Time Efficiency and Performance of Single-Use vs Reusable Cystoscopes: A Randomized Benchtop and Simulated Clinical Assessment
Authors:
- Ricky ChenRCRicky Chen
- Catalina BaasCBCatalina Baas
- Ala'A FarkouhAFAla'A Farkouh
- Kanha SheteKSKanha Shete
- Daniel R. PeveriniDPDaniel R. Peverini
- John C. HartmanJHJohn C. Hartman
- Akin S. AmasyaliAAAkin S. Amasyali
- Joshua D BelleJBJoshua D Belle
- Elizabeth A. BaldwinEBElizabeth A. Baldwin
- D. Duane BaldwinDBD. Duane Baldwin
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Endourology
- Vol. 38 (1) , 53-59
Abstract
Introduction A flexible cystoscope is an indispensable tool for urologists, facilitating a variety of procedures in both the operating room and at bedside. Single-use cystoscopes offer benefits including accessibility and decreased burden for reprocessing. The aims of this study were to compare time efficiency and performance of single-use and reusable cystoscopes. Methods Ten new AmbuⓇ aScopeTM 4 Cysto single-use and two Olympus CYF-5 reusable cystoscopes were compared in simulated bedside cystoscopy and benchtop testing. Ten urologists performed simulated cystoscopy using both cystoscopes in a randomized order. Times for supply-gathering, setup, cystoscopy, cleanup, and cumulative time were recorded, followed by a Likert feedback survey. For benchtop assessment, physical, optical, and functional specifications were assessed and compared between cystoscopes. Results The single-use cystoscope demonstrated shorter supply-gathering, setup, cleanup, and cumulative times (824 vs 1231s; p<0.05) but a comparable cystoscopy time to the reusable cystoscope (202 vs 212s; p=0.322). The single-use cystoscope had a higher image resolution but a narrower field of view. Upward deflection was greater for the single-use cystoscope (214.50° vs 199.45°; p<0.001) but required greater force (2.5x). Working channel diameter and irrigation rate were greater in the reusable cystoscope. While the single-use cystoscope lacked tumor enhancing optical features, it had higher Likert scale scores for Time Efficiency and Overall Satisfaction. Conclusion The single-use cystoscope demonstrates comparable benchtop performance and superior time efficiency compared to reusable cystoscopes. However, the reusable cystoscope has superior optical versatility and flow rate. Knowledge of these differences allow for optimal cystoscope selection based on procedure indication.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- In Vitro Evaluation of Single-Use Digital Flexible Ureteroscopes: A Practical Comparison for a Patient-Centered ApproachJournal of Endourology, 2018
- First clinical evaluation of a new single-use flexible cystoscope dedicated to double-J stent removal (Isiris™): a European prospective multicenter studyWorld Journal of Urology, 2016
- The new grasper-integrated single use flexible cystoscope for double J stent removal: evaluation of image quality, flow and flexibilityWorld Journal of Urology, 2016
- Multimodal 3D cancer-mimicking optical phantomBiomedical Optics Express, 2016
- Infectious diseases linked to cross-contamination of flexible endoscopesEndoscopy International Open, 2015
- Three-dimensional, distendable bladder phantom for optical coherence tomography and white light cystoscopyJournal of Biomedical Optics, 2014
- Eco-efficiency of disposable and reusable surgical instruments—a scissors caseThe International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2013
- Two centuries of cystoscopy: the development of imaging, instrumentation and synergistic technologiesBJU International, 2008
- Quantitative assessment of degradation of the optical quality of rigid endoscopes in clinical practice2008
- Bare Naked Baskets: Ureteroscope Deflection and Flow Characteristics With Intact and Disassembled Ureteroscopic Nitinol Stone BasketsJournal of Urology, 2002