 21 April 2020
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Oryx
- Vol. 55 (5) , 725-731
Does REDD+ have a chance? Implications from Pemba, Tanzania
Conservation scientists continue to debate the strengths and weaknesses of REDD+ as an instrument to slow greenhouse gas emissions in the developing world. We propose that general positions on this debate are less helpful than drawing lessons from specific investigations into the features of individual projects that make them successful or not. Here, focusing on a site-specific REDD+ intervention in Pemba, Zanzibar (Tanzania), we examine the circumstances under which REDD+ has a chance of success, teasing out specific features of both REDD+ interventions and the socio-economic and institutional contexts that render REDD+ a potentially valuable complement to community forestry. Additionally, we highlight some unanticipated positive outcomes associated with the design features of REDD+ projects. Our broader goal is to move away from ideologically-driven debate to empirically-based identification of general conditions where REDD+ could work, and to provide policy recommendations.
- 21 April 2020
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Oryx
- Vol. 55 (5) , 725-731
Open AccessDoes REDD+ have a chance? Implications from Pemba, Tanzania
Conservation scientists continue to debate the strengths and weaknesses of REDD+ as an instrument to slow greenhouse gas emissions in the developing world. We propose that general positions on this debate are less helpful than drawing lessons from specific investigations into the features of individual projects that make them successful or not. Here, focusing on a site-specific REDD+ intervention in Pemba, Zanzibar (Tanzania), we examine the circumstances under which REDD+ has a chance of success, teasing out specific features of both REDD+ interventions and the socio-economic and institutional contexts that render REDD+ a potentially valuable complement to community forestry. Additionally, we highlight some unanticipated positive outcomes associated with the design features of REDD+ projects. Our broader goal is to move away from ideologically-driven debate to empirically-based identification of general conditions where REDD+ could work, and to provide policy recommendations.