Caster Semenya, athlete classification, and fair equality of opportunity in sport
Open Access
- 20 July 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 46 (9) , 584-590
Abstract
According to the Differences of Sex Development (DSD) Regulations of the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF), Caster Semenya and other athletes with heightened testosterone levels are considered non-eligible for middle distance running races in the women’s class. Based on an analysis of fair equality of opportunity in sport, I take a critical look at the Semenya case and at IAAF’s DSD Regulations. I distinguish between what I call stable and dynamic inequalities between athletes. Stable inequalities are those that athletes cannot impact or control in any significant way such as inequalities in biological sex, body size and chronological age. Dynamic inequalities, such as inequalities in strength, speed and endurance, or in technical and tactical skills, can be impacted and to a certain extent controlled by athletes. If stable inequalities exert significant and systematic impact on performance, they provide a rationale for classification. If high testosterone level is an inborn, strong and systemic driver of performance development, inequalities in such levels can provide a rationale for classification. As is emphasised by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), this leads to a dilemma of rights: the right of Semenya to compete in sport according to her legal sex and gender identity, and the right of other athletes within the average female testosterone range to compete under fair conditions. I conclude with providing conditional support of the CAS decision in the Semenya case and of IAAF’s DSD Regulations.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- In the Halfway House of Ill Repute: Gender Verification under a Different Name, Still No Contribution to Fair PlaySport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2013
- The Onus of Inclusivity: Sport Policies and the Enforcement of the Women’s Category in SportJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2013
- Genomics of elite sporting performance: what little we know and necessary advancesBritish Journal of Sports Medicine, 2013
- Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female AthletesThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2012
- Gender Verification and Gender Policies in Elite SportJournal of Sport and Social Issues, 2011
- International Paralympic Committee position stand—background and scientific principles of classification in Paralympic sportBritish Journal of Sports Medicine, 2009
- Transsexuals in Sport–Fairness and Freedom, Regulation and LawSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2008
- Deserving to Be Lucky: Reflections on the Role of Luck and Desert in SportsJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2007
- Olympic Sport and the Ideal of Sustainable DevelopmentJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2006
- Where's the Merit if the Best Man Wins?Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 1999